• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Fleury has been perpetually overrated since his #1 draft slot and his SC ring. The truth is much closer to what ME has pointed out, Fleury is an above average goalie capable of going on prolonged hot streaks of elite-level play, but also capable of shitting the bed for a period of games.

He's one of those guys that in any given year could likely crack the top-10 in SV% but isn't a guy like Lou or Hank who you will consistently find there.
 
The more i think about it the more i am endorsing 1 of these 2 scenerios for the Hawks

1) Hossa for Luongo, go after Parise
2) Seabrook for Staal, go after Suter and Vokoun
 
and you think the odds of Vancouver dealing Luongo to Chicago are....what exactly?

Which still of course, wouldn't explain #2...which has exactly nothing to do with Luongo, or the Leafs.
 
and you think the odds of Vancouver dealing Luongo to Chicago are....what exactly?

Which still of course, wouldn't explain #2...which has exactly nothing to do with Luongo, or the Leafs.

1) I would rank them a distant 3rd behind tampa who is 2nd behind toronto as possibilities

2) havng a Luongo proposal has plenty to do with a Luongo discussion.
 
only "Seabrook for Staal...the go after Suter & Vokoun" has absolutely 0 to do with the Leafs, or Luongo.

As for ranking Chicago a distant 3rd to T-Bay & Toronto....surely you must agree that Gillis would rather schedule himself in for unnecessary rectal surgery than trade a top flite goalie to Chicago.
 
only "Seabrook for Staal...the go after Suter & Vokoun" has absolutely 0 to do with the Leafs, or Luongo.

As for ranking Chicago a distant 3rd to T-Bay & Toronto....surely you must agree that Gillis would rather schedule himself in for unnecessary rectal surgery than trade a top flite goalie to Chicago.

Unless the offer was too good to pass up ( Hossa) the 100% i agree.
 
I don't know if they would consider flipping a 10 year 5.3 million dollar contract for another 5.3 million dollar, 10 year contract to be "too good to pass up"

A large part of the necessity here is in clearing cap space to sign Schneider to the long term deal they should be signing him to.
 
I could see a Hossa for Staal deal working. Not sure the Canucks would want Hossa though. They need the cap space for D and depth up front.
 
Chicago is better off persuing Thomas or Vokoun to be honest...than to give up Seabrook for Luongo.

That I imagine though, is the type of price Vancouver would demand for Chicago of all teams to be the recipient of the Luongo sweeps. They have absolutley no reason to give Chicago any sort of discount when in one move, Vancouver would be installing Chicago as a heavy favourite to win the west for the next 4-5 years.
 
If I were Chicago I wouldn't be looking to move Seabrook. They already lost a ton on the blueline in Campbell. Not sure that is the best move for them.
 
If the price for Luongo was Schenn +... do you still do it?

I personally don't think Lou can fetch that kind of value due to his situation, but I'm sure it won't stop Gillis from asking. I think I'm at the point where I trust Burkie to do whatever the hell it takes to land Lou
 
If the price for Luongo was Schenn +... do you still do it?

I personally don't think Lou can fetch that kind of value due to his situation, but I'm sure it won't stop Gillis from asking. I think I'm at the point where I trust Burkie to do whatever the hell it takes to land Lou

Yes, I would.

And everyone on here knows how much I've defended Schenn over the past four years. We're talking about one of the most valuable players in the game.
 
Which is why Vokoun is the best move for them imo. They can afford to throw him a healthy 2-3 year deal, and it costs them 0 assets. They're also in a pretty good position to roll the dice on a guy like Harding who is just coming into his prime goaltending years and though he has question marks, has shown the ability to be above average for long stretches. If he doesn't pan out, it would be the end of the world either as their core is still young enough to be competitive in 2-3 years. They have a pretty lengthy window to compete for the cup within.
 
Yes, I would.

And everyone on here knows how much I've defended Schenn over the past four years. We're talking about one of the most valuable players in the game.


If it came down to it, yeah. I'd be forced to say yes as well. You just look at where our assets stack up...I like Schenn a lot and think he's going to be a very, very good shut down defender when he's matured...but:

Phaneuf, Gardiner,Gunner, Franson, Blacker, Percy, Holzer..and potentially whatever we draft at the 5...we're not short on good young or prospect defenders.

To finally address the biggest hole the organization has had since Eddie...yeah, I'd pull the trigger on that. Don't think it should cost that much...but push come to shove...yeah
 
If it came down to it, yeah. I'd be forced to say yes as well. You just look at where our assets stack up...I like Schenn a lot and think he's going to be a very, very good shut down defender when he's matured...but:

Phaneuf, Gardiner,Gunner, Franson, Blacker, Percy, Holzer..and potentially whatever we draft at the 5...we're not short on good young or prospect defenders.

To finally address the biggest hole the organization has had since Eddie...yeah, I'd pull the trigger on that. Don't think it should cost that much...but push come to shove...yeah

Well ideally it doesn't, but in terms of the context of the situation, if Gillis is insistent on Burke/Nonis including a young asset like Schenn into the deal in order to guarantee that it seals things up, would anyone on here truly be opposed to that prospect?
 
If I were Chicago I wouldn't be looking to move Seabrook. They already lost a ton on the blueline in Campbell. Not sure that is the best move for them.

I would only move Seabrook in a deal for someone like Staal, if i was confident we could use our cap money for Ryan Suter.

Hawks have a ton of cap and willingness to give out a crazy deal problem is our needs of G and C is not where free agency is strong, its why i would consider moving Hossa ( and signing Parise) or Seabrook ( and signing Suter)
 
Back
Top