• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

It's funny how in sports the most "overrated" players in these polls all seem to play for teams based on Toronto, New York, Boston, Los Angeles, or Chicago, and never any small markets. Must be all coincidental I'm sure.
 
It's funny how in sports the most "overrated" players in these polls all seem to play for teams based on Toronto, New York, Boston, Los Angeles, or Chicago, and never any small markets. Must be all coincidental I'm sure.

Jovo's on the list... I'm completely stumped. 35 year old playing for Florida.

I saw him on the list and to be quite honest, I realized I had forgotten he was still in the league. Absolutely bizarre.
 
It's funny how in sports the most "overrated" players in these polls all seem to play for teams based on Toronto, New York, Boston, Los Angeles, or Chicago, and never any small markets. Must be all coincidental I'm sure.


The kicker is, it's usually the opposite. It's usually the guys that play in hockey backwaters that get horrendously over rated.
 
that list was kind of bizarre, what with it including guys like Jovo and gomez. these guys aren't rated by anyone anymore, let alone overrated. That poll feels like it was drawn up a full 5 years ago, to be honest.

Most overrated:

1) R.Miller
2) J.Carter
3) V.Lecavalier
4) B.Ryan
5) R.Nash
 
Nice to hear burkie talking like that about a trade.

A schenn-jvr swap would make plenty of sense for both teams - both pretty overrated top-5 picks, but both still good with good upside, and the trade would fill a need on both teams.
 
Nice to hear burkie talking like that about a trade.

A schenn-jvr swap would make plenty of sense for both teams - both pretty overrated top-5 picks, but both still good with good upside, and the trade would fill a need on both teams.

How would it help us? Were already one of the top scoring teams in the league, yet were one of the worst at giving up goals. Losing Schenn would actually set us back a bit though.
 
It would help us because replacing schenn with Komi/aulie/gardiner is no downgrade at all, but replacing lombardi with JVR is a nice upgrade.
 
Yea im with Pronger on that one. I dont see the sense in getting rid of Schenn in a deal for Van Reimsdyk. Sure he has a chance to be a nice player in the next few years but he doesnt help us now.

This team needs a centre with size.

Now Van Reimsdyk for Kadri would be interesting. Even though it still doesnt solve our issue with finding a 1st line centre.
 
It would help us because replacing schenn with Komi/aulie/gardiner is no downgrade at all, but replacing lombardi with JVR is a nice upgrade.

Schenn is a lot better then Komi and hes 7 years younger to boot, definetly not a downgrade IMO. Aullie is a tough call, because he is Schenns age but hes struggling after a solid rookie year, I think Aullie could be better defensivley (note the word "could") but Schenn is far more physical then Aullie could ever dream to be. Cant really compare Schenn to Gardiner, both bring different things to the game, Gardiner brings elite speed and above average puckmovement whereas Schenn is a steady physical stay at home blueliner. I agree JVR would be an upgrade on Lombardi, but at best it would be a wash if we give up Schenn for him.
 
that list was kind of bizarre, what with it including guys like Jovo and gomez. these guys aren't rated by anyone anymore, let alone overrated. That poll feels like it was drawn up a full 5 years ago, to be honest.

Most overrated:

1) R.Miller
2) J.Carter
3) V.Lecavalier
4) B.Ryan
5) R.Nash

So much so that I actually went back and looked at last year's to make sure they didn't just use the same one.

Phaneuf was #1 last year too, Redden #2.
 
Our only real weakness defensively is the PK, and Schenn has been really awful on the PK, and the PK looks much better with him off it.

Losing Schenn doesn't hurt us at all.
 
Philly also has no reason to make that deal. They don't need a young, intriguing, high end prospect at the centre spot. They need defenders, and badly.
 
If you have 8 good NHL dmen, trading one of them for a player in an area where you don't have that kind of depth definitely makes the team better.
 
Not sure about JVR though. Schenn is the big trade chip, that they can afford to move at least, do you blow it on JVR or Voracek?
 
Thinking about it a little more, it is true that in terms of youth/prospects, we've got Kadri, Colborne, McKegg at center, young guys in Aulie, Franson, Gardiner, Blacker on the blueline but not a ton of good young wingers coming up through the system. Adding a 22 year old JVR wouldn't be so bad.
 
Not sure about JVR though. Schenn is the big trade chip, that they can afford to move at least, do you blow it on JVR or Voracek?

Unless the price on Bobby Ryan is astronomical....no.

If we're trading for a young winger and not a centre, may as well get the best one on the market.
 
Unless the price on Bobby Ryan is astronomical....no.

If we're trading for a young winger and not a centre, may as well get the best one on the market.

I think the prices were hearing for Bobby Ryan sound pretty silly. The few reports I've heard seem to indicate that what they're looking for for Getzlaf and Ryan is the same, which is just ridiculous. In that one report they said Kadri, Colborne and two firsts.

I said so in the Rumours thread on the Habs board and was told that if the Leafs did that they'd "finally get the superstar they were looking for" because Ryan >> Kessel.
 
Back
Top