• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Well, Getzlaf has a $5.4M cap, but you trade away Schenn's $3.6M cap hit and Bozak's $1.5M so it's almost a wash, for this season and next.

Ideally if we can lose Komi's $4.5M cap hit we free up a lot of cap space for the next 3 seasons. Armstrong has 2 more seasons at $3M @ so that's $7.5M we can lose ... Komi might have to be sent down to the Marlies if nobody would take him, but Armstrong is a lot easier to trade.

i don't know what you're even responding to.

that's the whole point.. if you add getzlaf while trade schenn and bozak, the leafs' cap is maxed out.

and the guys you are suggesting they trade... really aren't tradeable. komisarek has a limited no trade, but good luck finding a team willing to take on a $4.5mn #7 defenseman. lombardi and armstrong are diminished and injury prone.. and imo without the lefas taking back a hefty salary (defeating the purpose of shipping them out, frankly), pretty much untradeable.

the best they can do is demote lombardi and armstrong. they CANNOT demote komisarek -- he has a no movement clause.

so my point basically stands... if the leafs were to make that trade they would have no cap space, and very little wiggle room under teh cap, and be devoid of any valuable trade chips, or young players to step in and replace the armstrongs/lombardis (i.e. to supplement depth and make the team better).

that's a crazy package to give up for a player. i'm not even saying i wouldn't do it, but you'd have to feel pretty damn confident about reimer and gus/scrivens/owuya/rinnas, and in the rest of that lineup to make that sort of trade.
 
i don't know what you're even responding to.

that's the whole point.. if you add getzlaf while trade schenn and bozak, the leafs' cap is maxed out.

and the guys you are suggesting they trade... really aren't tradeable. komisarek has a limited no trade, but good luck finding a team willing to take on a $4.5mn #7 defenseman. lombardi and armstrong are diminished and injury prone.. and imo without the lefas taking back a hefty salary (defeating the purpose of shipping them out, frankly), pretty much untradeable.

the best they can do is demote lombardi and armstrong. they CANNOT demote komisarek -- he has a no movement clause.

so my point basically stands... if the leafs were to make that trade they would have no cap space, and very little wiggle room under teh cap, and be devoid of any valuable trade chips, or young players to step in and replace the armstrongs/lombardis (i.e. to supplement depth and make the team better).

that's a crazy package to give up for a player. i'm not even saying i wouldn't do it, but you'd have to feel pretty damn confident about reimer and gus/scrivens/owuya/rinnas, and in the rest of that lineup to make that sort of trade.
Eh ... I don't see your point at all.

Bozak + Schenn's cap hit is a wash with Getzlaf's cap hit.

Armstrong and Komi ... that's a side point. That part doesn't change whether you trade for Getzlaf or not. I'm just suggesting other ways to come up with more cap space.

You keep saying if you make the trade you have no cap space for other moves. Well, if you don't make the trade you have no cap space for major moves either as long as you keep Schenn and Bozak.

And if you trade away Schenn and Bozak, chances are you'll be trading for a bigger cap hit (Ryan, JVR, Parise ... or any other rumored forward aren't any cheaper) so you are in the same situation.
 
The Leafs would still have young players to step in for guys like Army, Lombardi in guys like Frattin, D'Amigo, Biggs, McKegg, Blacker, Percy. They just wouldn't have guys with top end potential anymore.

And the whole 3rd line's (Connolly, Army, Lombardi) contracts are up after next season, which opens up $11 million in cap space in the near future, so its not like they won't have any flexibility. They also aren't locked into Lupul, Kulemin, Grabo and Mac beyond next season either. So they aren't committed to anything cap-wise really.

I think they can afford to make a deal like that. The question should be whether its worth it.
 
it's because you keep trying to break my argument down into component parts.

stop doing that.

i don't really care about spending to the cap... i DO care about being at the cap with absolutely no talent in the pipeline, no cheap young talent to slot on to the 2nd or 3rd line, and no prospects with any trade value.

if the leafs make that trade then their only hope at improving the roster -- should it require improvements -- is the long shot chance of dumping 2 of lombardi/armstrong/komisarek, which is a tall order and might not even help the team when you consider that their replacements (unless the leafs are willing to trade draft picks, which would be an awful decision after trading colborne, kadri and schenn all in the same deal) would almost certainly have to be via the ufa market.

again, im' not even necessarily saying i wouldn't make the trade... it's just an incredibly risky move that basically necessitates the team being able to compete for a cup as is.
 
To Toronto :Getzlaf
To Anaheim: Schenn, Kadri, Colborne, Bozak and 1st

I know Burke loves Getzlaf but I don't think he pays that. I know we can't look at it this way but that is basically four 1sts and a late 2nd/3rd (Bozak's value)
 
I'd pull the trigger. You get the elite and uber talented 1st line centre and figure out the rest later. It would hurt for sure, but I'd do it.
 
The Leafs would still have young players to step in for guys like Army, Lombardi in guys like Frattin, D'Amigo, Biggs, McKegg, Blacker, Percy. They just wouldn't have guys with top end potential anymore.

And the whole 3rd line's (Connolly, Army, Lombardi) contracts are up after next season, which opens up $11 million in cap space in the near future, so its not like they won't have any flexibility. They also aren't locked into Lupul, Kulemin, Grabo and Mac beyond next season either. So they aren't committed to anything cap-wise really.

