• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Huge returns in a saturated goalie market.

We can certainly try offering Ryan Hamilton, Mike Komisarek and a 2016 7th, but odds are that all of these rumoured teams are going to offer something decent. If one good offer comes in, other teams will then have the option to top that offer, or bow out of trade talks.
 
If multiple teams are in play then absolutely they should.

1308792464976.jpg
 
The only non starters for the Leafs should be Gardiner and the 5

Schenn and Kadri should absolutely be in play if need be ( a big if, as we arent sure if Tampa can afford him, Vancovuer would deal to Chciago or if Jersey, Florida, and Columbus are real)

That said if they need to do Kadri and Schenn, you do it.

It's not about what he's worth to us. It's about what he's worth on the market. There's very rarely a reason to pay over market, and there's never a reason to pay significantly over market.

I can't stress enough how over saturated the market is. There is no appreciable short term difference between Luongo, Vokoun, & Thomas. When was the last tiem 3 of the top 5-7 goalies in the world were available at the same time? At the same time there's very few teams looking to change their goaltending situation.
 
We can certainly try offering Ryan Hamilton, Mike Komisarek and a 2016 7th, but odds are that all of these rumoured teams are going to offer something decent. If one good offer comes in, other teams will then have the option to top that offer, or bow out of trade talks.

stop being obtuse, I've never suggested anything of the sort.

Armstrong + Colborne + 2nd is approximately Luongo's market value as I see it.
 
stop being obtuse, I've never suggested anything of the sort.

Armstrong + Colborne + 2nd is approximately Luongo's market value as I see it.

That way overlooks the fact that they will be desperate to dump Luongo. You're way too generous on the salary dump and the prospect.

Frattin and Komi is more like it.
 
stop being obtuse, I've never suggested anything of the sort.

Armstrong + Colborne + 2nd is approximately Luongo's market value as I see it.

I think that's a fair opening offer. Obviously it all depends on what other teams are offering as well. I do think somebody will offer a good prospect and a 1st though, at which point our Colborne+2nd won't be enough.

There is no appreciable short term difference between Luongo, Vokoun, & Thomas.

Tomas Vokoun will be 36 going into next season, and coming off a "pretty severe tear" in the groinal region. Tim Thomas is 38.

Luongo is 33.

My take on this point, is that nobody is going to be able to fully count on Vokoun when these talks get serious early summer. One of these suitors, however, will likely trade for Thomas.
 
Last edited:
That way overlooks the fact that they will be desperate to dump Luongo. You're way too generous on the salary dump and the prospect.

Frattin and Komi is more like it.

So there are 4 or 5 teams, at minimum 3, bidding for a top 5 goaltender, hoping he will lead them to a long playoff run. And your argument, is that none of these teams, can possibly top an offer of Matt Frattin and Mike Komisarek's Albatross Contract?
 
I think that's a fair opening offer. Obviously it all depends on what other teams are offering as well. I do think somebody will offer a good prospect and a 1st though, at which point our Colborne+2nd won't be enough.

Only us and Chicago can take Lou without sending significant salary back. Chicago would have to absolutely blow our offer out of the water for Gillis to prefer dealing with Chicago over sending Lou across conferences.

I just don't see them doing it.



Tomas Vokoun will be 36 going into next season, and coming off a "pretty severe tear" in the groinal region. Tim Thomas is 38.

Tampa can afford to give him a shot, while signing another cheap option like Biron as back up. Biron >>> what they received this year.

Luongo is 33.

And guaranteed 47 million dollars in salary

My take on this point, is that nobody is going to be able to fully count on Vokoun when these talks get serious early summer. One of these suitors will likely trade for Thomas.

I agree that Vokoun is door #3 out of the 3 big names, but he also comes with the least amount of cost (compared to Lou....ridiculously significantly). With a few potentially cheap 1B options like Biron, Ellis, & Harding out there (though honestly, I see Columbus going after Harding, and over paying Harding...makes so much sense) as insurance. It would be relatively easy, and significantly less risky to get your hands on Vokoun + Biron for 4-5 million total, with only 2 years of exposure to each and be relatively sure that you're going to get ~.915 goaltending. Something like that, has Tampa's name written all over it.

Something that has to be remembered about Tampa, on top of their financial limitations is that Yzerman trained for the job at the right hand of Holland....would Holland, with limited resources, bury 47 million dollars in goaltending? Not to say that Stevie thinks exactly like Holland, but I'd be surprised if some team building philosophies didn't rub off on him.
 
Last edited:
Only us and Chicago can take Vokoun without sending significant salary back. Chicago would have to absolutely blow our offer out of the water for Gillis to prefer dealing with Chicago over sending Lou across conferences.

I just don't see them doing it.

Tampa can afford to give him a shot, while signing another cheap option like Biron as back up. Biron >>> what they received this year.

And guaranteed 47 million dollars in salary

I agree that Vokoun is door #3 out of the 3 big names, but he also comes with the least amount of cost (compared to Lou....ridiculously significantly). With a few potentially cheap 1B options like Biron, Ellis, & Harding out there (though honestly, I see Columbus going after Harding, and over paying Harding...makes so much sense) as insurance. It would be relatively easy, and significantly less risky to get your hands on Vokoun + Biron for 4-5 million total, with only 2 years of exposure to each and be relatively sure that you're going to get ~.915 goaltending. Something like that, has Tampa's name written all over it.

