• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Oooooh a half a season. That's a pretty ridiculous way of reaching YOUR conclusion.

I'm just showing market value for defensemen. Saying no to Nash because of Gardiner is based on pure and utter Leaf Goggles IMO. If you choose to have a different opinion, or think he's the next Niedermayer, then go for it. Please note that hockey players trajectories are not linear, as in they do not always go up or stay at the current level of production. Maybe Gardiner has limited offensive upside and will be a 40-45pt D-man in his prime, with great passing ability. This is not someone I would want to move, but to get a top line all star forward I'd do it in a heart beat.

We already traded away Neidermayer once. If we are lucky enough to have found another one I don't want to do that again and I am willing to take the chance that Gardiner turns into something special for us
 
I really liken Gardiner to Kaberle, in the sense that he came in a rookie and just has looked great. I really would like to keep a young player and make him a leaf forever. The same can be said for Schenn, but the skillset is what is tempting.
 
For sure. I remember watching Kaberle his first year..and thinking "Shit this guy makes so many mistakes" (he gave away the puck so often)...The next year he became so much better and rarely made any turnovers. With Jake, i don't even see it as much and unlike Kabs he isn't scared of shooting the puck(which is one part i didn't like about Kaberle).

Just curious, how old were you when Kaberle played his first season (1998)?
 
Just curious, how old were you when Kaberle played his first season (1998)?

I was around 17 BG, why? Don't get me wrong, the guy was a smooth skater and showed great vision. I just thought his decision making ability wasn't very good in that first year...which is normal as pretty much all rookies do that.
 
Simply put, I would unconditionally say no to trading Gardner in a package for Nash.

I don't think Nash is good enough for it to be worth it, especially at that cap hit.
 
I think Nash is the issue.... I don't think people would be so unsure if someone said would you put Gardiner in a package for Getzlaf. (Now I know that Anaheim wouldn't do that, but the main problem I think people are having is letting Gardiner go for a 27 year old winger, when a centre would be ideal.
 
I changed my mind on trading for Nash. Here is a quote from Burke:

"Some GMs remind me of the guy who goes to the grocery store without a list. I never go to the grocery store without a list. I might buy a bag of beef jerky that's not on the list, or I might by a ****ing Swanson TV dinner that's not on the list, but I'm not going to buy 50 things that aren't on the list. There's discipline involved. We aleays go shopping with a list. Some of the moves by other GMs make you think, 'Why the **** would they do that?' All of a sudden when a guy is available, they'll say, 'Okay, yes let's get him.' I don't get that. Where's the ****ing blueprint? I think some of the GMs drift a little bit until they figure it out."

Nash isn't what the Leafs need. They already have two goal scoring wingers that are as least as good, if not better, and cheaper than him. This team need a big center and goaltending. Unless you are getting one of those things I'd continue to hold onto their assets and build from within. Nash would be a good Nolan-esq addition if they were one or two pieces away. But they are still missing a couple of foundation pieces, and they need to save up their assets to get those, whether its from development within, or a trade down the road. But guys like Kadri or Colborne could one day be the center this team is looking for. Nash never will be.

Stay the course.
 
As for Gardiner the most exciting part of his game and potential isn't his offense. It's his defense. He has all the tools to be a Keith, Bouwmeester or Neidermayer in his own end and has shown signs of becoming that player. If he can become an elite 50-60 point offensive guy on top of that, then that is just a bonus, but it is looking like he has that kind of potential too.

I wouldn't trade a defenseman who has a high hockey IQ, can skate and handle the puck like that period. Not for Nash. Not for Getzlaf. Only in a package for a guy like Keith. To me Gardiner's upside is the most valuable kind of player you can have aside from a goalie.
 
Oooooh a half a season. That's a pretty ridiculous way of reaching YOUR conclusion.

I'm just showing market value for defensemen. Saying no to Nash because of Gardiner is based on pure and utter Leaf Goggles IMO. If you choose to have a different opinion, or think he's the next Niedermayer, then go for it. Please note that hockey players trajectories are not linear, as in they do not always go up or stay at the current level of production. Maybe Gardiner has limited offensive upside and will be a 40-45pt D-man in his prime, with great passing ability. This is not someone I would want to move, but to get a top line all star forward I'd do it in a heart beat.