I think they can afford to make a deal like that. The question should be whether its worth it.

getzlaf isn't locked in either.

whcih creates another problem.

conceivably they could lose all of connolly, lupul, macarthur, armstrong, getzlaf... with only biggs, frattin and (assuming they select a forward thsi year) their 2012 first round selection around to replace them.

again... not saying that i wouldn't do the deal. just that you'd have to feel pretty ****ing good about the current roster (with getzlaf replacing schenn/bozak) to make the deal.

it would maybe be the riskiest deal a team has ever made.
 
That's too much for the Leafs to pay. I'm with mbow, that deal would clean us out and we still wouldn't be a contender even with Getzlaf.
 
Heck if that's a no-no then Burke should stop his search for a top center altogether.

I don't care who it is that the Leafs bring in - JVR, Perry, Ryan, Staal, Parise ... anyone who is or is not on the rumor list, but to acquire ANY top line center the other team is going to be asking for cheap, young, promising players + prospects and picks.

So you will always be giving up the likes of Schenn, Gardiner, Gunnarson, Kadri, Colborne, etc for a top line forward.

And as a result of that, you will always be maxing out your cap, no matter who you trade for. If you are uncomfortable with that then forget about the trade altogether. Let's wait for Kadri and Colborne to develop into that top line center.

It doesn't mean you can't tinker with the lineup or add players after picking up a $5-6M cap hit in that top forward. Grabs and MacArthur are tradeable parts if Frattin, D'Amigo etc are ready to step up, Connolly is also easily tradeable next year in the final year of his contract.

And at the end of the day, if you bring in ANY big name player he's going to take up most of our remaining cap space ... that goes for any top spending team too. It's a must if you even think about trading for a top line player.
 
Pretty solid overpayment. No thanks.

Kadri and Colborne's potential together is just too high.
I like Kadri and Colborne a LOT. But let's just say neither of them will ever pan out to be Getzlaf.

And Getzlaf is not some 31 year old power forward looking for his retirement contract ... Getzlaf is 26 years old, already has won the cup and the Olympics and is an established 20/80 top line center who plays at both ends of the rink and knows what it takes to win in the playoff.

If guys like Getzalf even hit the market you HAVE TO do it.

Bringing in a guy like Getzlaf will also give us a 1st line of Lupul - Getzlaf - Kessel. I'd say that's as good as ANY first line in the East, or in the league.

We'll still have a top 4 of Phaneuf, Liles, Gardiner and Gunnarson. Again, that's as good as any team in the East.

That, to me, is the core of a contender. It's much easier to tinker with the supporting cast, even given a very tight situation, than to be stuck with a bunch of 2nd liners and prospects and hope we can win the cup with those.

And ideally, I'd keep 1 of Kadri or Colborne ... I don't believe the rumor has any substance to it, but if it does, that's probably the sticking point for Burke.
 
Heck if that's a no-no then Burke should stop his search for a top center altogether.

when has a team ever had to trade its three best young players/prospects, which includes a recent 5th and 7th overall pick... in addition to a recent mid-first, a 25 year old centre on pace for over 50 points who is signed to a cap friendly deal AND a first round pick on top of that?

that's insane.

a reasonable deal for a first liner would certainly include ONE of kadri/colborne, but not both. it would probably HAVE to include schenn because of cap dollars. it MIGHT include bozak. it MIGHT include a first. not all of that, though.

a reasonable trade would probably include some high end young talent -- some combination of kadri, colborne, schenn and the leafs' 2012 or 2013 first; but all of it? that's a steep, steep price to pay.
 
To Toronto :Getzlaf
To Anaheim: Schenn, Kadri, Colborne, Bozak and 1st

Haha, uh, no thanks.

Basically five first rounders for Getzlaf.

Hahaha. That is ****ing hilarious. Unless the point is to make up for the absolute rip off of Lupul and Gardiner, this would and should get Burke fired on the spot.

I wouldn't even trade three of those guys for him. Schenn, Kadri, and a 1st is the MAX I would consider.
 
i don't know what you're even responding to.

that's the whole point.. if you add getzlaf while trade schenn and bozak, the leafs' cap is maxed out.

and the guys you are suggesting they trade... really aren't tradeable. komisarek has a limited no trade, but good luck finding a team willing to take on a $4.5mn #7 defenseman. lombardi and armstrong are diminished and injury prone.. and imo without the lefas taking back a hefty salary (defeating the purpose of shipping them out, frankly), pretty much untradeable.

the best they can do is demote lombardi and armstrong. they CANNOT demote komisarek -- he has a no movement clause.

so my point basically stands... if the leafs were to make that trade they would have no cap space, and very little wiggle room under teh cap, and be devoid of any valuable trade chips, or young players to step in and replace the armstrongs/lombardis (i.e. to supplement depth and make the team better).

that's a crazy package to give up for a player. i'm not even saying i wouldn't do it, but you'd have to feel pretty damn confident about reimer and gus/scrivens/owuya/rinnas, and in the rest of that lineup to make that sort of trade.

meh, lombo and army are still useful player with only a year left on their deals. shouldn't be a problem to move them somwhere in the offseason if we want to.
 
Back
Top