• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Gardiner has been a little unlucky regarding his point total this year.

I did some digging, and Gardiner has the highest 1st assist per game average on the entire Leafs blueline (0.51 per 60 mins). So, you can make the argument that he's been directly involved in more Leafs goals than any of the other blueliners on a per minute basis.

What's hurting him is that he isn't picking up those 2nd assists, which in some cases, help to pad your stats. He averages just 0.30 2nd assists per game, which is 3rd worst on the blueline. In comparison, Schenn is averaging 0.76 2nd assists per game, but only 0.22 1st assists.

Gardiner is going to be a big time points producer imo. And that actual numbers will show that soon.
 
I should mention, those stats are for 5 on 5 only.

Gardiner ranks 21st among defensemen in 1st assists per 60 minutes played, 5 on 5 (min. 20 gms played).

But I do agree with the points brought up in the past, he's going to have to figure it out on the PP to be an elite offensive dman. Can't be good just at even strength to get there.
 
yeah, i'm not sure that statistic is at all meaningful.

I believe in most cases, the 1st assist is more meaningful in the creation of a goal, than the 2nd assist. I have no way of proving this obviously, just based on my observations.

Regardless of how many points Schenn has compared with Gardiner this year, Gardiner has been more impactful to the Leafs offense than Schenn.
 
He's shown flashes of real highend offensive skills, but nothing consistent yet. right now his offense is a big fat question mark.

But his defense and puckmoving skills aren't.
 
yeah, i'm not sure that statistic is at all meaningful.

It does go along with what i've seen, though. he's really had to earn his points this year with some great plays.....he's got almost none of the "dump the puck at the net andsee what happens" points that a guy like schenn keeps getting.
 
It does go along with what i've seen, though. he's really had to earn his points this year with some great plays.....he's got almost none of the "dump the puck at the net andsee what happens" points that a guy like schenn keeps getting.


I'm of the personal opinion that the 2nd assist is usually a product of a good simple play, putting the puck in the right direction offensively. Whether it's a good break out pass, finding the open man during offensive possession, etc.

I'm no fan of the contention that 2nd assists are "garbage" points. They're indicative of the right play being made, an important linkage from puck possession to a scoring play.
 
I think Gardiner's definitely got more to show offensively...I don't agree with Eakins there.

He's made enough great plays to suggest there are more of them to come. he doesn't seem to have the raw puck skills that a guy like Kaberle did, but few do.

maybe putting the puck on net and seeing what happens might get him a few more points.
 
5 on 5, 1st Assist Per 60 Mins (Min 20 gms)

1. Gonchar: 1.00
2. Spacek: 0.92
3. Pitkanen: 0.73
4. Colaiacovo: 0.72
5. Weber: 0.71
6. Greene: 0.69
7. Zidlicky: 0.67
8. Yandle: 0.67
9. Stattenkirk: 0.67
10. Carlson: 0.63

5 on 4, 1st Assist Per 60 Mins (Min 20 gms / Min. 2.00 PP)

1. Streit: 3.26
2. Chara: 3.10
3. E Johnson: 2.97
4. Keith: 2.73
5. Hamuis: 2.73
6. Campbell: 2.72
7. Liles: 2.46
8. Byfuglien: 2.42
9. Karlsson: 2.19
10. Ehrhoff: 2.18
 
It does go along with what i've seen, though. he's really had to earn his points this year with some great plays.....he's got almost none of the "dump the puck at the net andsee what happens" points that a guy like schenn keeps getting.

yeah, but sometimes you get those points off of simple plays because you're making the right decisions, and have the acumen to make those decisions.
 
I believe in most cases, the 1st assist is more meaningful in the creation of a goal, than the 2nd assist. I have no way of proving this obviously, just based on my observations.

generally, sure. but you're looking at it wrong. it's a really small sample. we're talking about 8 ES assists on the year.
 
