• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Bobby Ryan is a great young player. One of the few players besides Kessel to have scored 30 goals each of the past three years, and he's on pace to hit 30 again this year. What remains to be seen is if he has that extra gear that'll let him kick his production up to superstar level, like Getzlaf and Perry have done in the past and Kessel has for the past year. For that reason, he'd have to be available for significantly cheaper than the Ducks would be asking for Getzlaf/Perry.
 
Nobody took ESPN's hockey coverage seriously and they finally figured out how to get people to talk about them.

Yup, the same way Toronto Sun generates headlines in the hockey circle.

As for this whole 'overrated' thing ... I was listening to the TO media people talk about it, and I realize 1 thing - the same people who 'over-rate' Dion Phaneuf are the same people who vastly underrate Phaneuf.
 
Nobody took ESPN's hockey coverage seriously and they finally figured out how to get people to talk about them.

Yup, the same way Toronto Sun generates headlines in the hockey circle.

As for this whole 'overrated' thing ... I was listening to the TO media people talk about it, and I realize 1 thing - the same people who 'over-rate' Dion Phaneuf are the same people who vastly underrate Phaneuf.

I'm not sure if I said ESPN by mistake earlier or not but sorry if I did, it's actually SI.
 
I think the prices were hearing for Bobby Ryan sound pretty silly. The few reports I've heard seem to indicate that what they're looking for for Getzlaf and Ryan is the same, which is just ridiculous. In that one report they said Kadri, Colborne and two firsts.

That is pretty steep, but I understand why. Ryan is signed to a very friendly deal, for a bunch more years. I wouldn't move him for anything less than a king's ransom either. Neither Getzky or Perry are controllable for much longer at all for Anaheim.

I'm just hoping Murray is a twit and makes a mistake in his evaluations and decides that flipping Ryan to fill his holes is the answer to his problems. A lot of GM's aren't very forward thinking.

I said so in the Rumours thread on the Habs board and was told that if the Leafs did that they'd "finally get the superstar they were looking for" because Ryan >> Kessel.

What have I told you about hanging out with morons?
 
As for this whole 'overrated' thing ... I was listening to the TO media people talk about it, and I realize 1 thing - the same people who 'over-rate' Dion Phaneuf are the same people who vastly underrate Phaneuf.

Wait until he finishes 3rd or 4th in Norris voting this summer.
 
That is pretty steep, but I understand why. Ryan is signed to a very friendly deal, for a bunch more years. I wouldn't move him for anything less than a king's ransom either. Neither Getzky or Perry are controllable for much longer at all for Anaheim.

I just wouldn't do that big of a package for Ryan. Our best two center prospects and two first rounders for our new 2nd line winger and then we still don't have a legit #1C?
 
I just wouldn't do that big of a package for Ryan. Our best two center prospects and two first rounders for our new 2nd line winger and then we still don't have a legit #1C?

Oh, I wouldn't do it either from Toronto's perspective. But I'd definitely roam into the ridiculous with my demands if I was Murray, just because of how controllable Ryan is right now. If Perry & Getz don't re sign this summer, the smart move is to deal them. No reason to move Ryan for anything but a ridiculous package, he might be the only one of the 3 around for much longer.
 
Bobby Ryan is a great young player. One of the few players besides Kessel to have scored 30 goals each of the past three years, and he's on pace to hit 30 again this year. What remains to be seen is if he has that extra gear that'll let him kick his production up to superstar level, like Getzlaf and Perry have done in the past and Kessel has for the past year. For that reason, he'd have to be available for significantly cheaper than the Ducks would be asking for Getzlaf/Perry.

never has a young player ever had an easier entrance into the NHL, with full time minutes with two epic linemates covering for all his weaknesses.

no surprise that the ducks want to move him.
 
never has a young player ever had an easier entrance into the NHL, with full time minutes with two epic linemates covering for all his weaknesses.

no surprise that the ducks want to move him.

You don't score 30 goals every season from the ages of 21-23 (including scoring at nearly a 40-goal pace at the age of 21, like Phil) without having a lot of talent, no matter how good your linemates/teammates happen to be. However, I do agree with you that he's had things pretty easy and has been overrated as a result. He's not yet on the level of Getzlaf, Perry, or even the ageless cyborg that wears a "Selanne" jersey in Anaheim, though I'm sure a lot of people believe that he either is, or isn't far off.
 
Uhhh, correct me if I'm wrong here, but does Ryan not get shafted on PP time because of the obvious excellence in Anaheim's top 6?
 
