• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

I know I rant a lot about effort on here, but if we're making this guy the 2nd or 3rd most important player on this team, I REALLY don't want him having the history of inconsistent effort that Nash does.

I agree with you about effort. But let me ask you this? Have you watched Nash play the last 2 seasons? I know I havent. I dont know what his effort level has been, I hope you are not making this judgement based on his point totals or what whomever the hockey journalists are in Columbus f*cking Ohio. Or hockey fans in the same market.

I have seen some sick highlight goals. I have seen him play in the international spotlight.
 
I agree with you about effort. But let me ask you this? Have you watched Nash play the last 2 seasons? I know I havent. I dont know what his effort level has been, I hope you are not making this judgement based on his point totals or what whomever the hockey journalists are in Columbus f*cking Ohio. Or hockey fans in the same market.

I have seen some sick highlight goals. I have seen him play in the international spotlight.

I've watched a few Columbus games, but personally I'm basing it on my best friend's testimony. He's listed his favourite player as Nash since the lockout, and is only lukewarm on picking him up because of the effort issues. That says a lot...
 
[video=youtube;rY7ULz7Ebt0]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rY7ULz7Ebt0[/video]

Amazing how many ways he can score. Every type of highlight goal you can imagine he can do. Go around players, go through players, go over players, wrap arounds, between the legs..... How many defenders get in this guys way? Not too many, and the ones that do end up on their ass.
Please tell me how many Leafs can score the way this guy does? The answer in a big fat zero.
 
Last edited:
I've watched a few Columbus games, but personally I'm basing it on my best friend's testimony. He's listed his favourite player as Nash since the lockout, and is only lukewarm on picking him up because of the effort issues. That says a lot...

Like I mentioned a few posts ago, I am in agreement with you on effort. But I am also a firm believe in the positive aspects of change of scenery. Especially when you think about going from a shit hole franchise like Columbus to the star ship franchise of the NHL and the fan base and one of the more pro-active gms in sports. How does that NOT motivate a player?
 
I think before Burke or any GM makes a bid for Nash there are a few things we should understand ...

- Only 5 other players have scored more goals than Nash over the last 5 years. Since his sophomore season, this is really only the first 'off-season' Nash is having. He's well on pace to ~30G (with some injured season) every single season otherwise, with almost nobody to play with all these years in Columbus

- Nash is not exactly young. He's 28, typically power forwards see their production go down after 27. Nash may keep himself in tip-top shape, or he may have the Lidstrom gene ... who knows? But with an off-season at 28, that's right on the trend with other power forwards.

- Nash does almost nothing in his own end. He was not a very good defensive player to begin with, combined with the fact all these years in CBJ he was never asked to play D, defense is something that needs to be drilled into his head ... which isn't easy at 28.

- Nash has almost no playoff experience (only 4 games) and that's not his fault ... but with people quick to point to his Olympics performance as a sign he can perform on the big stage, there's a disclaimer .... yes he played VERY well in the 10 Olympics, playing on the 'energy' line scoring 2G 5Pts in 7 games. He also did NOTHING when he was given a bigger role in the 06 Olympics in Torino, scoring 0G, 1 Pt in 6 games.


So it is true power forwards like Nash rarely become available, and when it happens you typically do have to overpay to get him. All that said, we have to understand what we're getting. Nash will bring a lot of physicality to our front lines, he will play close to 20 min a game on our top 2 lines, being a force in PP, giving us a physical presence in front of the net and along the board. He will give us 30G for at least another 3-4 years. He will, however, be a player that you scream at without the puck. He will not help fix our defensive woes, in fact he will add to it. He will sure not help bring our GAA down, he will not help goaltending, which is our biggest need at the moment.

We need big forward up front, but when the price gets crazy - which it will, then you gotta ask yourself whether for short term goal (to make playoff this year) and for longer term goal (to build a contender in the next 3-4 years) is Nash the one piece we can't do without?

Or, are we better off trying to ply a forward like Stewart, JVR, Couturier etc that fits in better with our long term plan, while looking for band-aid goaltending help to get us into the playoff this year?
 
F*ck, why did i mention Sundin in my intial post? christ.... not the point I cared to argue about here.

If you can get Nash without giving up Kessel, Lups, Gardiner or Liles then you do it.

Really Liles? He'd be a deal breaker for you? That's crazy, and I don't even want Nash.
 
Or, are we better off trying to ply a forward like Stewart, JVR, Couturier etc that fits in better with our long term plan, while looking for band-aid goaltending help to get us into the playoff this year?

Excellent post.
Mind you, where do you get those 27 year old decline for a power forward numbers? Is there a stat kept somewhere for this that I am not aware of?



are we better off trying to ply a forward like Stewart
he will not help goaltending, which is our biggest need at the moment.

The Blues would be a great trading partner for the Leafs.
They have 1. a tradable goalie (Halak or Elliot, either of which would be better than the shit we can toss between the pipes)
2. Stewart.

What would it take to lure the Halak and Stewart away from the Blues?
 
Really Liles? He'd be a deal breaker for you? That's crazy, and I don't even want Nash.

