• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

This just IN. You heard it here first. Burke is one of four teams in the running. Here is the final offer from the Toronto Maple Leafs; Schenn, Kadri and our first round draft pick. AND so far, Anaheim, is sifting through three other offers.

Plus, Calgary is very much into getting a package for Iginla, but WE knew that or suspected it.

So there ya go.
 
I don't mind losing Schenn.

Kadri would be a tough pill to swallow, but I'm not surprised Burke is dealing Kadri ... the writing's on the wall. I guess it's a LITTLE easier to take with Colborne here, and playing well.

1st round pick ... the way we've played the first 30 games is gonna be a 20ish pick, so it's not bad.

I'd much rather have Anaheim throw in their 2nd ... or a mid-tier prospect. But that's not gonna be a deal breaker.
 
would be an overpayment, but that is more than likely going to be what it takes to get a 24 year old former 2nd over all pick that has put up good to dominating numbers at every level.
 
They will after the Habs beat them tonight.

I don't really know if I'd call that an overpayment.

I mean, was Kessel an overpayment? Doesn't look so bad afterall.

Like Kessel, Ryan's established at a very young age, and he's still youngish, and may still fulfill his potential - as early as next season.

I also think Ryan, being an american kid from Jersey, who has a pertty loud personality too, would do well in a market like Toronto.

And he's a player Burke's always loved ... as long as the feelng is somewhat mutual, I'm sure he'll try his very best in TO too.
 
Well the Schenn+Kadri+1st is IMO substantially more than the 1st, 1st, 2nd that we paid for Kessel.

The situations were different though because Boston was being forced to trade Kessel.
 
You win the trade if you get the best player. The big question with hypothetical deal teeds is proposing is: will Ryan ever develop into more than a 30/60 guy in a typical season? And does Kadri have what it takes to score 70-80 points at the NHL level?

With the subtraction of Schenn, our defense would also be getting to be a bit on the soft side, barring a return to form from Keith Aulie and/or Mike Komisarek.
 
There was a post I read early this morning from some reporter named Garth something who posted the same thing Teeds... but instead said it was a second...

Here is the post...

Here's what I've heard.



Toronto:



Brian Burke drafted Ryan when he was the GM in Anaheim. Brian Burke knows this player intimately, having seen the kid star at Owen Sound, at AHL Portland, and at the Olympics with Team USA. Ryan is American, and we all know how much that means to Brian Burke and Ron Wilson.



Burke has had a great relationship with Murray for years, in fact, the Leaafs GM fleeced the Ducks last season by trading Francois Beauchemin for young D stud, Jake Gardiner. Burke knows the prospects in Anaheim like the back of his hand and that why he is in the cat bird's seat for Ryan. Burke knows his true value, and is willing to pony up a thick package for Ryan's services. I've heard that Burke may be offerring D Luke Schenn, F prospect Nazim Kadri and a second, rounder in this year's draft.




Boston:




Peter Chiarelli loves the size and skill that Ryan brings to the rink.



It would take a trade of Nathan Horton, D prospect Dougie Hamilton (6'5 230), and a second rounder to Anaheim to land Ryan in Beantown. If not Horton, then David Krejci may be considered. One thing is for certain: the Bruins will not part with Seguin, Bergeron, or Lucic.



Whether Chiarelli would do this deal, no one knows.




The Leafs and Bruins kick off a huge home and home series tonight in Toronto. The scouts who were in Buffalo last night will also be at the ACC tonight, and will also travel to Boston for Saturday night's tilt between the Buds and B's. The Marlies play at Grand Rapids on Thursday night. One predicts that the scouts will be there too.



From that Garth dude.
 
This just IN. You heard it here first. Burke is one of four teams in the running. Here is the final offer from the Toronto Maple Leafs; Schenn, Kadri and our first round draft pick. AND so far, Anaheim, is sifting through three other offers.

Plus, Calgary is very much into getting a package for Iginla, but WE knew that or suspected it.

So there ya go.

It's a lot to pay, and it's also not getting us the center we need.

But I think Burke assigns almost negative value to Kadri, considers the 1st to be a 2nd, and can live without Schenn.

I probably agree with all that, but like Schenn a fair amount more.

Ryan's not a center, but I'd do that deal if it was on the table. I just don't like that it means Kuly or Mac get bumped down a line.
 
And now that I put it that way, do we really want to pay that much for a guy who will be a second line winger for us?
Dude, when our #1 and #2 wingers are the right and left wingers on our first line and also happen to be first and second in the league in scoring, by definition it's impossible to find any winger in the league that wouldn't be a second line winger for us.
 
i guess picking up mogilny was a bad idea since, after all, he was only a 3rd line winger for most of his time with the leafs...
 
I think Luke Schenn + a draft pick should be a good enough offer. Luke Schenn is an absolute gem of a hockey player. As much as I like Bobby Ryan and trust me I do, parting with Schenn and Kadri in the same deal would be a devastating blow. I wouldn't mind trading a package surrounding Kuly, Grabo, Aulie, Bozak, Biggs, Percy or even Colborne + picks.
 
Schenn, Kadri + a 1st rounder is IMO too steep a price to pay. Again, it depends on how high you rank Ryan. Schenn and Kadri without the first rounder would still be for me a tough trade to make.
 
Lupul - Bozak - Kessel
MacArthur - Connolly - Ryan
Kulemin - Colborne - Crabb
Brown - Steckel - Rosehill/Orr

Phaneuf - Gunnarsson
Liles - Komisarek
Gardiner - Aulie/Franson

Reimer
Scrivens
 
My MLSE contacts think Schenn is once again climbing the ladder again this year and are singing his praises, whereas earlier this year, they weren't so happy.

And they think Kadri is NOT an NHL hockey player.

ME? The complete opposite and I am appalled at the prospect of giving him up. I think that his HEART/Ego and Pride are what drive him, and if traded will try even harder, just to make Burke cough up his chips at the mention of his name.

I think Kadri believes he is better than anyone on the Maple Leaf roster, and unfortunately it might show up a bit in his personality.

Guess I can relate to him, but one day, he just might be able to say that.
 
Dude, when our #1 and #2 wingers are the right and left wingers on our first line and also happen to be first and second in the league in scoring, by definition it's impossible to find any winger in the league that wouldn't be a second line winger for us.

That's exactly my point. In making this trade, we would in effect simply be marginally upgrading on our second line, which would relatively substantially upgrade our third line also if Kulemin or Mac moves down.

But we're not improving the area in which we need improving most. And if those assets or slightly more can be used to get a center like Staal, then that's their best use, not in a trade for Ryan.
 
Schenn, Kadri + a 1st rounder is IMO too steep a price to pay. Again, it depends on how high you rank Ryan. Schenn and Kadri without the first rounder would still be for me a tough trade to make.

I love Ryan as a prospect, and have high hopes for Schenn, but I think it's in the realm of fair.

It comes down to how much you value Kadri, I think. No one is going to cry over a late 1st, we all more or less like Schenn, but the wildcard is Kadri. If you aren't high on him, you like the deal. If you are, you don't.
 
Back
Top