• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Adam Foote was Canada's worst defenceman in 2006.

Chris Pronger was also really bad.

And unless you consider 62 points per 82 games over his career to be something particularly impressive, no he doesn't.

62 points is pretty impressive. Is Mikhail Grabovski a plugger? And Bergeron's career average would likely be significantly higher if not for his concussion issues. 70+ points is his natural level.

Also, Bergeron "ended up as the 13th forward due to a groin injury obtained in Canada's first game" (from Wikipedia).
 
Lets not hate on a player who would instantly be the best centre we've had since Mats Sundin.

Patrice Bergeron would be a welcome addition to this team as a centre between Lupul and Kessel.
 
Bergeron is a damn good player and I'd like to have him on the Leafs but there's no denying he is incredibly overrated. Every so often one of those defensive specialists who provides a bit of offence becomes egregiously overinflated in terms of ability by fans.
 
Bergeron is a damn good player and I'd like to have him on the Leafs but there's no denying he is incredibly overrated. Every so often one of those defensive specialists who provides a bit of offence becomes egregiously overinflated in terms of ability by fans.

That I agree with. Bergeron is good, but he's far from the franchise player that people often peg him as.

My big issue with these overrated polls is "overrated by whom?" I mean, guys like Komi and Gomez, yes, they're "overrated" relative to their contract, or if you think they're anything more than a #6 defenseman or 12th forward. But as far as I'm aware, most people only think of them at that level. So a guy like Phaneuf, I could agree with being on the list, if you think that he's regarded as being up there with Chara and Weber.
 
If he's on his game, which he is this year, Dion is definitely up there with Weber. Chara on the other hand, I'm not sure if any defenseman is really "up there" with him. He brings a pretty unique skill set of mobility and mutant strength, size and toughness that's difficult for any other defenseman to match.

As for Bergeron, he looked like he was going to be something special early in his career until he had that severe concussion. He's never really gotten back on that track since then.
 
It's just the Maple Leaf effect. If a never-concussed, fully healthy Sidney Crosby pulled on a Leaf jersey and beat Gretzky's single-season scoring record, there would still be gnat-brained Leaf-haters lining up to call him overrated.
 
Actually, if the Leafs won that lottery, nobody would have hated Crosby. The universe would have collapsed into itself and exploded, obliterating us all.
 
As much as it pains me to say it, I was actually interested in seeing if Montreal could inch a few spots closer and possibly nab him. Not because I want the Habs to have any prolonged success over the Leafs or anything, but just for the curiosity of having a noted Habs fan his entire life playing in that market.

It would have been great for hockey in general. The sport is much healthier when teams like the Leafs, Montreal, and Chicago do well than when we suck.
 
Interesting/weird stat:

The Leafs haven't gone 4-0 after the New Year since 1962, the year they began a streak of three straight Stanley Cups. The year before, 1961, is the only other time the team has done it in the history of the club.
 
**** that, Jays. The Habs have already had far too many generational talents and Stanley Cups in their history. It was bad enough that the Pens got him when they already had Lemieux/Jagr last decade, but I'd have choked on my own bile if the Habs had nabbed him.
 
Interesting/weird stat:

The Leafs haven't gone 4-0 after the New Year since 1962, the year they began a streak of three straight Stanley Cups. The year before, 1961, is the only other time the team has done it in the history of the club.
I'd be up for another Leaf three-peat.
 
The defensive metrics all suggest that Phaneuf isn't just good...but really good defensively.


Advanced statistical metrics >>>>>>> Anonymous NHL haters
 
Back
Top