• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Well, there's that and Luongo's limited options. I mean, I'm sure Columbus will stick their noses in...and if he wants to go there...well, have at it.
 
I wonder which Damospin we're going to get on this one...he seems to alternate between being very solid, and a mindless shit disturber. I guess it depends on how many page views his contracts require him to get. If he's short for the month, he'll be an epic shit disturber.
 
i'd be willing to bet cox is critical of a potential luongo pick up. that way if it doesn't happen he can play the 'see, i told you to temper your expectations' card. if it does happen but doesn't work he can say 'i told you so'. and if he were acquired and was awesome... people will be too engrossed with that to remember that damien cox said not to do it.
 
James Mirtle
I can't see any way Luongo wants to go from one nuthouse to a bigger one. Why would he waive a no-trade clause to play in Toronto?


Mirtle ostencibly says he thinks Luongo is gutless and scared of the media......makingcomment claim of Toronto being a bigger "nuthouse", a bit of a self fulfilling profecy.


Shrewd.
 
I wonder which Damospin we're going to get on this one...he seems to alternate between being very solid, and a mindless shit disturber. I guess it depends on how many page views his contracts require him to get. If he's short for the month, he'll be an epic shit disturber.

http://www.thestar.com/sports/hocke...-poses-awkward-questions-for-maple-leafs?bn=1
It seems a hypothetical hockey trade tailor-made for the needs and resources of the Maple Leafs.

But that doesn’t mean MLSE hockey mandarins will want any part of it.

More to the point, the Vancouver Canucks may have little or no interest in even considering trading goaltender Roberto Luongo to the Leafs, if only because watching Luongo star for the hated Torontonians every Saturday night on national television could be a difficult pill for already unhappy Vancouver fans to swallow.

Still, this is tasty grist for the mill, with Luongo adding to the discussion on Tuesday by indicating he’d be willing to waive the no-trade element of his mammoth contract if the Canucks would like to move him in the wake of a very disappointing playoff defeat to Los Angeles.

When it comes to the Leafs, it’s not a simple yes or no when it comes to gauging their interest in the veteran goalie, and you can be certain Brian Burke, Dave Nonis et al won’t be saying much publicly after the charges of tampering hurled their way by Vancouver GM Mike Gillis several years ago.

So let’s run through the issues:

• Could Luongo help the Leafs?

Certainly. He’d be an upgrade on anything they currently have, and the organization seems divided on whether James Reimer still can be considered a candidate to become a No. 1 goalie in the NHL.

• Is Luongo in his prime?

Nope. But he’s still very good at age 33, and while he was replaced by Cory Schneider in the series against the Kings, that was after two games in which he played very well.

He’s still in the top third of NHL goalies. In the East, he’d probably be in the top five, which might get you to the playoffs for the conceivable future.

• Is the contract a crippling deal to any team?

Actually, it’s cap friendly at $5.33 million for the next 10 years. The catch is the actual salary is $6.7 million for the next six years, then it drops to $3.4 million, then to $1.6 million, then to $1 million for each of the final two years.

So really, you can look at it as a six-year deal, with a buyout of the final four years and $7 million to occur at age 39. That’s the way many assume the contract was expected to work when Luongo signed it.

But while many teams might not mind the cap hit, many would mind laying out more than $40 million in actual dollars over the next six years.

The Leafs, of course, that could handle the cash flow.

• Hasn’t Burke made it clear he is against this type of “backsliding” contract?

Absolutely. He says he won’t negotiate this kind of contract, and he was the only NHL executive who testified against the New Jersey Devils and the Ilya Kovalchuk deal when it went to arbitration.

That, however, doesn’t mean he might not be willing to alter that philosophy, or at least accept a contract that he wasn’t a party to signing. He may be coming around to the belief that while his stance is noble, it could be putting the Leafs at a competitive disadvantage.

• Would the Leafs have to surrender their first-round pick, fifth overall, in the entry draft or a top youngster like Jake Gardiner to do the deal?

Absolutely not. The belief around the league is that the Canucks would not get much of a return, if anything at all, for moving the contract.

• Wouldn’t it be a better play to go after Cory Schneider, the other Canucks goalie?

Maybe. But it’s expected the Canucks will want to keep the 26-year-old. If traded, Schneider would cost much more in terms of assets, and he’s also an unrestricted free agent after next season. Until he agrees to a multi-year deal, no team will want to surrender a great deal for what might be a one-year rental.

• With the current collective bargaining agreement set to expire at the conclusion of this season, could a new CBA make the Luongo contract easier to move?

Theoretically. Burke, interestingly, is one of the GMs leading the call for teams to be able to “eat” money in a deal. In other words, teams would be able to move a $2-million-a-year player and the cap hit while paying $1 million of the salary. Currently, that’s not legal.

• Is Luongo the best option for the Leafs to get a true No. 1 goalie?

While Luongo on his own will create some fierce discussions within the Leaf hockey office — remember, Nonis was the Vancouver GM who acquired him — a greater debate could be created if other name netminders become available.

Can St. Louis keep both Jaroslav Halak and Brian Elliott? If Pittsburgh wants to sign Jordan Staal, could the Pens move Marc-Andre Fleury, who had a brutal playoff series against Philadelphia? What is Miikka Kiprusoff’s future in Calgary? Will Nikolai Khabibulin be in Edmonton next fall? Is Columbus ready to throw in the towel on Steve Mason? Might Buffalo be ready to trade Ryan Miller after all?

Until the Leafs and other NHL clubs looking for goaltending know the identities of all the goalies who may be available, it’s impossible to measure Luongo’s value against them.

So, all in all, it’s complicated. The Leafs very much need to find a real answer in net. Luongo could be that answer, but a better one may emerge.
 