Liles would be the last name on the list for me, but he is the only solid veteran puck moving defenseman we have.
No, its not really a deal breaker for me, you are correct, he doesnt really belong on the list.
I am a big Liles fan and think our PP success hinges a lot on him.
 
Excellent post.
Mind you, where do you get those 27 year old decline for a power forward numbers? Is there a stat kept somewhere for this that I am not aware of?



are we better off trying to ply a forward like Stewart
he will not help goaltending, which is our biggest need at the moment.

The Blues would be a great trading partner for the Leafs.
They have 1. a tradable goalie (Halak or Elliot, either of which would be better than the shit we can toss between the pipes)
2. Stewart.

What would it take to lure the Halak and Stewart away from the Blues?

A kidnapping and a ransom note.
 
I was watching one of your programs the other night looking for informative hockey information and came accross a segment featuring Craig Button and his expert opinion on the Rick Nash trade situation.


How do you people employ this boob and expect to be taken seriously as a quality sports network?...The man suggested Lupul, Gardiner, Kadri, Colborne, and a 1st for Rick Nash....When did Nash become Gretzky?...Seriously the dude has been on a 60 point pace for the past 2 seasons.


As if that isnt bad enough, he suggests the Kings need scoring, and should get Nash by giving up Kopitar in a deal?...thats borderline insane, not to mention Bernier and 2 firsts.


And it goes on, suggesting ridiculous pakcages from the Rangers and Bruins as well ( seguin and rask?...good lord).


It's as if this "analyst) hasn't read a stat sheet in 2 years. Let alone the fact that Nash has a pretty large contract.


It's no wonder he's a collossal failure as a GM.


The fact you people pay him to give hockey fans an "expert opinion" is a damn joke.


Sincerely


A hockey fan waiting out you firing this guy, or Sportsnet dumping Doug McLean.



This is the email i sent TSNrelations...i wonder if i get a response.
 
Excellent post.
Mind you, where do you get those 27 year old decline for a power forward numbers? Is there a stat kept somewhere for this that I am not aware of?
Look here ...

It's a high level stat analysis that basically suggests in post-lockout, forwards' production peaks at 25, and really declines past 28-29.

are we better off trying to ply a forward like Stewart
he will not help goaltending, which is our biggest need at the moment.

The Blues would be a great trading partner for the Leafs.
They have 1. a tradable goalie (Halak or Elliot, either of which would be better than the shit we can toss between the pipes)
2. Stewart.

What would it take to lure the Halak and Stewart away from the Blues?
Elliot is the young and better goalie from StL. He's their goalie of the future if he continues his development. They are not going to let Elliot go. You can forget about that one.

In an ideal world, they don't really want to let Halak go either. Elliot is having an amazing season but like all young goalies, you never know what happens next year. You don't want to gamble without a safety net. Halak is that safety net.

If you pay a high enough price, they *may* consider parting with Halak, but the question is do we REALLY want Halak?

I'd say no. Reason is Halak is a smallish goalie who, if you look at his stats, can post VERY good numbers (.920+) if he's limited to 35-40 games, but last season when the Blues gave him #1 duty he ended up being pretty average (.910SV%) ... if Burke believes Reimer is the goalie of future (and rightfully so, Reimer's only 23, like many young goalies they struggle in their sophomore season) and he wants to bring in Halak as the veteran to help share the load before Reimer's ready ... fine. But how much do you want to pay for a 1B goalie of that limited role?

Harding and Bishop are 2 goalies Burke can maybe target (now that NYI is pushing for playoff and won't trade Nabokov) if they can be had for cheap. From my perspective, I'm quite ready to write off Gustavsson (28, and only managed to post average stats in a backup role). I can be patient with Reimer (23, struggling in sophomore season after concussion) but we need help in net before the deadline.
 
Elliott is not a star goalie - he's barely a starting goalie.

He is simply benefitting from playing under Hitchcock just like Mason, Leclaire, ect.
 
I'd be happy with Halak#1 and Reimer #2 tandum. Give this Leafs team a .930 goalie for 40-50 games? Yes please.

I understand your point in regards to Harding and Bishop but I thought that the point of a trade for a goalie is to propel us to the playoffs this season. I have absolutely no faith whatsoever in either of our goalies taking this team deep into the playoffs.
I know there is a lot of positive people here for the future with Reimer, I am not one of them and I know that is not a popular opinion around these parts. I would love nothing more than for him to become our #1 for the next 10 years. I realize he is young and many a #1 goalie today started off the same way. I will remain optimistic in regards to Reimer though.
 
Elliot is the young and better goalie from StL. He's their goalie of the future if he continues his development. They are not going to let Elliot go. You can forget about that one.

halak and elliot are the same age.
 
Elliott has really said that his biggest change for his turnaround has come from his goalie coach in STL (Corey Hirsch), just telling him to get back to the basics to what made him successful earlier in his career.

Sounded like other coaches he had in the past were trying to change the way he played the game, and he was not able to succeed in the system they set up for him.

That being said, I don't think STL wants to or has any plans on trading him, especially after signing him to an extension. Same goes for Halak, really. They are gifted with one of the best 1/1a tandems in the league right now, and really have no reason to change that.
 
Back
Top