• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

i don't care what he said, elliot isn't a top notch starter. i don't even thikn he is a starting goaltender, to be honest.
 
I am just not sold on Halak. I have bad memories with smallish goalies who posted good #'s in a backup role ....

Give me Harding.
 
I definitely agree that I would not consider him a starter long term. He has certainly done a fine job this year as a 1a/1b type of goalie though.

Will be interesting to see what his role is next year, and how he adapts. Almost kind of reminds me of Craig Andersen moving from Col to Ottawa.
 
St-Louis would be foolish to trade one of their goalies. Neither has proven that they can be a starter on their own, but they are an elite tandem. And from the Leaf perspective, have people learned nothing from Toskala and Raycroft? No more paying a premium price to acquire goalies who haven't even proven they're starters.
 
Yes he is, but I don't expect Vokoun to sign with the leafs.

Vokoun has been a very good goalie for Washington, it'd be foolish to blame their sad season on him and let him go.

In any case, Vokoun will not re-sign for $1M ... he will easily fetch $5-6M long term deal in the market, and I'm not sure that's the direction we're going.
 
Elliott is solid, IMO. He's shown steady progress as a young pro, aside from his one disaster year last year.
 
I actually change the channel whenever one of these so-called "expert" panels comes on to try and provide their infallible analyses.

yep.

I've totally given up on the panels (and sports radio). They're all just ignorant, really.

Aside from Trade Rumours, they're useless.
 
it means that both he is overrated talentwise, and more importantly his specific skillset is still overrated amongst hockey people.

you are so full of crap.

he either sucks or he doesn't. stop putting Schenn in trade proposals for good players. nobody is moving a major star for a deal centred around bottom-pair defenceman that apparently only you can evaluate properly.
 
It's not crap to point our that there are overrated and underrated players in hockey.

look at Komi's contract.
 
Come'on Burke - get your deals done and lets get back to winning hockey games.

Toronto is BRUTAL around this time of year and it definitely affects some players on the ice.

Either push to get a deal done, or tell the boys that this is the team you believe in.
 
Yeah, I don't see how zeke's wrong here. If people around the league didn't massively overrate "the shut-down defenseman" (especially if he's "physical"), then you wouldn't see guys like Commodore, Komisarek, Volcheknov and Paul Martin getting huge deals thrown at them. For the same reason (and also because of his very young age) it's reasonable to assume that Luke Schenn has an over-inflated trade value around the league.
 
Its the same thing for a guy like JVR as a forward, or an even better example would be Wayne Simmonds....who is proving to people that he wasnt overrated, when LAK was demanding so much years ago, but years ago the stat line and performance didnt warrant the ask.
 
he's either a #6/#7 dman with no upside and limited talent, or he's the main piece in a deal that brings us a star centre or winger.

make up your mind.
 
For the record, Bob McKenzie was on TSN radio yesterday, and the hosts were trying to suggest everyone's asking for Gardiner and Schenn has no market. Bobby Mac was quick to point out while puck moving defensemen are a hot commodity, there is no shortage of interest in Luke Schenn because of his size, his age, and his physical plays. In fact Bobby M suggested Schenn will fetch quite a bit if Burke is willing to trade him.

And Stevie Y was talking about Kubina yesterday, saying he expects to get a reasonable return for Kubina because defensemen, to start off with, fetch a lot this time of the year. This is coming from a GM, not analysis.
 
Back
Top