• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Carter Ashton's WHL and AHL numbers dont inspire confidence, but maybe he can be a late bloomer and develop into a decent 2nd/3rd line PF.

I think I'd rather have Aulie though. He's already shown he can play at a reasonable high level at the NHL level.
 
not a huge fan of moving aulie but this is the type of deal we should be making. dealing from a position of strength to fill a position of weakness
 
not a huge fan, but our defense is all locked up so I guess it makes sense.

Ashton is having a decent rookie AHL year at age 20, and is probably a 3rd liner but has some 2nd line upside.
 
Is this a good move guys?..For those who know about the young players...I kinda liked Aulie. He'll help Tampa for sure.

Nope as far as I'm concerned, Burkes two biggest needs are a goaltender and a top 6 with size who can play now. He failed to accomplish either in this deal, which doesn't do anything for the leafs this year. That being said, down the road this move could turn out well in the long run, Eakins has a diamond in the rough here and with any luck this player can turn out to be a solid top 6'er.
 
Ashton is a similar prospect to Aulie. He's never going to be a first liner. But he can be a 20 goal 2nd/3rd liner, and he is a big body on the wing which they need.

Its trading from a position of strength for a guy at a position of weakness. Aulie isn't playing here, and probably wouldn't in the immediate future.
 
not a huge fan of moving aulie but this is the type of deal we should be making. dealing from a position of strength to fill a position of weakness

Keith Aulie was one of the main reasons trading Luke Schenn made some sense. Aulie could have potentially brought everything Schenn did on the defensive side of the puck minus the elite physicality. Now if we trade Schenn to get an elite forward, who do we replace him with?

For Carter ****ing Ashton?
 
First round picks:

2008 - Schenn, Colborne, Gardiner
2009 - Kadri, Ashton
2010 -N/A
2011 - Biggs. Percy

7 first round picks in the last 4 years.
 
Nope as far as I'm concerned, Burkes two biggest needs are a goaltender and a top 6 with size who can play now. He failed to accomplish either in this deal, which doesn't do anything for the leafs this year. That being said, down the road this move could turn out well in the long run, Eakins has a diamond in the rough here and with any luck this player can turn out to be a solid top 6'er.

Just because he made a minor league, as opposed to getting help now doesnt make it a bad deal.

It's a bad deal if you think Aulie is better down the road for the club then Ashton is.

It would be like saying me dealing a ripe tomato for some string beans is a bad decision because i should be looking for poultry.
 
not a huge fan of moving aulie but this is the type of deal we should be making. dealing from a position of strength to fill a position of weakness

Agreed.

It's pretty evident that Burke is looking to build this team himself and doesn't want any outside help(unless he can rape someone)...so i guess we'll have to wait for all the things to come together. I like the fact we have Colborne at 6'5 and now this guy is 6'3..If at least one can become a good top 6 player i'll be happy.
 
Keith Aulie was one of the main reasons trading Luke Schenn made some sense. Aulie could have potentially brought everything Schenn did on the defensive side of the puck minus the elite physicality. Now if we trade Schenn to get an elite forward, who do we replace him with?

For Carter ****ing Ashton?

Yeah, this.
 
Back
Top