You'll have to excuse me here...but what you're saying, and the conclusions you're drawing from those words don't mesh...they just don't. You don't just get to say that you regularly mistake Kadri on the ice for a 61 point 2nd line winger, then excuse the fact that Kadri is 21 years old, and proclaim him to have upside no better than the 26 year old 61 point winger you regularly mistake him for.
They "look" similar out there. Same stature, similar size, skate similarly, etc. And MacA has been more or less horrendous this year, so it's not necessarily a flattering comparison. The whole reason I'm even making it is to say that we got MacA for nothing, Grabo for a pick, etc. Kadri types come along all the time. Cammalleri was a UFA, just traded on a whim. But guys with size, skill, speed, and vision aren't that common, and that's why Colborne is special imo, and Kadri isn't that much.
As for the dangles being "big deal"....even assuming that he's an exact carbon copy of MacArthur, but with significantly better dangles, you've taken a 61 point winger and given him the ability to make defenders miss, as well as keep dead plays alive with his stick handling...do you not see how significant an upgrade on a player that is all by itself?
I'm not sure you understand exactly what you're looking at when you see him quite frankly. I mean, dismissing away his stick handling ability that way is incredible. Puck skills might be the single most important talent you'll find in common among elite hockey players and Kadri has it in spades....it's ridiculous that you would explain that away as "big deal", ridiculous.
I repeat, "big deal", until it turns into something. For now, it's a Harlem Globetrotters gimmick that is only useful in the shootouts.
You've already claimed he's a Macarthur clone with better hands (MacArthur of course, being the highest point getter of the 3 last season), but you would take Macarthur over him? Again, your conclusions don't seem to be consistent with your observations.
Yes, reason being, those guys have all at least proven they can put up significant points if the stars align for them. They're not prospects anymore. Kadri is.
Problem is, he's not strong yet (though the hope is that at his size, it's only a matter of time before he can control the puck along the boards at an elite level), and his skill level at the NHL level is still very much up in the air.
You could just as easily be describing Kadri there, other than the size comment.
Granted, he's a very intriguing prospect. But he's simply not on Kadri's level in terms of upside.
Disagree. I've never, ever been smitten with Kadri, except for a brief time during the preseason a couple of years ago, which I've never seen him repeat. But the first game I saw Colborne play (his first as a Marlie), I was sold. The kid is super smart, a character guy, with all the raw tools I'm looking for to project him to be a complete top line player in the NHL.
It really seems that you're over valuing Colborne's size and strength (because frankly, the strength isn't there yet) and horrendously under valuing the potential in Kadri's hands and passing ability.
You have to assume his strength will be there as they develop him; no worries there.
And I'm not undervaluing anything when it comes to Kadri's hands. I think he could be a pretty good player in his own right, but likely top out at what we saw MacA do last year. That doesn't excite me that much. But I could see Colborne being a force out of the C position for years to come, a guy that is more a threat than a pest, more of a full rink player than an offense-only guy, a guy who can stand in front of the net just as well as he can control the zone and make a pass, etc. I can't remember the last time we had a prospect like him, frankly. Pre-knee disaster Antropov maybe? That's about it.
101 hit the nail on the head, there have been periods of games and entire games since his callup that Naz was if not our best player, absolutely a major impact player on the game, one of our top 3 performers overall. Colborne acquitted himself pretty nicely all things considered during his stint, I think he earned himself a longer look (especially considering guys like Lombardi getting PT ahead of him), but at no time did he look like a force out there. At no time did he appear to be one of our best players. Throw in the fact that Kadri is 9 months younger and further along in his development and I'm pretty shocked that you can continue to hold this opinion.
Not everyone develops at the same rate.
Kadri looked miles ahead of where he is now a couple of years ago during that preseason. To me, he has plateaued for some time now. Now maybe putting him on that first line would be just the opportunity he needs to break through, but we won't know till it happens. Like I've said several times already, he's in all likelihood going to be a good player, but I'm more intrigued by Colborne. All it takes for me is to see certain glimpses of a prospect to have a real good idea of what he's going to be. I see Kadri having a Subban-ish type of career (as that one has gone so far) - tons of skill, but not going to get where the majority projects he'll get to. Colborne is a lot more solid of a player, a lot more complete, imo, and if he fills out and catches up to the pace of the NHL game, he'll be something potentially truly awesome.
Anyway, it's just my opinion; no need to agree with it or try to convince me otherwise. If we trade for Getzlaf, I genuinely hope Kadri is the centerpiece to that deal and not JC.