• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

This Burke loyalty helps him sign players to favourable contracts

Yes thats one of the upsides of his loyalty. That being said, his job as a GM is to identify weaknesses on the team and find upgrades for them whether it be a goaltending upgrade, a coaching trade, or even a front office hiring/firing. Burkes loyatly should be to the leafs, not just a select group of individuals.
 
Yes thats one of the upsides of his loyalty. That being said, his job as a GM is to identify weaknesses on the team and find upgrades for them whether it be a goaltending upgrade, a coaching trade, or even a front office hiring/firing. Burkes loyatly should be to the leafs, not just a select group of individuals.
One must walk a fine line. I think Burke's done an admirable job in one of (if not THE) most critical hockey market in the world.
 
One must walk a fine line. I think Burke's done an admirable job in one of (if not THE) most critical hockey market in the world.

Burke's been amazing when it comes to trades and when it comes to contracts those are where he's at his best. However, his inability to realize that goaltending is a weak point and his inability to seperate pleasure from business when it comes to Wilson are his two biggest downfalls as a GM.
 
Burke's been amazing when it comes to trades and when it comes to contracts those are where he's at his best. However, his inability to realize that goaltending is a weak point and his inability to seperate pleasure from business when it comes to Wilson are his two biggest downfalls as a GM.
You honestly think Burke doesn't realize goaltending and coaching haven't been questionable? Yes, he is loyal, but the man is not an idiot when it comes to hockey IQ. Can anyone here honestly say with a straight face that Josh Harding is the answer to all our problems?
 
You honestly think Burke doesn't realize goaltending and coaching haven't been questionable? Yes, he is loyal, but the man is not an idiot when it comes to hockey IQ. Can anyone here honestly say with a straight face that Josh Harding is the answer to all our problems?

I never said his hockey sense is lacking, actually he's a genius in terms of hockey IQ. I really think Burke is in denial about Wilson, he feels if he fires him then he is ruining their friendship, which is complete BS because he should be doing whats right for the leafs and not whats right for Ron Wilson. I never said Harding is our long term answer either, I just think an upgrade in goal will help us THIS year, next year is a whole new animal.
 
At bare minimum Harding would be a considerable improvement over Gustavsson as the Leafs second option even if they plan to run with Reimer during the majority of matches down the stretch run.
 
I never said his hockey sense is lacking, actually he's a genius in terms of hockey IQ. I really think Burke is in denial about Wilson, he feels if he fires him then he is ruining their friendship, which is complete BS because he should be doing whats right for the leafs and not whats right for Ron Wilson. I never said Harding is our long term answer either, I just think an upgrade in goal will help us THIS year, next year is a whole new animal.

All I see here is you forming an opinion based off your own made up speculation.
 
At bare minimum Harding would be a considerable improvement over Gustavsson as the Leafs second option even if they plan to run with Reimer during the majority of matches down the stretch run.

Yup! Gus has shown he needs a long stretch to warm up and stay warm, he doesnt do well in spits and spurts starts. Harding would make a much better backup option this season then Gus, but then again Burke is more intent on going down with the ship instead of saving it.
 
Harding would def be an upgrade for THIS season. heck if you can even resign him and keep him as the backup/split goaltending with Reimer it is a step in the right direction.
 
All I see here is you forming an opinion based off your own made up speculation.

How is any of it speculation? And yes it's my opinion which I'm entitled to have, never said it was "fact", if you want to disagree with it go right ahead.
 
How is any of it speculation? And yes it's my opinion which I'm entitled to have, never said it was "fact", if you want to disagree with it go right ahead.

I really think Burke is in denial about Wilson, he feels if he fires him then he is ruining their friendship, which is complete BS because he should be doing whats right for the leafs and not whats right for Ron Wilson.

This
 
1.) Rated is correct in pointing out that Pronger engaged in speculation, which he denied in that aforementioned post.

2.) Pronger is correct in that he never stated that it was factual. If he's trying to pass a potentially accurate theory off as fact that's fine, but I don't think he did that in this instance. It's more than feasible to believe that Burke's relationship with Wilson is clouded by nepotism and therefore his judgement on the issue is unsound.
 
