• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

We can't afford to trade them Lupul and have Kessel playing by himself again all year. We got lucky with Lupul who was supposed to be a salary dump and turned into a top-line performer. Replacing that kind of production won't be easy given Burke's moral principles on contracts.

Like I said it won't come to that. I was just making a point of how valuable Luongo actually would be to this team. Talk about not willing to move guys like Frattin and Colborne is nuts.
 
The Leafs want Jake Horton bad. Burke and Nonis went to see him twice. And lo and behold, he is American. And they like Colberg.
 
ESPN

The question is: How much will a team pay for one season of stellar goaltending. That's what suitors will have to ask when they look to trade for Tim Thomas, who is likely headed out of town with one year left on his contract. And the Boston Herald's Stephen Harris writes, "In return, the B's could get a pick or a prospect."

Now one big hint this trade will happen is that, as Harris point out, Anton Khudobin has a one-way deal next season, which means the Bruins are likely going to go with Tuukka Rask and Khudobin as their crease duo in the fall.

As far Thomas, several teams need a goalie -- the Tampa Bay Lightning and Columbus Blue Jackets among them -- but he only has one year left on his deal and he's 38. So it would make more sense for a team closer to the Cup to make the deal for him. The Lightning could be a possibility, but the Toronto Maple Leafs and Chicago Blackhawks may look this way, as well. What also makes this situation interesting is that Roberto Luongo is also on the market, but he has a long-term contract which might scare some teams away.

Roberto Luongo apparently asked for a trade out of Vancouver, Sportsnet's Nick Kypreos tweets, and his preferred destination appears to be Florida, TSN's Darren Dreger writes. That means the Florida Panthers or Tampa Bay Lightning may be his ideal destinations; we know the Lightning are looking to upgrade in goal, but it's unlikely the Panthers would want to make this move since a) they would be taking on a big contract and b) Jacob Markstrom may be ready to take over the No. 1 role.

Now, as of earlier this week, Luongo had yet to present a list of teams he'd be willing to go to. But chances are, the two Florida teams will be there, and if he really wants to get out of town, he would list the Toronto Maple Leafs and Chicago Blackhawks, since they both might look to upgrade the goalie position.
 
And Luongo is our second choice. They actually want Lindback more. Almost got him at the deadline.
 
I'd prefer Thomas over Luongo easily, but the fact it's Boston makes it more tough. They'll want to ship him out of the conference.
 
Can this team really afford to give up assets for a 1-2 year solution though.

Thomas only makes sense if you think you can with the cup next year IMO.
 
Like I said it won't come to that. I was just making a point of how valuable Luongo actually would be to this team. Talk about not willing to move guys like Frattin and Colborne is nuts.

I agree with that, not impressed with either of those two at all. Kadri at least looks to have the potential to be a top 6 forward one day.

And it's not like the Leafs have to worry how Luongo will perform under pressure in a deep playoff run. they're still trying to get to where the sens got this year, a happy to be there squad who gives a good fight in the first round. Hell, in Toronto a first round loss in a year's time will probably get Burke a contract extension. you don't need elite goaltending to be a playoff team, just good goaltending. Luongo can definitely provide that.

the problem is the contract structure and Burke will have to go back on his professed beliefs to make it happen. If he trades for Luongo's deal then what was the problem with making a competitive offer to the younger Brad Richards? I'm aware he's made a distinction between those two scenarios, but I don't see it.
 
the problem is the contract structure and Burke will have to go back on his professed beliefs to make it happen. If he trades for Luongo's deal then what was the problem with making a competitive offer to the younger Brad Richards? I'm aware he's made a distinction between those two scenarios, but I don't see it.

Yeah I agree, there is no difference. But whatever he has to tell himself to be willing to take on Luongo's contract is fine with me.
 
But that brings up an interesting point. For the last few years people have been hard on Burke for not willing to give out those kinds of deals to guys like Kovalchuk and Richards, saying his "principles" are hurting the team.

But now all of a sudden that Luongo is a possibility those contracts are bad?
 
But that brings up an interesting point. For the last few years people have been hard on Burke for not willing to give out those kinds of deals to guys like Kovalchuk and Richards, saying his "principles" are hurting the team.

But now all of a sudden that Luongo is a possibility those contracts are bad?
To be fair, people have been critical of Burke for not being willing to hand these deals out to young, in their prime players like Kovalchuk. A 33 year-old goaltender signed for another 10 years is a different ball game.

Still, while I hate the contract and am relatively unenthusiastic about Luongo, I've come around to accepting that he's a guy we should go after. However, at no point in the process should we lose sight of just how bad his contract is, and the magnitude of the gamble we'd be taking by acquiring a 33 goaltender that's signed for as long as he is, and paid as much as he is. If he starts running into the kind of groin problems JS Giguere and Tomas Vokoun have within the first couple of years, acquiring him could end up being an unmitigated disaster. On the flip side, he could end up being a repeat of Dallas's acquisition of Ed Belfour. So, what we give up should reflect the risk that's being taken, and the enormous service we'd be doing to Vancouver by taking that contract off their hands and clearing the way for Schneider.