Something that has to be remembered about Tampa, on top of their financial limitations is that Yzerman trained for the job at the right hand of Holland....would Holland, with limited resources, bury 47 million dollars in goaltending? Not to say that Stevie thinks exactly like Holland, but I'd be surprised if some team building philosophies didn't rub off on him.

I don't know, you could make the same argument for us. Why doesn't Burke just go out and sign Vokoun+Biron? Because Roberto Luongo is a much better option. I'm having a hard time including Florida on this list, they'd probably be better off gambling on Markstrom in the long-term, Theodore in the short-term.

Luongo's contract is horrific, make no mistake about that. So it remains to be seen how many teams are going to be on both (a) the list of teams Luongo will agree to go to, and (b) the list of teams willing or able to take on that contract.

If there's only one team on that list (the Toronto Maple Leafs), then Gillis will have to show up at MLSE's executive offices with a crate of whiskey and a pair of knee pads. But you know Lou loves bold moves, and really it then depends on how serious Tampa Bay and Chicago are about adding Luongo.

It is possible we can get him for next to nothing, I just keep coming back to the probability that there are going to be at least 2 teams (and probably 3 or 4) interested in bidding. And if you decide to bid, you do so knowing you're going to have to pay more than Matt Frattin.
 
The biggest thing that would give pause is that they already have a stupid contract they hate on the blueline in Ballard.
Yeah I don't see the Canucks eating a $4+ million contract on the 3rd pairing when they already are eating one on the roster right now (though at least Ballard doesn't have even have NTC - I'm pretty sure it got "extinguished" [NTC] when he get dealt to the Canucks). A player with a bad contract on a NTC I can see but not with a NMC.
 
I don't know, you could make the same argument for us. Why doesn't Burke just go out and sign Vokoun+Biron? Because Roberto Luongo is a much better option. I'm having a hard time including Florida on this list, they'd probably be better off gambling on Markstrom in the long-term, Theodore in the short-term.

Because a financial **** up means nothing to us. Paying 6.7 million dollars to Luongo until he's 39 is a risk for a team with limited financial capabilities. It becomes a ****ing albatross to their entire hockey budget if he shits the bed at even 37 years old. Us? He gets waived and sent to the AHL if necessary. Luongo has a better chance of providing .915+ goaltending for the next 3-4 years than Vokoun/Biron would....but Vokoun Biron would come with an 8-10 million dollar total financial risk associated with them. Luongo comes with a lesser chance of busting, and a higher overall upside....but a 47 million dollar financial risk for a cash strapped team already locked into some massive long term expenditures.

Luongo's contract is horrific, make no mistake about that. So it remains to be seen how many teams are going to be on both (a) the list of teams Luongo will agree to go to, and (b) the list of teams willing or able to take on that contract.

I think it's reasonably safe to assume that the only teams that the money simple "doesn't matter" to are Chicago & Toronto.

If there's only one team on that list (the Toronto Maple Leafs), then Gillis will have to show up at MLSE's executive offices with a crate of whiskey and a pair of knee pads. But you know Lou loves bold moves, and really it then depends on how serious Tampa Bay and Chicago are about adding Luongo.

Lou doesn't flinch until Marty decides his future. Coming off of what can only be considered a good year for Marty, it's tough to bet on him hanging them up.

It is possible we can get him for next to nothing, I just keep coming back to the probability that there are going to be at least 2 teams (and probably 3 or 4) interested in bidding. And if you decide to bid, you do so knowing you're going to have to pay more than Matt Frattin.

Oh, there will be teams that bid. Hell, I'm sure Columbus places a bid...or at least tests the water. The major questions are 1) Will Luongo waive for that location 2) Can that team fire a bid that doesn't include a large salary going back (if necessary, we don't have to include any veteran salary) 3) Does Vancouver prefer cap relief and distance (eastern conference) over a "hockey deal"

Again, I'm only making assumptions...but the smart move/safe assumptions here are 1) Of the rumoured/logical interested teams he waives for Toronto, Chicago, or Tampa 2) yes, yes, no 3) Cap relief and distance (why risk running into him in the playoffs every year for the next 4-7 years)
 
Yeah I don't see the Canucks eating a $4+ million contract on the 3rd pairing when they already are eating one on the roster right now (though at least Ballard doesn't have even have NTC - I'm pretty sure it got "extinguished" [NTC] when he get dealt to the Canucks). A player with a bad contract on a NTC I can see but not with a NMC.

Capgeek has him listed as being free and clear. No NMC or NTC.

I don't see Komi interesting VanCity in the least. A team like the Islanders or another cap floor team that likes the fact he's owed 7 million in salary but constitutes 9 million in caphit over the next 2 years might take him off our hands, but that's really the only scenario that makes sense. Outside of that, he's the most expensive #7 defender in the league for the next 2 years.
 
Again, I'm only making assumptions...but the smart move/safe assumptions here are 1) Of the rumoured/logical interested teams he waives for Toronto, Chicago, or Tampa 2) yes, yes, no 3) Cap relief and distance (why risk running into him in the playoffs every year for the next 4-7 years)

If Tampa Bay absolutely has to move a contract in this deal, Ohlund's deal is tailor-made for it, and they can sweeten the offer sufficiently to make up for it. Just like I've tried to do re: Komi's contract.

I still think a Lecavalier for Luongo swap is interesting enough to make both front office's at least consider the possibility. And I think either way, Tampa is the frontrunner right now. Unless of course, we absolutely blow the Canucks away with a Frattin-Komisarek offer.
 
Back
Top