JAYS, you never saw Turnbull fawking play, you gotta zip that young impestuous trap in this case. I saw him play, I have played very high end hockey, I still do, and Ian Turnbull was the OPPOSITE of Jake Gardiner.

Whereas Gardiner improves the flow of all four of his teammates on the ice, Ian Turnbull would take the puck EVERY TIME he touched it, skate energetically up the ice, NEVER PASS, until he was trapped behind the goalline of the opposing team, with two guys on him and either get stripped of the puck, or pass off to the opponent.

That he would do for 8 games out of ten, then tease you with a big game or two, making you HOPE and BELIEVE that perhaps a BRAIN had entered into that incredibly THICK HEAD of his.

I like Luke Schenn considerably more than Turnbull. Heck, I like Komisarek better than Turnbull. It amazes me that he is now an investment advisor. I bet he loses 50% a year like clockwork.

Turnbull was loathed and despised by all his teammates, management was mesmerized by his two games out of ten, and thought he would eventually skate and pass. But he never, every figured out that the other four guys on the ice, could actually help him accomplish something.

Backing up Ian Turnbull suggests one thing, you have NO CLUE about what you are talking about. His nickname behind his back was TEAM KILLER.
 
I'm of the personal opinion that the 2nd assist is usually a product of a good simple play, putting the puck in the right direction offensively. Whether it's a good break out pass, finding the open man during offensive possession, etc.

I'm no fan of the contention that 2nd assists are "garbage" points. They're indicative of the right play being made, an important linkage from puck possession to a scoring play.

as am I.

but we're talking about a very small and specific sample here, so we don't have to just dismiss the issue here because of that generality here, IMO.

I mean, most of us can probably remember every single one of Gardiner and Schenn's points this year.
 
If the rest of the league was watching our last game, Luke Schenn in my mind, played his best game as a Leaf. If he could string five or six of those in a row, it would be hard to see him go. I actually saw some Scott Stevens/Milan Lucic there. Did everything right.
 
JAYS, you never saw Turnbull fawking play, you gotta zip that young impestuous trap in this case. I saw him play, I have played very high end hockey, I still do, and Ian Turnbull was the OPPOSITE of Jake Gardiner.

You have to stop making things up.

NHL record for goals in a game by a defenceman. Single-season Leafs points record by a defenceman (more than Salming even). Top ten Norris Trophy and year-end all-star team consideration for multiple seasons.

I don't care if you played high-end hockey. That doesn't make you more of an astute talent evaluator than anyone here, and if you didn't play at least OHL hockey it's entirely irrelevant in the first place. Wayne Gretzky was arguably the greatest player of all-time and he sucked as a coach.

Whereas Gardiner improves the flow of all four of his teammates on the ice, Ian Turnbull would take the puck EVERY TIME he touched it, skate energetically up the ice, NEVER PASS, until he was trapped behind the goalline of the opposing team, with two guys on him and either get stripped of the puck, or pass off to the opponent.

That he would do for 8 games out of ten, then tease you with a big game or two, making you HOPE and BELIEVE that perhaps a BRAIN had entered into that incredibly THICK HEAD of his.

One of the elite offensive defenders in the NHL year in and year out and a career +29 rating. He must have been doing something correctly for someone who you seem to think was so heinous.

Turnbull was loathed and despised by all his teammates, management was mesmerized by his two games out of ten, and thought he would eventually skate and pass. But he never, every figured out that the other four guys on the ice, could actually help him accomplish something.

Prove it.

Backing up Ian Turnbull suggests one thing, you have NO CLUE about what you are talking about. His nickname behind his back was TEAM KILLER.

Well no, it doesn't suggest anything beyond the fact that Turnbull was in fact (along with Benning and Nylund) a more highly-regarded Leafs defence prospect than Gardiner was. Benning in particular was coming off of a season in which he scored 129 points when drafted.
 
looks like gardiner, our best skating defenseman, is sitting out tonight so that Komisarek, our slowest defenseman, can play.

against the red wings, no less.
 
Back
Top