• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Until Reimer's proven otherwise, he is a #1 goalie.

For a month he played like a #1 goalie who's missed significant time and is coming back from an injury ... because ... he missed significant time and was coming back from injury.

So far after the all-star game he's played like a #1, period.

Until there's further evidence to suggest otherwise, case closed, Leafs are fine with our #1 Reimer and backup Gustavsson for the rest of this season.
 
Riemer was an average #1 goalie this season before going down to his injury and when he came back his numbers weren't even decent for a backup goalie. Wilson has now alternated back to giving Reimer the past few starts and in those he has looked like a #1 goalie again. That being said though he has not earned the starting job here, then again neither has Gus. I actually dont even think we have a starter/backup, we just have two average goalies who are sharing the workload this season, and right now there isn't anything wrong with it given that were north of 8th spot. However, between now and the end of game 82, one of those goalies is going to need to flat out steal the starting role and prove they can provide above average goaltending numbers by the time the playoffs start.
 
So you're basing your opinion on Reimer on essentially what amounted to three starts?

No that isn't what I'm saying at all. What I am saying is that so far this season Riemer has not secured the #1 job both due to injuries, subpar stretches of goaltending and at time Gus showing he is better in net this season.

You seem to be basing your opinion on Riemer this season based on his past track record which is extremely faulty logic IMO. Yes, he's been an above average goaltender every league he's played in prior to the NHL and yes he had a really solid rookie season, that being said though his past shouldn't define who and where he is now. This season is what matters, and so far he's been merely average in net, average before going down, horrible for a stretch when he came back and now he's back to having a slightly above average stretch these past several games. Overall like I have said Riemer has come nowhere close to securing the top goaltending spot on this team, but I'll say this, this is his big chance to show the leafs that he can be that elite goalie we've been lacking since the lockout ended.
 
No that isn't what I'm saying at all. What I am saying is that so far this season Riemer has not secured the #1 job both due to injuries, subpar stretches of goaltending and at time Gus showing he is better in net this season.

You seem to be basing your opinion on Riemer this season based on his past track record which is extremely faulty logic IMO. Yes, he's been an above average goaltender every league he's played in prior to the NHL and yes he had a really solid rookie season, that being said though his past shouldn't define who and where he is now. This season is what matters, and so far he's been merely average in net, average before going down, horrible for a stretch when he came back and now he's back to having a slightly above average stretch these past several games. Overall like I have said Riemer has come nowhere close to securing the top goaltending spot on this team, but I'll say this, this is his big chance to show the leafs that he can be that elite goalie we've been lacking since the lockout ended.


It's Reimer...Reimer...........

familyguy.jpg
 
Riemer was an average #1 goalie this season before going down to his injury
You mean his 5-0-1 record was just an average #1 eh?

Seriously, if I am to break down reimer's brief NHL career ...

- Rookie season = as good as you can expect of any rookie goalie, not only he had the stats and the W's to prove he has what it takes to be a #1, if you watch how he plays he has the composure, the mental strength, the physical size, goaltending skills to be a good #1 in this league, over a pretty big sample size.

- Sphomore season is always toughest for young goalies, but Reimer started the season with a 5-0-1 record, while not posting the best SV% he was clutch and came up with big saves with critical times of a game. You can't critique a 5-0-1 start.

- After the injury, he struggled for a month, which as other concussed goalies would tell you, is perfectly normal. I suggested Burke should look for another goalie during this time, not because I don't believe reimer will rebound to be a good #1 in his career, but I wasn't sure if that would happen this season, and we HAVE TO make playoff this year.

- After the all-star break, he's played 3 games and has looked very very good again. Any goalie can look good in 3 games, but combine with what he showed before injury, last season, and also his entire pre-NHL career there are good reasons to believe these 3 games are the norm for Reimer, not a fluke.
 
No that isn't what I'm saying at all. What I am saying is that so far this season Riemer has not secured the #1 job both due to injuries, subpar stretches of goaltending and at time Gus showing he is better in net this season.

