• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

I don't agree with that at all. Kessel is an elite player. Staal is a super elite 2nd liner.

Eric Staal. Getzalf. Sure. Jordan Staal? pass. At least for the #5.

I wouldn't put Kessel in the Getzlaf or Staal class until he does it more than once (as much as I love him).

I think Staal is a great #2 C or good 1B C at this point, but has the potential to be better than that. And when you factor in that he has many of the traits the Leafs lack and he's young, it makes sense to me.
 
Staal's twenty four years old already, so I'm not sure how much more of a window he should be given before we accept that he is what he has shown to date. I understand that bigger men tend to have a longer development curve but is he realistically any better than Antropov? A Selke quality two-way 60 point centre with size has a lot of value, but I'm not really sure that he has better upside than Galchenyuk or Grigorenko at this point. And we'd at least have the latter two under control for a lot longer.

Staal's numbers (PPG) have gone up in each of the last 3 seasons -- from ~50 pts to ~60 pts to ~70 pts. He's shown a steady improvement.

He's still a very young guy. He's Kessel's age -- and we expect Kessel to improve.
 
Staal's numbers (PPG) have gone up in each of the last 3 seasons -- from ~50 pts to ~60 pts to ~70 pts. He's shown a steady improvement.

He's still a very young guy. He's Kessel's age -- and we expect Kessel to improve.

The only reason Staal's numbers have increased is because Crosby has only played a combined 68 games in the last two years and he received a bump in ice-time accordingly (from 19:24 to 21:21 and 20:03 respectively).
 
The only reason Staal's numbers have increased is because Crosby has only played a combined 68 games in the last two years and he received a bump in ice-time accordingly (from 19:24 to 21:21 and 20:03 respectively).

But he'd play a ton here centering Kessel and Lupul. He probably be one of the top forwards in icetime in the NHL here given he plays in all situations and he'd be playing a 1st line role.
 
We've always agreed that the Leafs need to stockpile elite talent because it's the hardest talent to acquire. Virtually the only way to do that is through the draft and with high picks (occasional Detroit quality latter-round gems aside). Do you consider Staal an elite talent?

Because quite frankly I think that Galchenyuk is a possible elite talent and I'm more than willing to take that chance.
 
Yeah and Luongo might turn out to be better than Schneider and Clark. And Neidermayer might turn out to be better than Tom Kurvers.

How about we stop giving up high picks for non-elite talent.
 
I can TELL YOU that Leafs are already in talks with Vancouver. And the first proposal from Vancouver was Gardiner and the fifth rounder this year for Luongo. And then after Burke laughed, it was for our first. He didn't laugh, and I have one message for Burke, if you trade our number five pick for Vancouvers first and second round, then he will have purged me entirely of this bizarre obsession with the MLSE Leafs.
 
Yeah and Luongo might turn out to be better than Schneider and Clark. And Neidermayer might turn out to be better than Tom Kurvers.

How about we stop giving up high picks for non-elite talent.

I don't like the chances of getting an elite player at 5 in this draft. Good, maybe very good player, but not elite.

I think at best, you will get a comparable player to Staal unless you move up to #1 or #2.
 
Back
Top