• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

who would you trade a 22 year old solid defenseman for straight up Zeke?? JVR? Couturier? Legit question. Because I don't understand giving away a good solid player to a team that is above us in the conference, and one who we will be competing with in the forseable future for playoff spots.

We have too many dmen.

I don't see how trading Schenn for a JVR or Couturier is "giving him away".
 
We have too many dmen.

I don't see how trading Schenn for a JVR or Couturier is "giving him away".

I think that's a pretty good return. Obviously the idea of trading Schenn as part of a big package for Getzlaf appeals to me more but I doubt they even move him.

Of course, Flyers fans are saying that's not enough for one of those two.
 
I've said this before, but I saw JVR score the nicest goal I've ever seen in real life. I believe it was the 2008 WJC relegation round OT vs the Czechs.
 
I like Schenns style, but his trade value is close to an all time low, the guy is barely playing over 10 mins a game these days and has lost his top 4 spot to Komi.... yes Komi! If Burke were smart he'd hang on to Schenn for the next little bit, give him a chance to reform his play and if hes back in a top 4 spot logging close to 20 mins a game then yes trade him, but now isnt the time to pull the trigger.

All and all schenn is having a pretty good season, close to the top in hits, the 2nd best +/- on the leafs, and avg of 16 minutes of ice.
 
We have too many dmen.

I don't see how trading Schenn for a JVR or Couturier is "giving him away".

They say that the best offence is a good defense(I think thats the saying lol), defense wins championships its just that simple, its always good to have a tremendous amount of depth on the blueline. Besides, the way our defence plays there tends to be injuries, again another reason for depth on the backend. Scoring isnt our problem, but keeping goals out is, its far more beneficial to hang onto our blueliners, trading Schenn IMO wouldnt help rectify our issues.
 
They say that the best offence is a good defense(I think thats the saying lol)

The other way around. The best defense is a good offense.

If you have a great group of forwards who can maintain possession of the puck, that's less opportunity to be scored upon.
 
Getting Couturier would be a coup IMO. The guy is Jordan Staal with more talent. As a 19 year old rookie he is the Flyers best PKer up front leading the team with a 5.49 GAon/60 while playing 2:45 on the pk per game. He also leads the team in GAon/60 ES too at 1.77.

Throw on top of that elite numbers in junior, and a 15+ goal 30+ point pace playing 12 minuts a game (1/4 of which is short handed).

And with Giroux, Briere and Schenn they just might be wiling to move him. Either that, or them lucking into Couturier has led them to be willing to move Schenn.
 
Bottomline is we need another top 6 forward, and defense is a position of depth for us ... to a point Gardiner is not getting any icetime even with Liles still out because of injury.
 
Bottomline is we need another top 6 forward, and defense is a position of depth for us ... to a point Gardiner is not getting any icetime even with Liles still out because of injury.

I would say our top 6 is decent- Lupul and Kessel are elite this year, Connolly is a decent second line player, Grabo is decent as well, Kulemin while struggling has potential to be a perenial 25-30 goal player, Mac is on pace for another 50 point year. While we dont have an elite top 6, its decent nonetheless.
 
Backwards cliches aside, if you have a surplus of NHL-callibre defensemen, as the Leafs do, it makes perfect sense to improve your team elsewhere by trading one, rather than sending them to the AHL when they don't belong there, or leaving them to munch on popcorn in the press box. And even after trading one of our defensemen, we'll still be left with 7 NHL callibre defensemen, as well as a few guys down on the Marlies that'd be perfectly fine as short-term injury fill-ins (Blacker, Gysbers, Holzer).
 
I would say our top 6 is decent- Lupul and Kessel are elite this year, Connolly is a decent second line player, Grabo is decent as well, Kulemin while struggling has potential to be a perenial 25-30 goal player, Mac is on pace for another 50 point year. While we dont have an elite top 6, its decent nonetheless.
Yeah, IF Grabs and Kulemin play on 25-30G, 60-70 points pace ... which they haven't.

Connolly is a band-aid solution, and we obviously lack size in our top 6.

We should trade for a youngish top 6 with size.
 
Yeah, IF Grabs and Kulemin play on 25-30G, 60-70 points pace ... which they haven't.

Connolly is a band-aid solution, and we obviously lack size in our top 6.

We should trade for a youngish top 6 with size.

Grabo IS playing at a 30g pace this season. Kulemin has fallen off the horse this year but if he has a strong surge in the 2nd half I can see him hitting 20 goals and 45 points, and so far hes coming back to life in the 2nd half. I agree our top 6 is on the small size, but we make up for it with elite speed.
 
Maybe, but even so both Burke and Wilson have said they want a top 9, not a top 6. And right now Joey Crabb/Colby Armstrong/Matthew Lombardi are in that mix.
 
Pretty sure Burke's gonna be on the Fan at 6 this evening. I'll try to listen and give a summary.

Way too much time spent on SensFans' feeble trolling attempts on my day off. Back to Leaf talk.
 
They say that the best offence is a good defense(I think thats the saying lol), defense wins championships its just that simple, its always good to have a tremendous amount of depth on the blueline. Besides, the way our defence plays there tends to be injuries, again another reason for depth on the backend. Scoring isnt our problem, but keeping goals out is, its far more beneficial to hang onto our blueliners, trading Schenn IMO wouldnt help rectify our issues.

You said this the other day, and were promptly called out on it, and shown evidence to disprove your assertion. So I don't know why you keep repeating this expecting it to be true.

And we have too many NHL calibre blueliners currently, even with the injury to Liles. It's good asset management to use our depth, and trade from a position of strength, to address a position of relative weakness. Plus, we could use more size up front.
 
I actually like listening to Cox on radio and on TV.

I absolutely CANNOT stand Bob McCowan.

That, and the fact PTS rarely talks about hockey, and almost never talk about the Leafs unless it's in a pointless bashing format, and every hockey discussion always ends with 1 of the followings ...

1. The Leafs will not make playoff this year (and Cox will disagree, and McCowan will call him bonehead or something to end the pointless discussion)
2. NHL is a dinosaur league and an old boy's club stubborn to make any changes
3. Fighting is the root cause for concussion, depressions, suicide, and all things evil among hockey players, current or ex.

I'm not looking for a 'homer station' to listen to, but to hear day after day after day of some pointless and baseless Leafs bashing is pretty tiring ... I'd much prefer TSN Radio beceause at the very least they are more hockey-focused and they do bring in guests like Scott Morrison, Bob McKenzie, Pierre McGuire etc ...
 
I hear you number17, but I don't really understand people who complain about Bob McCowan. The guy straight up admits that he doesn't follow hockey, so why should anybody care about or be upset by anything he has to say about hockey/the Leafs? Especially now that you can change the station to TSN radio, as they have the Cybulski show and usually a lot of Leafs/NHL discussion at the same time that McCowan is blathering on about the NFL, baseball, US college sports or about how much the Leafs suck.
 
Back
Top