• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

The guy is sublime. I want Getzlaf IF Gustavsson is sorta for real. But I do not want to give up Gardiner. He is the best LEAF defence prospect I have ever seen. Much, much better than Ian dumb as a fencepost Turnbull. No comparison. And Iafrate was just too whacked. Gardiner has a serious head on his shoulders.

But yeah, he has not given the average bear a lot of offensive indictions. I have seen some though.

I think he was all about NOT playing for the Marlies this year. Next year I expect and anticipate some sick dekes. And his shot is better than Schenn's,but I want BOTH to improve significantly. Neither will be mistaken for Franson.
 
The guy is sublime. I want Getzlaf IF Gustavsson is sorta for real. But I do not want to give up Gardiner. He is the best LEAF defence prospect I have ever seen. Much, much better than Ian dumb as a fencepost Turnbull. No comparison. And Iafrate was just too whacked. Gardiner has a serious head on his shoulders.

But yeah, he has not given the average bear a lot of offensive indictions. I have seen some though.

I think he was all about NOT playing for the Marlies this year. Next year I expect and anticipate some sick dekes. And his shot is better than Schenn's,but I want BOTH to improve significantly. Neither will be mistaken for Franson.

When Jake Gardiner scores five goals in a game and puts up an 80 point season while getting consideration for the year-end all-star team like Turnbull, then you reserve the right to make disparaging remarks about him. Until then, zip it.
 
Gardiner is a fantastic skater, but I've yet to see the puck skills and offensive IQ of an elite defender in him. He actually reminds me a lot of Brett Hedican. A big, very good skating puck moving top 4 defender who never lived up to his offensive potential...mainly because most of it was based on the fact that he was an awesome skater.

I hope I'm wrong, and Gardiner is already a good NHL defender and looks a lock to be a legit top 4 guy...I just don't know where his offense is going to come from.

Holy smokes...you took the words right out of my mouth. Hedican was exactly the player I had in mind. Of course, Gardiner needs to become a lot better/more consistent defensively for the comparison to be valid.

Thank you for your REALIST fan perspective. Gardiner should be a good one, but he isn't the Calder nominee/potential star many here make him out to be. Truth be told, he's one of the most overhyped Leaf prospects in a long time.
 
When Jake Gardiner scores five goals in a game and puts up an 80 point season while getting consideration for the year-end all-star team like Turnbull, then you reserve the right to make disparaging remarks about him. Until then, zip it.

:worshippy:

You deserve an Orson Wells clap for that statement but I am on my I-Pod and do not have access to it.
 
I loved Ian Turnbull...but he was dumb lol.
I saw his five-goal performance, I remember him putting a puck right through the net one night, and he's a great hockey trivia answer (who was the only Leaf to record a point without Darryl Sittler's involvement in his historic ten-point night?)...but even as a young kid I remember him as a bit of an oafish type.
He kind of scared me the one time I saw him up close.

...but don't let that stop you from telling teeds how it is. :smilewinkgrin:
 
I'm not sure either way about Gardiner, but it's interesting that Eakins questioned how offensively potent Gardiner would be in the NHL.
 
To be fair, Eakins hasn't seen a lot of Gardiner. He only had him for 10 games at the end of last season. And the point that was raised earlier about Gardiner only having moved to defense pretty recently is a valid one. I'd imagine most NHLers have been playing their position for at least 6-7 years by the time they get drafted. He's still got a lot to learn.
 
Sure, but switching from forward to defence shouldn't mess with the development of your offensive abilities. He's obviously grown into the defensive side of the game very quickly, as he's already very good at it.
 
Sure, but switching from forward to defence shouldn't mess with the development of your offensive abilities. He's obviously grown into the defensive side of the game very quickly, as he's already very good at it.

Increased emphasis on the defensive side could very well hamper your offensive development.

Changing positions (especially from forward to defence) is not an easy transition and your focus really has to be to take care of your own end and it may make him a bit more hesitant to be as assertive as he probably should be with all his offensive tools. Time will tell, but I think it's a bit too early to write off his offensive abilities so early.
 
it has nothing to do with focus, it's just the nature of the game.

imo he wasn't a great forward - if he was then he wouldn't have been moved to the blueline - so we aren't talking about a guy with dangles.

but there is still an enormous difference between how the game is played. D is about stretch passes, hitting your man in stride, puck retrieval. in the offensive zone you have less latitude with the puck. you aren't cycling, you aren't standing in front of the net. your offensive forays have to be measured. you're attacking more than you're creating, too.

basically, it changes how you play the game. he has to learn and adjust. so, yeah, there is definite offensive potential there.

i do agree with ME, though, that poise, vision and soft touch wtih the puck don't seem to come naturally to gardiner like they didfor, say, the 20 year old kaberle.

can he get there? yeah, but i don't think he's a total slam dunk.
 
He is too smart with the puck to NOT pick up his share of assists. Goals? I don't know, but if he starts hitting the net now and then he's bound to pop a few.
 
Kaberle only played at a low 30ish point pace in his rookie season. Gardiner isn't that far off that pace. With a strong finish, he can be in that range by the end of the season.

Count me in as a guy who believes Gardiner will be a consistent top 10 scoring dman in the NHL. His skills are just too good for it not to happen.
 
Kaberle only played at a low 30ish point pace in his rookie season. Gardiner isn't that far off that pace. With a strong finish, he can be in that range by the end of the season.

Count me in as a guy who believes Gardiner will be a consistent top 10 scoring dman in the NHL. His skills are just too good for it not to happen.

+1
 
Back
Top