• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Ugh this is only going to get worse as the deadline approaches.

I think I would pretty safely wager that the odds of us hearing rumours about any deal that is imminent are slim to none. Whatever Burke does, I really doubt any of us (or the bozos in the media) will see it coming.

With that said, I wouldn't do that Nash deal. Don't want that fat lazy bum on our team. Especially if it required giving up Kadri (who I would love to see play alongside Nash) to get him.
 
Nash would be our best player imo. When you come and play here the pressure is that high (just ask Kessel) and i think under Wilson Nash would be a very dominant player

I don't buy that. I think if you're expecting the home town factor or the media pressure to make an under-achiving player play up to par you are always gonna be disappointed.

Also, if Nash wanted to play in a *real* hockey market then why the heck did he sign that long term deal with Columbus???

Columbus is the perfect little town for a lazy millionare to fly under the radar, escape scrutiny and play his entire career with no expectation whatsoever. Every 4 years or so he'll get his chance at Team Canada's camp to remind the hockey world he's still around, build is reputation then go back into getting by doing the absolute minimum mode.
 
I don't buy that. I think if you're expecting the home town factor or the media pressure to make an under-achiving player play up to par you are always gonna be disappointed.

Also, if Nash wanted to play in a *real* hockey market then why the heck did he sign that long term deal with Columbus???

Columbus is the perfect little town for a lazy millionare to fly under the radar, escape scrutiny and play his entire career with no expectation whatsoever. Every 4 years or so he'll get his chance at Team Canada's camp to remind the hockey world he's still around, build is reputation then go back into getting by doing the absolute minimum mode.

No in some ways you are right. The thing is i'm sure we can point out many players who had under-achieved seasons and gone to other teams and done much better. Aside from his stats, all i'm looking at is a guy who can dominate the boards, has great speed and skill to go along with that. When you have those assets it's very tough not to make a player go from being a 60 pt player to an 80-90pt player especially playing with great players like Kessel and Lupul and being in a city that will kick you in the ass every time you struggle.
 
agreed completely.

i just see it as a case of bringing in a guy who might make you better, but won't help you win a cup.

kind of like columbus bringing in carter.

that said, yeah, i'd have a tough time saying no. because the leafs definitely get the best player out of that deal, and like you said... it gives them a hell of a 2nd line.

This is pretty much how I feel. The Leafs are more than a piece or two away from being deemed legitimate contenders, although with how wide open the Eastern Conference is this year perhaps that sort of thinking is restrictive in terms of the possibilities, and Nash does not necessarily represent the final piece.

What he would represent though is a big-bodied local winger with an uncanny goal-scoring ability. He's certainly overrated and I don't think he possesses nearly the degree of leadership skills that most standard TV analysts (I'm looking at you Doug MacLean) seem to think he possesses, nor is he a demi-god in terms of talent like is often inferred, but he is a damn good first-line winger. The Leafs would be a better team with him in the fold. The possibility of jettisoning Komisarek's awful contract would simply be icing on the proverbial cake of course.
 
Yeah but giving up Grabo, who is already producing at a similar rate to Nash; Kadri, who one day could easily outscore Nash; and Schenn, who's a solid defensive d-man, for a lazy underachieving bum with an almost $8 million cap hit? No thanks.
 
Last 2 years:

R.Nash (27): 124gms, 49gls, 99pts (82gms, 32gls, 66pts)
M.Grabo (27): 124gms, 45gls, 90pts (82gms, 30gls, 60pts)

That's ridiculous. I had no idea the two were so close off-hand. Just goes to show you that the media and fanbase's perception of a player's value can be significantly off much of the time.
 
I'd rather trade for a Ruutu for now and then target Parise in the off-season. Just as much risk involved and we can keep Kadri.

A decent B level prospect and a respectable pick (2nd rounder) probably gets it done.

On the other hand, Rutherford might elect to take a wait-and-see approach given the advantageous market for sellers this season. There's more parity in the league than ever before, particularly in the East, and it would be in Carolina's best interest to wait things out to drive up the price of their available players.
 
Well its only close because Nash is having a terrible year this year. His 2 year split from the previous 2 years is 72 points.
 
I mean, let's be honest here - Rick Nash is 27 years old and has managed to score 70pts exactly once in his career.

There's no doubting his talent, and that in the right situation with the right linemates he might go off for some huge seasons, but the risk/reward given his contract doesn't add up to me.

I mean there was risk enough in going for Phaneuf with his contract - and Phaneuf had been a truly elite offensive defenseman every year of his career but one at that point, with a 17% smaller caphit for only 3 more years, instead of Nash's 6.

and we're going to give up MORE - WAY more - for nash than we did for Phaneuf? no thanks.
 
Last edited:
Yeah but giving up Grabo, who is already producing at a similar rate to Nash; Kadri, who one day could easily outscore Nash; and Schenn, who's a solid defensive d-man, for a lazy underachieving bum with an almost $8 million cap hit? No thanks.

I hate giving up Grabo too, i think he's been one of our best this season (and last). Remember how Burke works though. If he has to overpay to get a player that he thinks will bring him closer to competing for the Cup, that's what he will do...so yeah i agree it's a lot but we aren't giving up too much in terms of our current roster players (Komi and Schenn can easily be replaced) and Kadri wasn't on the team for most of this season anyways.
 
No in some ways you are right. The thing is i'm sure we can point out many players who had under-achieved seasons and gone to other teams and done much better. Aside from his stats, all i'm looking at is a guy who can dominate the boards, has great speed and skill to go along with that. When you have those assets it's very tough not to make a player go from being a 60 pt player to an 80-90pt player especially playing with great players like Kessel and Lupul and being in a city that will kick you in the ass every time you struggle.

so when a player has the 'assets' that they already have, it's tough not to predict a 20-30 point jump in production?

nash is what he is, and imo it's very unlikely that coming to toronto would result in a 60-70 point player turning into an 80-90 point guy.

maybe getting out of the proverbial hockey backwaters might elicit a better defensive effort, and a player more apt to show up in big games.

but then, the toronto market, its media glare and the (your words) 'kick in the ass' for lousy efforts has been more apt to HINDER players than it has helped them. there are many more examples of players UNDERPERFORMING in toronto because of the fanbase and rabid media than players who have taken their game to a new level because of it.
 
7.8 million until 2017, and there's no guarantee whatsoever we'd be getting the 07-09 40-goal Nash.

It would be a big gamble, one that if it didn't pay off would haunt not only Burke but his successor. Even leaving aside the assets we'd have to pay.
 
Nash scored at a 70+ point pace in 5 out of 6 seasons since the lockout heading into this year. He is 10th in goals in the NHL over that span and 23rd in points, pacing out at a 71 point pace.

He's overrated because he isn't a 90 point superstar like some people treat him. But at the same time he isn't a shitty 60 point player. He is a legit, consistent 70+ point player, and as such one of the top 20-30 most productive players in the NHL. He's still a very good player. Just isn't one of the top ones.
 
Hmm?

AM640_Bill_Watters.jpg
 
Back
Top