Mirtle ostencibly says he thinks Luongo is gutless and scared of the media......makingcomment claim of Toronto being a bigger "nuthouse", a bit of a self fulfilling profecy.


Shrewd.

His point is based on a flawed premise. He is assuming that Luongo doesn't want to stay in Vancouver because of the pressure. He doesn't want to stay in Vancouver because he is the backup now. He never had a problem with Vancouver until Schneider replaced him last week.
 
To change the topic slightly: if St-Louis goes on a long playoff run with Brian Elliott continuing to play sublimely in net, and they decide that they can afford to trade away Jaroslav Halak in the off-season, what would the Luongo boosters think about acquiring Halak as an alternative to Luongo and his bloated contract?
 
I would much rather have Luongo.

Halak is good, but I'm not interested in paying $4 million a year for a good goaltender if I can have one of the best goaltenders for $5.
 
Of all the names Cox's mentioned (Halak, MAF, Mason, Khabibulan, Kiprusoff) no question Luongo is the best goalie. If that is the complete list, then let's go for Bobby Lou.

Mason might not be a bad gamble seeing how Mike Smith has rebounded nicely, and even Clemmensen is playing great for Florida, but that's not for us. We're way past the point of taking another gamble in goal. Plus, I'd much, much rather gamble with Reimer, Scrivens, or even Bishop (who was available) than Mason.

Luongo is better than MAF. MAF has shown a steady decline it is scary. And, Pittsburgh is not parting with MAF. Don't be silly.

Halak is a smallish goalie, not going to go with him as our #1. I will not touch Khabibulan with a 10' pole.

So if that is the list, let's just go for Bobby.

Cox seems to suggest it will take very little to get Luongo ... not even a decent prospect according to him. I doubt that is true, but we shall find out.

And as for Mirtle, I think he has a good point, and that's what I was trying to say. Luongo might not WANT to leave Vancouver, but judging from the way he interacted with the media in Vancouver can you say he enjoyed the spotlight?? If he has to move now, and he has a say in where he goes, I doubt he would put another media-crazy city on top of his list.
 
The assets we would have to give up for a goalie like Halak would also make a deal for Luongo much more favourable.
 
Only goaltender who could be made available that I would consider on the same level and Lou would be Thomas, and he is only made available if Bos decides to run with Rask.

on another interesting note: the eating of money in trades... that could really benefit us. If we can eat salary that makes Komi, Army, Lombo all attractive pieces to teams who need to hit the cap floor.
 
It also makes us more attractive in free agency to veteran players. It would allow us to be a little bit more free wheeling with additional contract years. For example, Shane Doan would be a great get for us this summer...if the bidding for him is tight, it would be nice to be able to throw a 3rd year out there knowing that we can just pay the Islanders, etc to take him off of our hands at the beginning of that 3rd year if he's no longer worth the cap hit to us.
 
I would much rather have Luongo.

Halak is good, but I'm not interested in paying $4 million a year for a good goaltender if I can have one of the best goaltenders for $5.

This. A fairly young quality goaltender is an attractive option, but an all-world goalie is even better.

The small difference in salary and cap savings doesn't make up for the level of consistently high-end performance and track record advantage that Luongo possesses over Halak.

The latter is a quality goaltender and much younger, but if the Leafs are going to be giving up assets, and Halak would not doubt be more expensive in that regard than Luongo, they would ideally look to acquire the best available goaltender possible rather than going for the more "economical" option yet again. Go for the elite, proven, franchise goaltender. They come around so infrequently that when you have the opportunity to add one at minimal cost, as Luongo would, you have to take advantage of that fact.
 
Luongo is better than MAF. MAF has shown a steady decline it is scary. And, Pittsburgh is not parting with MAF. Don't be silly.

I agree entirely with most of the rest of the content of your post, 17, but I'm a little confused as to how you came to the aforementioned conclusion.

Fleury's last four seasons:

2008-09: 62 GP, 35 wins, 18 losses, 7 OTL, .912 save percentage, 4 shutouts, 11.9 goalie point shares.
2009-10: 67 GP, 37 wins, 21 losses, 6 OTL, .905 save percentage, 1 shutouts, 9.40 goalie point shares.
2010-11: 65 GP, 36 wins, 20 losses, 5 OTL, .918 save percentage, 3 shutouts, 11.4 goalie point shares.
2011-12: 67 GP, 42 wins, 17 losses, 4 OTL, .913 save percentage, 3 shutouts, 10.7 goalie point shares.

Looks pretty consistent to me.

Let's not let one poor (okay, exceedingly poor) post-season series cloud one's opinion of Fleury. He is a very solid, good, albeit not elite, goaltender. The Flyers teeing off on him for six games in which everything was clicking on all cylinders for them does not change that fact IMO.
 
Halak is one of those goalies who appears to play worse, the more he plays. It should come as no surprise that he's played the best hockey of his career in a platoon situation, and the worst as the undisputed #1 guy. Keep him around 40-45 starts and he's lights out.

Which means that he's over priced at his contract....

Just give me the guy who can play 60-70 games if necessary.
 
and yeah, Fleury is consistently good...but just good. He's over rated in the same way Ryan Miller is...but at least Miller has that one insane season on his resume.
 
and yeah, Fleury is consistently good...but just good. He's over rated in the same way Ryan Miller is...but at least Miller has that one insane season on his resume.

Fleury and Miller are definitely in that tier of good, not great, goaltenders. But you're right that Miller's 2010 season is the outlier between the two and gives him the edge to date.

Fleury was fantastic in Pittsburgh's run to the 2008 Finals though (.933 mark that playoffs).
 
Last edited:
Back
Top