All I said was is he's forming opinions based off shit he's making up. I wouldn't make the mistake for claiming anything P84 says is fact lol
 
I guess one thing you could say in Burke's favour is that Harding is currently out with an undisclosed injury. Who knows how much longer he'll be out, and whether it's an injury that could continue to affect his play when he does get back?
Yes I guess ... and I guess it's also true we gotta take what Dreger said with a grain of salt. Bishop went for a 2nd + ... so Harding would probably fetch significantly more.

Still, failing to bring in a goalie and just go with 2 goalies whose recent performance is making life so difficult for his coach is a failure on Burke's behalf.

And if they continue to go with those 2, without calling up Scrivens that is the 2nd mistake.

I mean, I agree with Burke reimer is the future. How do you think being boo'ed at home and feeling the pressure every single second is doing for the development of the 23 year old goalie? He is pushed out there to do a job he's really been struggling with, ever since coming back from concussion, and he has no support and no safety net. Every game is a must win. Imagine yourself in his shoes.

Young goalies (and players in general) need support to develop. Baptism by fire should be a desperate measure, not the default route to develop young players. You can't just put a group of young inexperienced players together and let them fall without any mentorship, without shielding and hiding them when the going gets tough.
 
As much as I hate JFJ, those horror trades he made were probably not fully his doing although he had a lot to do with it. It would be safe to assume that our scouts at the time actually believed Raycroft and Toskala would be starters.

Boy were they wrong.

scouts who were hired by JFJ...
 
Dreger just said the Leafs kicked the tires on Josh Harding but didn't like the asking price of a 2nd round pick

I think Dreger is full of shit.......when Burke was asked about the goaltending market in today's press conference, he replied there was nothing available that they had to spend any time considering.

I suspect that the only real option that was made available to him, was likely Khabibulin........had Harding been offered, particularly at that price, it's a guarantee that Burke and co. would have at least discussed/considered it.
 
I think Dreger is full of shit.......when Burke was asked about the goaltending market in today's press conference, he replied there was nothing available that they had to spend any time considering.

I suspect that the only real option that was made available to him, was likely Khabibulin........had Harding been offered, particularly at that price, it's a guarantee that Burke and co. would have at least discussed/considered it.

Yeah if Harding was out there for a 2nd...where was Philly and Chicago on that too?
 
True that ... Philly would sure love to have Harding in the fold at the right price ... if nothing else it gives them 1 more option.

That said, you gotta wonder about teams like MIN, who would rather lose Harding for nothing in the off-season than to get a 2nd rounder for him. You can tell yourself you should get more, considering even Bishop went for 2nd+, but anything is better than nothing right?


Anyways, just want to point out riding in my friend's car last night, I was very unfortunate to have to listen to Bob McCowan on FAN590 cos that's what my friend had on the radio ... and no surprise, he spent the entire time blasting the Leafs. First a fan called in and said he's not disappointed Burke didn't do anything, because the going price was crazy and no move is better than bad moves. McCowan said "No, you ARE disappointed. You are just not surprised the Leafs, as usual, did nothing ... but you're surely disappointed if you're a fan. I can't care less." ... then another caller called in and said it's a young team, you gotta give them time to develop. McCowan said "Young has no value if you suck. There's no difference between losing with a 32 year old team and losing as a 22 year old team." (really? Interesting, cos most people think 22 year olds have an upside to mature and develop, but just not Bob McCowan)

He goes on to use Schenn as an example. "Look at Schenn. He is young alright, but he not only didn't develop, but he REGRESSED from his rookie season, 4 years in a row now." The caller pointed out Schenn is taking the path of what many young defensemen are taking, and McCowan said "I've seen other defensemen develop, and I don't see that from Schenn. It's a fact other GMs think that way too, because Schenn has no value." Cox immediately said "Schenn was offered multiple offers, including 1st round picks and prospects from what I've heard." and McCowan dismissed that "It didn't happen did it? Rumors are for losers."

Then he went on to say Kadri has no value. He said you can't even get a 2nd rounder for Kadri today because "he's a bust for all intents and purposes. If you can't crack this lineup then you're not going to make the NHL."

That's the point I put my headphones on and listened to music instead ... I wish McCowan has the balls to say the same to Burke when Burke goes on the show, which he never does.
 
Back
Top