• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

i think that some players available at 5 can be as well, and won't require the leafs to sign them to an extension under the pretense that they're 70-80 point players before they actually produce that.... and who won't also cost the team luke schenn in the process.
 
You wouldn't give up that package unless you think Staal can be a 70-80 point player.

I think he can be.

I believe that Alex Galchenyuk or Mikhail Grigorenko can be that type of player within a similar time frame. And they would not cost the assets required to acquire Staal in the hopes that he might rise above being a 50 point guy (albeit elite defensively).
 
Nobody is going to give you a 23 year old, proven 70-80 point player for the 5th overall pick.

And Schenn isn't a stumbling block in getting the player I want.

That's poor asset management though.

A lot of teams like Schenn and feel that he can be an impact player for them on defence. Why would you throw away that asset for minimal value? The fifth for Staal is already somewhat disproportionate, let alone including another recent fifth overall pick that has played four seasons in the NHL already.
 
Well it does matter, because if you draft them you have 5-7 years of them at a reasonable price, as opposed to Staal who has 1.

But you can use the same argument with Kessel.

Should have kept the picks instead of paying Kessel 5 mill.

I will take the sure thing most of the time, even it costs me a little more.
 
But you can use the same argument with Kessel.

Should have kept the picks instead of paying Kessel 5 mill.

I will take the sure thing most of the time, even it costs me a little more.

Well there is two pretty big differences there. One Kessel is a hell of a lot better than Staal. Two, the Leafs didn't know they were trading top picks.

And Staal isn't a sure thing. You are trading for him on the premise that he has a lot of room to grow offensively. And frankly, I don't see it.

Like I said earlier, I would trade that pick for a star player like Kessel.
 
But you can use the same argument with Kessel.

Should have kept the picks instead of paying Kessel 5 mill.

I will take the sure thing most of the time, even it costs me a little more.

Phil Kessel had previously demonstrated high-end potential at the age of 21 that illustrated he had the proven capacity to be a future impact player (his solid first two playoff runs helped too). What has Jordan Staal displayed offensively that leads one to conclude he is worth a highly-regarded young defenceman and a potential 70-80 point draft pick himself?
 
That's poor asset management though.

A lot of teams like Schenn and feel that he can be an impact player for them on defence. Why would you throw away that asset for minimal value? The fifth for Staal is already somewhat disproportionate, let alone including another recent fifth overall pick that has played four seasons in the NHL already.

I don't think the Pens would trade Staal straight up for 5th though.

Because they know, they would be just hoping to get a player as good or better than Staal.
 
Phil Kessel had previously demonstrated high-end potential at the age of 21 that illustrated he had the proven capacity to be a future impact player (his solid first two playoff runs helped too). What has Jordan Staal displayed offensively that leads one to conclude he is worth a highly-regarded young defenceman and a potential 70-80 point draft pick himself?

Staal showed 35/70 potential this season.
 
Staal was only a PPG player in junior, so I have concerns about his long-term offensive upside. He was drafted as high as he was because of his size, athleticism, and combine performance metrics that were off the freaking charts. He's always been overrated based on what people deem his potential to be, not what he has produced to date.
 
Well there is two pretty big differences there. One Kessel is a hell of a lot better than Staal. Two, the Leafs didn't know they were trading top picks.

And Staal isn't a sure thing. You are trading for him on the premise that he has a lot of room to grow offensively. And frankly, I don't see it.

Like I said earlier, I would trade that pick for a star player like Kessel.

I don't know if Kessel is a lot better. He's better offensively for sure. But when you factor in size, defensive ability and position scarcity (C) -- the gap is a lot smaller.
 
I don't know, the Leafs gave up picks for a similar aged Kessel, who also wasn't a proven 70-80 point guy.

Whether you draft them or trade for them...it doesn't really matter to me.

imo it does matter. a team like chicago is a good reason why. same with anaheim when they won.

there is just no understating the benefit of having front end players not earning front end money.
 
I don't know if Kessel is a lot better. He's better offensively for sure. But when you factor in size, defensive ability and position scarcity (C) -- the gap is a lot smaller.

I actually don't agree with this either.

There are many fewer elite right wingers in hockey right now (Kessel, Gaborik, St. Louis, Kane, and Eberle are really the only truly elite ones presently) than there are elite centres (of which there are up to fifteen).
 
I don't agree with that at all. Kessel is an elite player. Staal is a super elite 2nd liner.

Eric Staal. Getzalf. Sure. Jordan Staal? pass. At least for the #5.
 
imo it does matter. a team like chicago is a good reason why. same with anaheim when they won.

there is just no understating the benefit of having front end players not earning front end money.

There's not just one way of building a cup winning team. Boston was built almost entirely through free agents, trades and mid round picks.

Like I said, I want the sure thing over the maybe. And drafts picks are just maybe's.
 
I actually don't agree with this either.

There are many fewer elite right wingers in hockey right now (Kessel, Gaborik, St. Louis, Kane, and Eberle are really the only truly elite ones presently) than there are elite centres (of which there are up to fifteen).

The number of big, young, C's with offensive potential is not a big group.
 
The number of big, young, C's with offensive potential is not a big group.

Staal's twenty four years old already, so I'm not sure how much more of a window he should be given before we accept that he is what he has shown to date. I understand that bigger men tend to have a longer development curve but is he realistically any better than Antropov? A Selke quality two-way 60 point centre with size has a lot of value, but I'm not really sure that he has better upside than Galchenyuk or Grigorenko at this point. And we'd at least have the latter two under control for a lot longer.
 
Back
Top