• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Pre injury Antropov > Staal.

And I just can't be concerned about a prospects skating anymore after the transformation Tavares has made. Skating can be turned from a weakness to a strength in a short period of time. And its not even a weakness for Couturier. He's a good skater he just lacks the burst. Like Tavares did.

But the only reason I made the Staal comparison is because of their defensive ability from an early age. Both guys stepped into the league and immediately were among the best defensive forwards in the NHL. Just Couturier has high end offensive talent and skill and Staal never did.
 
Last edited:
I think Toronto would overpay to get Brayden and I think Philly would overpay to get Luke. That is my opinion,not that of my sources. I would be happy with either scenario.
 
In fact, scouting reports show his pros and cons are very similar to Antropov's.

He's got size, long reach, is a very smart defensive player early in his career, he has good vision, and is a smart hockey player.

He uses his size well, but primarily to protect the puck. He doesn't hit often, and he doesn't play 'on the edge' or with emotion.

He is described as an average or average minus skater, not much of a first and second step, and isn't very agile neither. He is also a better passer than a scorer, doesn't have a great shot.

And yeah both of them made the NHL at 19. I hope there's no similarity when it comes to injuries.
 
I think Toronto would overpay to get Brayden and I think Philly would overpay to get Luke. That is my opinion,not that of my sources. I would be happy with either scenario.

Schenn for Schenn is still the most fair trade these two teams can make that gives each team exactly what they need IMO.
 
Yeah, but Burke would rather shoot a priest than do that to a kid and his family. And that is why players like him. That is just pure institutional cruelty. I wouldn't put it past some GM's and Paul Holmgren poked a guys eye out in the WHA with his stick, so............
 
Schenn for Schenn is still the most fair trade these two teams can make that gives each team exactly what they need IMO.
That's what I said months ago ... it fits both teams' needs, the price is fair, and it makes the most sense.

"So Luke, we have good news and bad news for you. The good news is we just made a trade for your brother, so he's packing to catch the next flight to Toronto. The bad news is you are the player going to Philly."

Nah ... Burke would never do that.
 
I question why not.

I mean, look at what exactly Brayden Schenn has achieved in the NHL thus far. Luke Schenn has achieved more as a defenseman than B Schenn has as a forward, granted, Luke is 2 years older and his ceiling is also lower.
 
That tired excuse can be used for any prospect who has yet to play an NHL game, vs any young player in the NHL......doesn't mean much to me.


Brayden has a higher ceiling at a more valuable position, is the more valuable asset.....and will be the better player.
 
It is a cruel league, but trading bro for bro? I KNOW Burke would resign before doing that.
 
I don't think Brayden has a higher ceiling. I think they both do very similar things, in different ways. IMO it'd be like trading a potential Brind'amour for a potential Foote. Only the Schenn's like to hit more.
 
Hey, you know how non-Leaf fans always bend over backwards to give credit to Bryan Murray for the Ducks' cup run?

Check this article out from 2003:

The deal is done.

Only it isn't.

The Mighty Ducks have agreed to the terms of a trade that would bring Edmonton forward Mike Comrie to Anaheim. Duck General Manager Bryan Murray has worked out a contract with the unsigned Comrie.

Yet Comrie is not a Duck.

As a condition of the trade, Edmonton General Manager Kevin Lowe added a demand of $2.5 million, to be paid by Comrie, a source familiar with the negotiations said.

The source said that Comrie will not pay the Oilers, at least at this time, and is seeking legal advice on the matter.

...

Murray, looking to pep up the Duck offense, expressed interest in Comrie last month but refused to part with a player currently on the team. The Oilers had asked for rookie Joffrey Lupul and later requested center Andy McDonald.

The two sides came to terms this week, with the Ducks agreeing to send to Edmonton prospect Corey Perry and a first-round draft pick in exchange for Comrie. Murray also worked out a contract with Comrie that will pay him about $1.5 million a season.

But Lowe made it clear no trade would occur until Comrie paid what seems to amount to an exit fee. Comrie had a base salary of $1.025 million the last three seasons but made $5 million in bonuses.


http://articles.latimes.com/2003/dec/11/sports/sp-ducktrade11
 
I highly doubt Burke will trade for Brayden Schenn- 1. Schenn really isnt that big of a guy, he's only 6'1/190lbs 2. Who's spot would Schenn (Brayden) would Brayden take? 3. Brayden overs nothing experience wise down the stretch, the last thing the leafs need is another raw player.

There is far better options out there then Brayden Schenn.
 
I highly doubt Burke will trade for Brayden Schenn- 1. Schenn really isnt that big of a guy, he's only 6'1/190lbs 2. Who's spot would Schenn (Brayden) would Brayden take? 3. Brayden overs nothing experience wise down the stretch, the last thing the leafs need is another raw player.

There is far better options out there then Brayden Schenn.

Like who? And what would it take to get them?
 
I highly doubt Burke will trade for Brayden Schenn- 1. Schenn really isnt that big of a guy, he's only 6'1/190lbs 2. Who's spot would Schenn (Brayden) would Brayden take? 3. Brayden overs nothing experience wise down the stretch, the last thing the leafs need is another raw player.

Sidney Crosby isn't particularly large either (5'11 and 200 pounds according to most publications), but no one would contest, other than teeds perhaps, that he's a legitimate number one centre and likely the best player in the league when healthy. Brayden has top-line centre potential despite not being a 6'4 210+ pound specimen like an Eric Staal or a Ryan Getzlaf. There isn't necessarily a one size fits all approach when it comes to addressing the void down the middle on the Leafs top line. A while ago Irish and I even had Brayden ranked as the top prospect not playing in the NHL on our yearly top prospect list: you're talking about one of the most productive junior players in recent memory who was a top five draft choice and demolished the competition in the AHL. 6'1, 190 pounds is plenty good enough in terms of size.

There is far better options out there then Brayden Schenn

Such as? We have to be realistic here. It makes far more sense to target players who haven't reached their full potential due to the fact that their cost would likely be far less prohibitive in a trade than if they were more established. Asset management, asset management, asset management. If you can get a potential top end centre down the road like a Brayden Schenn or a Sean Couturier you jump on it so long as the price is reasonable.
 
Like who? And what would it take to get them?

Clowe, Malone, Doan are far better options right now, because they have size, skill and grit to their game, not to mention playoff experience. I would imagaine the price to get Clowe would be steep, probably something like Schenn and a 1st (I could be wrong though on the asking price it's just a guess). Malone would probably cost us giving up a bad contract player plus a prospect. Doan I don't know if we could get him, doesn't he have a NTC? Again the asking price would be steep as well.
 
Back
Top