• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Holy overrating JG Batman. I think you guys are clueless, but I'd love to be wrong on this one. He's no Erik Karlsson.

Maybe, but I don't think so. He's easily the best rookie Leafs dman I've ever seen.

His skillset is more reminscent of a niedermeyer or keith than karlsson, though.
 
Last edited:
Maybe, but I don't think so. He's easily the best rookie Leafs dman I've ever seen.

For sure. I remember watching Kaberle his first year..and thinking "Shit this guy makes so many mistakes" (he gave away the puck so often)...The next year he became so much better and rarely made any turnovers. With Jake, i don't even see it as much and unlike Kabs he isn't scared of shooting the puck(which is one part i didn't like about Kaberle).
 
Holy overrating JG Batman. I think you guys are clueless, but I'd love to be wrong on this one. He's no Erik Karlsson.

He is on pace for almost 30 pts, playing 22 minutes a game and is a +6 on a team who has been giving up their fair share of goals lately.

No is expecting him to be Erik Karlsson but when you have a dman who is capable of playing big minutes and has the hockey IQ with skating ability at his age, you don't let him go.
 
He is on pace for almost 30 pts, playing 22 minutes a game and is a +6 on a team who has been giving up their fair share of goals lately.

No is expecting him to be Erik Karlsson but when you have a dman who is capable of playing big minutes and has the hockey IQ with skating ability at his age, you don't let him go.
IMO - You don't let him go for nothing. Doesn't mean you keep him over an all-star like Nash.
 
IMO - You don't let him go for nothing. Doesn't mean you keep him over an all-star like Nash.

If this was a 21-23 year old Nash, i'd definitely think about it. With his contract and being late 20's, it is an easy no...especially with the fact as already mentioned, a player like Jake doesn't come around so often. Defensive position is one that is hardest to play so you want to keep your elite players (especially young ones).
 
If this was a 21-23 year old Nash, i'd definitely think about it. With his contract and being late 20's, it is an easy no...especially with the fact as already mentioned, a player like Jake doesn't come around so often. Defensive position is one that is hardest to play so you want to keep your elite players (especially young ones).

Rick Nash is 27 years old. Prime of his career. We all love Jake, it wouldn't be an easy deal to make but they are going to demand at least one of Gardiner or Schenn, among other things. I'd certainly hope they have a strong interest in Luke instead.

However, it wouldn't be the worst thing in the world if Burke could effectively turn Beauchemin into Lupul and Nash.
 
So what do you guys think Jake's upside is?

Dobber has him at 10-40-50+, 65 PIM's. 3YP, 7-30-37, 50 PIM

Sounds a lot like Liles' upside to me, whom we got when he was established for a 2nd round pick.
 
yes but Liles had a heftier contract (though still very fair) and has more softness and defense questions than I think Gardiner will ever have. I don't think those questions are justified, but they were there. Liles also has an injury history. Plus we pretty much committed robbery getting Liles.

If Gardiner puts up 50 point seasons he'd likely be worth way more than a 2nd rounder.
 
So what do you guys think Jake's upside is?

Dobber has him at 10-40-50+, 65 PIM's. 3YP, 7-30-37, 50 PIM

Sounds a lot like Liles' upside to me, whom we got when he was established for a 2nd round pick.

that's a pretty ridiculous way of reaching that conclusion.

i mean, having watched both play now for more than half a season, do you really see them as comparable talents?

outside of numbers there isn't much of a comparison to be made.

i mean, this is pretty much akin to saying that liles = suter.. i mean, their numbers are similar, right?
 
yes but Liles had a heftier contract (though still very fair) and has more softness and defense questions than I think Gardiner will ever have. I don't think those questions are justified, but they were there. Liles also has an injury history. Plus we pretty much committed robbery getting Liles.

If Gardiner puts up 50 point seasons he'd likely be worth way more than a 2nd rounder.

likely?
 
So what do you guys think Jake's upside is?

Dobber has him at 10-40-50+, 65 PIM's. 3YP, 7-30-37, 50 PIM

Sounds a lot like Liles' upside to me, whom we got when he was established for a 2nd round pick.

upside?

keith. maybe niedermayer.
 

Liles put up 46 in 76 last year, so basically 50 points. So yeah a slick skating 50 point offensive d-man could go for a 2nd rounder... but I also said "way more than." I'm 99% agreeing with you. I was pointing out why Liles for a 2nd rounder wasn't a good comparable despite statistical and even style comparisons.
 
that's a pretty ridiculous way of reaching that conclusion.

i mean, having watched both play now for more than half a season, do you really see them as comparable talents?

outside of numbers there isn't much of a comparison to be made.

i mean, this is pretty much akin to saying that liles = suter.. i mean, their numbers are similar, right?

Tell me what you really mean.
 
that's a pretty ridiculous way of reaching that conclusion.

i mean, having watched both play now for more than half a season, do you really see them as comparable talents?

Oooooh a half a season. That's a pretty ridiculous way of reaching YOUR conclusion.

I'm just showing market value for defensemen. Saying no to Nash because of Gardiner is based on pure and utter Leaf Goggles IMO. If you choose to have a different opinion, or think he's the next Niedermayer, then go for it. Please note that hockey players trajectories are not linear, as in they do not always go up or stay at the current level of production. Maybe Gardiner has limited offensive upside and will be a 40-45pt D-man in his prime, with great passing ability. This is not someone I would want to move, but to get a top line all star forward I'd do it in a heart beat.
 
This is the problem with a lot (not all) leaf fans is their spoiled, they think they can demand getting good to great players without giving up much in return. Look, Nash isn't an elite player but he is a really good NHL'er and if Columbus wants Gardiner then Burke should at least consider it, because really its a fair deal. That being said I wouldn't trade for Nash, not because he isnt a good player but because we already have a decent enough top 6, I'd rather focus on building this team as a defensive juggnernaut, and that means keeping Gardiner.
 
This is the problem with a lot (not all) leaf fans is their spoiled, they think they can demand getting good to great players without giving up much in return. Look, Nash isn't an elite player but he is a really good NHL'er and if Columbus wants Gardiner then Burke should at least consider it, because really its a fair deal. That being said I wouldn't trade for Nash, not because he isnt a good player but because we already have a decent enough top 6, I'd rather focus on building this team as a defensive juggnernaut, and that means keeping Gardiner.

Leafs fans are spoiled?

Dear God I hope that is not the case because I can't imagine what it would feel like being a Red Wings fan.
 
If I were burke I'd push very very hard to replace Gardiner with Schenn in the trade ... I'd do Schenn + instead of Gardiner.

At the end of the day, if Howsen says "Gardiner or no deal" then would I trade Gardiner?

I think I won't ... for a few reasons

1. Nash is 27, not 24 or 25
2. Nash is a winger, not a center
3. Nash is poor in his own end
4. There's something about Nash's drive and his passion to win that concerns me ... if he didn't sign that long term deal to stay in Columbus I'd feel better about him

It's never easy to pass on a star top 6 forward but Nash isn't a perfect fit and Gardiner is a STEEP price to pay.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top