• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

And I get the impression he is undergoing a real tough time, as Murray wants Gardiner BACK for any of Ryan, Perry or Getzlaf and that is KILLING Burke, but he MAY do it.

Understand THIS, if we get one of the Anaheim three we could lose the best Leaf defence prospect of the last fifty years.
 
Burke would LOVE to get bigger up front. And NOT interested in a goalie,NOT according to my sources. He offered a second rounder for Josh Harding and was politely told to try and do something physically impossible.
Are your sources from the article directly above your post stating the exact same thing?

My sources told me that your sources state the exact same thing. Also, my sources told me that Getzlaf is in getting his calves measured, just in case.
 
Are your sources from the article directly above your post stating the exact same thing?

My sources told me that your sources state the exact same thing. Also, my sources told me that Getzlaf is in getting his calves measured, just in case.

Teed's sources do not know what a NMC is. Enough said.
 
I'd bet we would have to part with Scrivens as part of any deal with Anaheim

Yeah Scrivens would have to be in it ( or whatever goalie in the leafs system Murray liked best), as would Schenn.

That would address 2 of the Ducks glaring holes.

add in one of Kulemin/Grabovksi, and one of Colborne/Kadri....i think Anaheim looks into it
 
And I get the impression he is undergoing a real tough time, as Murray wants Gardiner BACK for any of Ryan, Perry or Getzlaf and that is KILLING Burke, but he MAY do it.

Understand THIS, if we get one of the Anaheim three we could lose the best Leaf defence prospect of the last fifty years.

okay but...is the spit on the hand?
 
And I get the impression he is undergoing a real tough time, as Murray wants Gardiner BACK for any of Ryan, Perry or Getzlaf and that is KILLING Burke, but he MAY do it.

Understand THIS, if we get one of the Anaheim three we could lose the best Leaf defence prospect of the last fifty years.

Ian Turnbull? Jim Benning?
 
aliafrate0111b.jpg
 
@Teeds- I think your extremely overrating Gardiner, sure he has a lot of potential, he'll likley be a solid top 4 guy both now and in the future, its even possible he is the best defencmen prospect in 15 years, but 50 years? Thats a huge stretch....

However if I'm Burke and Murray wants Gardiner in a package deal for Getzlaf I wouldnt do it, even though it would be a fair trade. The leafs problem isnt a lack of scoring, its that they have a history of lacking mobile puckmoving guys from the backend, Burke prides himself on this leafs team being an aggressive puck-pursuing team, well you cant be successful in that area unless you have mobility from the back end.
 
Gardiner is a fantastic skater, but I've yet to see the puck skills and offensive IQ of an elite defender in him. He actually reminds me a lot of Brett Hedican. A big, very good skating puck moving top 4 defender who never lived up to his offensive potential...mainly because most of it was based on the fact that he was an awesome skater.

I hope I'm wrong, and Gardiner is already a good NHL defender and looks a lock to be a legit top 4 guy...I just don't know where his offense is going to come from.
 
For instance...for all the talk of how limited Schenn's offensive upside is, he's only 6 months older and in 4 minutes less a game has 12 points to Gardiner's 10.
 
Gardiner is a fantastic skater, but I've yet to see the puck skills and offensive IQ of an elite defender in him. He actually reminds me a lot of Brett Hedican. A big, very good skating puck moving top 4 defender who never lived up to his offensive potential...mainly because most of it was based on the fact that he was an awesome skater.

I hope I'm wrong, and Gardiner is already a good NHL defender and looks a lock to be a legit top 4 guy...I just don't know where his offense is going to come from.


I agree. By now you want to have seen a few more crazy dekes or blistering slapshots from him to have hope of him being a top-notch offensive quarterback.
 
For instance...for all the talk of how limited Schenn's offensive upside is, he's only 6 months older and in 4 minutes less a game has 12 points to Gardiner's 10.

Age is misleading here, what needs to be strongly considered is experience- In Schenns case he has 3 years under his belt (4 if you include this season), Gardiner on the other hand only has half a season under his belt (if your including this season) it would be expected that Schenns offensive numbers in his 4th season are higher then Gardiners in his 1st year.

Gardiner is on pace for 20 points in his rookie season, while its not great, its not horrible by any stretch either. Given time/experience and also gains in strength Gardiner could very easily be a 45-55 point defencmen in this league, if not with the leafs then with another team.
 
Age is misleading here, what needs to be strongly considered is experience- In Schenns case he has 3 years under his belt (4 if you include this season), Gardiner on the other hand only has half a season under his belt (if your including this season) it would be expected that Schenns offensive numbers in his 4th season are higher then Gardiners in his 1st year.

Gardiner is on pace for 20 points in his rookie season, while its not great, its not horrible by any stretch either. Given time/experience and also gains in strength Gardiner could very easily be a 45-55 point defencmen in this league, if not with the leafs then with another team.


Well, age is always important, for a similar reason to experience. My point was, that if a guy with such a seemingly pedestrian offensive upside is out producing him at a similar age, it's not exactly encouraging.

FWIW, Schenn as a 19 yr old rookie, put up a similar PPG (.20) to Gardiner's so far this season (.27)
 
The thing about Gardiner is he has only been playing defense for a few years. I disagree that we haven't seen good puck skills and offensive IQ from him. We've seen some slick passing and puck handling skills and playmaking ability.

But he certainly isn't anywhere near as developed as most 21 year old dmen are in terms of knowing how to create offense from the blueline. He's just starting to scratch the surface there.
 
Back
Top