Uhhh, correct me if I'm wrong here, but does Ryan not get shafted on PP time because of the obvious excellence in Anaheim's top 6?

2011 PP TOI:
Fowler: 169:43
Getzlaf: 165:18
Perry: 163:43
Selanne: 159:08
Visnovsky: 132:23
Ryan: 81:01

2010 PP TOI:
Visnovsky: 336:00
Perry: 287:40
Fowler: 275:53
Selanne: 257:57
Getzlaf: 240:08 (spent time on IR)
Ryan: 196:55

2009 PP TOI:
Niedermayer: 318:10
Perry: 313:29
Visnovsky: 272:54 (time split between edmonton and ducks)
Getzlaf: 255:40 (once again spent time on IR)
Ryan: 232:30
Selanne: 195:11 (spent time on IR)

And for what ever it's worth:

Kessel 2009 PP TOI: 270:35
2010: 307:36
2011: 144:41
 
Last edited:
Philly and Toronto have discussed many times about one Schenn going one way or the other, as the brothers are really close and both GMs know that one plus one might make three for the other team. It would probably be an overpay by either GM to make it happen.

One rumour that I have heard is that Gustavsson is in play as well with the Anaheim trade. As Gustavsson's agent has made it pretty clear to Toronto, that because of being thrown under the bus(their opinion, NOT mine or my contacts) as a backup to Reimer, they are not going to resign in Toronto.

So like it or not, Gustavsson for Hiller plus whomever else is being discussed and like every Burke trade chip, the time to trade Gustavsson might be now. Is he really a 929% guy and a guy who can win 9 of 11, all the time? No. Actually only Thomas is.
 
Yeah, I don't believe for a second that Gus wants out of Toronto, or that Burke's looking to bring in Hiller. At this point, Hiller's a dangerous reclamation project with a mysterious, debilitating condition that could rear its ugly head again anytime that's also owed $11.5M over the next two and a half seasons.

As for Gus, the Leafs have stuck with him for longer than most teams would have through some pretty abysmal play. And the fact that Wilson's been perfectly willing to hand the reins to Gus the moment he started outplaying Reimer is something that's not lost on him. I'm sure he and his agent also realize that there are fewer and fewer undisputed #1 goalies these days, and there won't be a huge lineup of teams willing to offer him that role and good coin come July 1st.
 
I don't want to get into a twenty page mud slinging argument over this. I am the biggest Gustavsson fan on this entire board, so if ANYONE doesn't want to lose him, its me. But its what is out there, with all my contacts. Goalies are funny animals, and NOW Gustavsson has some power, and in my opinion,he deserves it.

I would hate to lose him, and I don't want Bobby Ryan. I wouldn't mind Getzlaf, but not by decimating the whole youth movement.

IF Burke wants to acquire a superior talent for Schenn because Philly wants to overpay, or if HE wants to acquire Brayden Schenn and overpay, I am okay with that.
 
Gus can be re-signed for cheap and there's no reason not to re-sign him if he can continue with this pace.

All that said, I am still not sold on Gus as a good #1 in this league. 3 years is a long time and despite hot streaks here and there during these 3 years, I haven't seen enough in Gus during these 3 years to convince myself he is a starter in this league, never mind a good starter.

And if Reimer isn't the answer either then Burke's got work to do in goal. With rumors of Miller being available, you never know what he's gonna do in the summer ... afterall, Miller was his goalie for the Olympics and got him as far as Team USA could go in that tourney.

And to be honest, it's been a while since we have a goalie who can win a playoff series all by himself, a goalie who when the opponent coach knows he's gotta get through in a playoff series it gives them serious headaches ... Reimer isn't there yet, I don't see that in Gus.
 
poor man's nash.

I don't see how you could say a poor mans Nash. More like a Nash that uses his size and plays physically and makes half the money.

From 21-23:
Ryan - 227 gms, 100 gls, 192 pts, 361 hits, 603:09 PPTOI (82 gms, 36 gls, 69 pts, 130 hits, 2:39 PP/G)
Nash - 209 gms, 105 gls, 180 pts, 181 hits, 885:55 PPTOI (82 gms, 41 gls, 71 pts, 71 hits, 4:14 PP/G)

And its not just an "Ryan gets to play with better players" thing. In their pre draft years, both in the OHL, Ryan 1.43 ppg, Nash 1.33 ppg.

Offensively they were the same type of prospects, they had the same type of production early in their careers (Ryan with better linemates, Nash with 50% more time on the PP).
 
Last edited:
Back
Top