Yes, that is what you are saying.

and when he came back his numbers weren't even decent for a backup goalie

Which essentially amounted to two or three starts during which there were still obvious post-concussion symptoms prevalent before the pair of consecutive shutouts.

You seem to be basing your opinion on Riemer this season based on his past track record which is extremely faulty logic IMO.

......

This isn't a serious "argument" is it?
 
:lol

I still can't believe that was stated as a counter-point.

Well actually it's a valid argument- Look at this way lets say a guy had 50 goals last season, it doesn't mean he will reach 50 again this year. Same thing applies to Reimer, just because had an elite 1st year, doesn't equate to him following it up again this year. That's the point I was/am trying to make here.
 
IF we had one big forward who likes to rock and roll and who could skate swiftly AND good to very good goaltending, I would give us a very good shot at getting to the Stanley Cup final.

Reimer and Gus, TO ME, are below average starting NHL goalies. I watch goalies closely and Reimer looked shaky last night, he looked GOOD to quite GOOD the previous game.
 
Well actually it's a valid argument- Look at this way lets say a guy had 50 goals last season, it doesn't mean he will reach 50 again this year. Same thing applies to Reimer, just because had an elite 1st year, doesn't equate to him following it up again this year. That's the point I was/am trying to make here.

You're not making any sense.

At all.

The whole point of using track record is that it provides us with a reference point that allows us to accurately project future performances. Ergo, Reimer performing poorly in a handful of starts (not even a statistically-significant sample size) upon returning from a CONCUSSION, in which he played through post-concussion symptoms, (which are well-documented as having a deleterious impact on goaltenders' performance) should not detract from the fact that we can accurately predict that he will get back to a .912-.916 type performance in the near future.

Which means that he is a legitimate starting option in the present and near-future. Which means that this whole discussion is simply foolish.
 
And your original argument is essentially equivalent to suggesting that the same 50 goal scorer that you used in your example is not any more likely to reach the 50 goal mark again (or any high goal-scoring total) than a 20 goal man. After all, track record is irrelevant to predicting future performance according to your logic, correct?
 
There is no such thing as "accurately predicting future performances", nobody unless they are a psychic can actually make valid future predictions. Regardless of the reasons, Reimer has in fact NOT secured the starting role, I already said the injury affected him but so did subpar perfomances as well, it's a combination of things. Do I think Reimer can be an average to above average goaltender? I hope he can, but he needs to take the bull by the horns here and show Wilson and company that he is worthy of carrying most of the workload going forward.
 
already said the injury affected him but so did subpar perfomances as well, it's a combination of things.

Jesus ****ing Christ. The subpar performances were the RESULT of the injury, not isolated of their own accord.

Do I think Reimer can be an average to above average goaltender? I hope he can, but he needs to take the bull by the horns here and show Wilson and company that he is worthy of carrying most of the workload going forward.

He already demonstrated last season that he can be a borderline elite goaltender and this season, even after losing significant time to one of the most impactful injuries any player can suffer, has still provided a minimum average-level NHL goaltending performance. He's cemented himself as an NHL starter and both his recent play and established previous track record illustrates that he is by far the best goalie available to the team each game.
 
I like Reimer. I like when he plays calm,cool and collected. But I think he has a weakness and its one that by my experience, of coaching,CANNOT be improved in someone as old as he is. He is slower than I like to see in his movements. So, the way to beat him is to get within a certain range and overpower him with puck speed.

Its rare to have someone who is quick, and who has quick hands. Guys like Quick of L.A. are unique.
 
Jesus ****ing Christ. The subpar performances were the RESULT of the injury, not isolated of their own accord.



He already demonstrated last season that he can be a borderline elite goaltender and this season, even after losing significant time to one of the most impactful injuries any player can suffer, has still provided a minimum average-level NHL goaltending performance. He's cemented himself as an NHL starter and both his recent play and established previous track record illustrates that he is by far the best goalie available to the team each game.

Oh for **** sakes..Stop answering his posts already. He can believe what he wants. It's as annoying(if not more) as reading teeds' posts especially when he actually believes in what he's saying.
 
Back
Top