Listening to how the media rates this Schenn for JVR rumor it's hilarious and once again shows how the grass is always greener on the other side of the fence, ESPECIALLY if you are in Toronto ...
"Schenn may develop into a very good player, but JVR may develop into a star."
Schenn, the former 5th overall pick, made the NHL at 18 (albeit on a bottom team) and has shown ability to play top 4 minutes and be physical and effective defensively. Like most 21 year old defensemen, he can be inconsistent and still needs to develop, but let's not pretend JVR is an established NHL star here. JVR, also 21, is playing in his 3rd NHL season, and his best year was last year when he had 21G, 40 points. Those are not bad stats for a 20 year old forward, but if you are to mention his 'star potential' those numbers aren't exactly convincing, especially when you consider his expectation as a 2nd overall pick.
"The Flyers are looking for a Pronger replacement here, and Schenn is, all due respect, not Pronger."
And who is?
The Flyers have a hole to fill on the blueline, Schenn gives them the physical aspect and is a very responsible defenseman. And he's only 21, he has potential to develop into an Adam Foote. Adam Foote is no Chris Pronger but who is a Chris Pronger in this league? Never mind among defensmen available ... but who is a Chris Pronger in his prime?
"Sutter may become available, and the Flyers gotta think about whether they want to use their trade bait on Sutter or Schenn."
Fair enough, but they are different trades. Sutter is gonna be a rental, and even if the Flyers do re-sign him in the summer he won't come cheap. Schenn is young, may develop into a better defenseman, and is cheaper. You are comparing a 21 year old to a pending UFA rental. I don't think they are comparable.
Plus, sure Flyers can wait, but so can Toronto. Is JVR the only young forward available out there? We've heard all kinds of rumors including Getzlaf, Ryan, Stastny to name a few. All of them will cost more than JVR, but all of them more established than JVR.