• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Posted by Zeke in GDT:

Report from @JohnBorukCSN saying bobby ryan trade is imminent. Could be an interesting night. Ducks play @ 10 et.
darenmillard 5 mins
more retweet favorite reply
 
There is nothing the Rags could offer that the Leafs couldn't beat if they wanted to. Kreider, Del Zotto, Anisimov, Stepan, Dubinsky.
 
Would you do Kulemin straight up for Ryan, LoF?

I know you're asking because you know what I'm going to say and are ready to call me crazy, but no, I honestly don't right now.

I see Kulemin as a complete player in every sense. I've never seen such effort and forechecking, the guy strips pucks off players and wins board battles like it's nobody's business. He skates like the wind and is strong as an ox. He's defensively responsible. And he has a really hard shot and a good scoring touch. This 20 game slump notwithstanding, I see 35 - 40 goal power in him with the right center.

Now, I see Ryan as an amazing talent too, with probably a higher ceiling as an offensive player, but not as complete a player.

That's my honest answer. Flame away.
 
There is nothing the Rags could offer that the Leafs couldn't beat if they wanted to. Kreider, Del Zotto, Anisimov, Stepan, Dubinsky.

We also said the Leafs would be able to beat any offer for Brad Richards and would get him, but they obviously didn't want to.
 
If we were to deal for Ryan, Kulemin becomes our 5th best winger. We're not maximizing his value to the club on the 3rd line, but Ryan would be a significant upgrade. Kulemin should be part of the package just on roster requirements alone.
 
If we were to deal for Ryan, Kulemin becomes our 5th best winger. We're not maximizing his value to the club on the 3rd line, but Ryan would be a significant upgrade. Kulemin should be part of the package just on roster requirements alone.

Totally disagree.

If you can have Kulemin or MacArthur as a winger on your third line, you're a ****ing deep team. There's no roster requirement to get rid of one if Ryan is better.

It's not a significant upgrade. It may not even be an upgrade.

You trade your surplus in a deal for Ryan. Guys who aren't on the team (Kadri) and guys who might be overpaid/overvalued (arguably Schenn). Not key pieces.
 
Totally disagree.

If you can have Kulemin or MacArthur as a winger on your third line, you're a ****ing deep team. There's no roster requirement to get rid of one if Ryan is better.

There's no requirement of course, but if you have a choice between trading a young centre, or young winger, trade the winger. And that's assuming equal ability/potential.

It's not a significant upgrade. It may not even be an upgrade.

Monstrous bias

You trade your surplus in a deal for Ryan. Guys who aren't on the team (Kadri) and guys who might be overpaid/overvalued (arguably Schenn). Not key pieces.

Your key piece has 2 goals in 24 games, and is looking a lot like a one hit wonder.
 
That would be a ridiculously deep team:

Lupul - Bozak - Kessel
Ryan - Connolly - MacArthur
Kulemin - Grabovski - Armstrong
Steckel - Colborne - Brown

I like that. ALOT.
 
Back
Top