As well, if the trade talks for Luongo start turning into a bidding war with Vancouver asking for extremely valuable trade chips in return, the Leafs should bow out of the process.
 
To be fair, people have been critical of Burke for not being willing to hand these deals out to young, in their prime players like Kovalchuk. A 33 year-old goaltender signed for another 10 years is a different ball game.

He was 30 and "in his prime" when he signed the deal though. A year younger than Richards when he signed his, and two years older than Kovy when he signed his deal that is 5 years longer.

These guys get older and are still signed for a long time. Thats how it works. If the contract is good in year 1, how can it be bad in year 3?

If the Richards contract was a smart one to give out, then it'll still be a good deal when he is 33. If its not, then it was never a good contract in the first place.

Its the same ball game. Just in the 3rd inning.
 
When he signed the deal initially has no relevance to us. We won't be getting a 30 year old, we'll be getting a 33 year old signed for 10 years, and for the Leafs the deal has to be evaluated from that perspective.
 
Thats not the point. The point is that everyone is arguing that Burke should be signing these deals, and he's an idiot and hurting the team by not doing it, yet all of a sudden, 3 years in, these are bad contracts that Burke would be an idiot to take on.

Its the same contract. If it is bad now, it was always bad. And Burke shouldn't have signed guys like Kovy or Richards to these types of deals.

Its the same contract. You are just further along down the line now.

No amount of spinning can erase that blatant contradiction.'

Either these long retirement deals are great for teams, and Burke is hurting the Leafs by refusing to give them out, or they aren't.
 
Spinning? You're the one spinning like a top on this contract. First with the dubious position that we should all consider this a six year deal, and now by claiming it's exactly the same as the Richards/Kovalchuk deals.

It's not the same contract at this point. The biggest benefit of these cap circumventing retirement deals is the years you get at the beginning of the deal, when you've got a player in their prime with an artificially low cap hit. The trade-off for those years at the beginning is all the years that are piled at the end to keep the cap hit low.

So with the deal as it stands right now, we'd be getting a player who has already burned off two valuable years from the beginning of the contract and is now a fair bit older than either Kovalchuk or Richards when they signed their deals. He also plays a position (goalie) and a style (butterfly) that makes players far more susceptible to chronic, debilitating injuries in the age bracket he's entering than either a center or a scoring winner.

Now, all of this is not necessarily justification for NOT doing the deal, but they are valid reasons for why we should be a lot more cautious about acquiring this contract than signing the other two, and why paying the Canucks any significant price for Luongo should simply not be an option.
 
If these contracts lose their value so quickly, then Burke is brilliant for not wanting to sign them and everyone else are a bunch of short sighted fools.

If Brad Richards contract is a bad one in 2 years, it was always a bad one. The day you sign these guys you know exactly how long the contract is, how much it costs, and how old the player is/will be. Bottom line.

Of course on the other hand, if these contracts are great and Burke is hurting the team by not being willing to hand them out...

As for spinning about the "6 year deal" thing, I just laid out the contract as it is. You were the one throwing out hypothetical changing landscapes, etc. One of us was spinning, and it wasn't me. Facts are either Luongo retires, and if he doesn't you can trade him or dump the contract in the minors.
 
Last edited:
Just to reiterate, I'm the one calling a ten year deal a ten year deal, you're calling a ten year deal a six year deal (with the added assumption that Luongo will want to retire rather than make $3.3M when he's 39), and I'm the one "spinning". Alright then. Moving on.

Every one of these cap circumventing retirement contracts is terrible. The only good thing about them is that they benefit the teams that sign them in the short term, but the trade-off is that the older the player gets and the longer into the deal you go, the more it becomes a liability for the team.

And again, as far as this deal compared to the Richards/Kovalchuk deals, if you honestly think signing a 27 year old winger until he's 42, signing a 30 year old center until he's 39 and acquiring a 33 year old goalie that's under contract until he's 43 are all exactly the same, and that none of those deals are better or worse than the other...I don't know what to tell you other than that position defies basic logic and reason.
 
My argument was never that he isn't signed for 10 years. My only argument was that the contract is easy to get rid of after 6 years because all of the way the deal is structured. Which isn't even really an argument. Its just fact. There is no NMC, the NTC comes off, and Luongo is likely going to retire anyway. You were the one spinning saying "oh well things might change."

And no there is no difference between signing a 27 year old Kovalchuck till he is 44, or a 31 year old Richards until he is 40, or a 33 year old goalie until he is 42. You have to do a hell of a lot of spinning to think otherwise. You are talking about 3 players signed until their early 40s where they aren't going to make money anymore and likely planned on retiring before their contracts are up.

Either those types of contracts are good and Burke is hurting the team by handing them out, or they are bad contracts and he isn't. The only thing that defies logic and reason is arguing on both sides of the fence.
 
Back
Top