Having watched Gardiner and Liles play for 40+ games each, it is pretty clear that they are not similar hockey players. Not in style and, outside of Gardiner's potential to produce similar numbers, not really in substance either.

As for showing market value for defensemen, you have done no such thing. In effect, all you have argued is that the trade value of one 50 point defenseman is equal to the trade value of all 50 point defensemen, which isn't really showing market value at all because trades don't happen in a vacuum.

Tomas Kaberle, a similar player in every way imaginable to Liles, was traded for a first round pick and a prospect recently selected in the first round mere months before the Liles trade. Francois Beauchemin, a #2 or #3 defenseman, was traded for Gardiner and Lupul as well. Do those establish 'market value for defensemen'? No. Obviously not. Otherwise Liles wouldn't have been traded for a 2nd.

It's a pretty silly, inherently faulty argument that makes some very strange assumptions... unless you think that Jake Gardiner is a carbon copy of Liles and that situations like the ones that landed the Leafs Liles are the norm (they aren't, as the Kaberle trade attests).
 
ya pkforce is totally full of shit with that kaberle statement. or maybe he's thinking of yannick tremblay.
 
Having watched Gardiner and Liles play for 40+ games each, it is pretty clear that they are not similar hockey players. Not in style and, outside of Gardiner's potential to produce similar numbers, not really in substance either.

As for showing market value for defensemen, you have done no such thing. In effect, all you have argued is that the trade value of one 50 point defenseman is equal to the trade value of all 50 point defensemen, which isn't really showing market value at all because trades don't happen in a vacuum.

Tomas Kaberle, a similar player in every way imaginable to Liles, was traded for a first round pick and a prospect recently selected in the first round mere months before the Liles trade. Francois Beauchemin, a #2 or #3 defenseman, was traded for Gardiner and Lupul as well. Do those establish 'market value for defensemen'? No. Obviously not. Otherwise Liles wouldn't have been traded for a 2nd.

It's a pretty silly, inherently faulty argument that makes some very strange assumptions... unless you think that Jake Gardiner is a carbon copy of Liles and that situations like the ones that landed the Leafs Liles are the norm (they aren't, as the Kaberle trade attests).
You are using Kaberle as your argument? The dude who was just traded for a bag of pucks? I think JG may one day be like Liles, and hasn't proven he will be as good, let alone better, do to one above average half season.

Let's give him 3 years to see if he plateau's, regresses, or improves. As for now, he's no all star and if we want to trade for an all star, we shouldn't hold back due to potential.
 
You are using Kaberle as your argument? The dude who was just traded for a bag of pucks?

the dude who was also just traded for a 1st round pick and joe colborne.

his value plummeted because of the subsequent quality of his play.

I think JG may one day be like Liles, and hasn't proven he will be as good, let alone better, do to one above average half season.

you are fundamentally misunderstanding the argument.

i don't really care to argue which of the two is better right now. liles is a 31 year old 8 year vet while gardiner is a 21 year old rookie.

the question is whether or not they are similarly styled hockey players. and they just aren't. if you want to act like the only thing that comes into the equation is production when judging a defenseman's value then good for you, but obviously that isn't the case.

i'm not really sure i agree entirely with leafman and zeke about gardiner's upside (or at least, the likelihood of him reaching such lofty heights), but if you see gardiner as a guy in the mold of a niedermayer, suter or keith then it would be ridiculous to trade him now because you can simply acquire another offensive defenseman down the line for a 2nd round pick.
 
Over value JG all you guys want. I don't really care. He's not the second coming, he's not an all star and he's a rookie with half a season under his belt.
 
JG has done nothing in the NHL that says he shouldn't be moved for an all star. If you believe otherwise, you may be Pronger84.
 
Some people just have foresight. If the Leafs traded Gardiner for Nash would they be a better team today? Of course. But they aren't winning the cup this year so why do we care about today?
 
If the Leafs traded Gardiner for Nash, they would improve their team. Now and for the foreseeable future.

I'm sick of debating this.
 
427381_10150544115401109_506331108_9005000_951656409_n.jpg
 
Back
Top