• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

I can't believe you don't see the very obvious, very clear conflict of interest at work here. In almost any professional setting, he would be expected to "excuse" himself here. Law, Medicine, Finance, Commerce, Corporate....you name a high level profession and a similar situation would have significant legal rammifications.

If this was Microsoft and Apple instead of Leafs & Habs, the lawyers on both sides would be warming up their briefs right now.

That is not what happens. You should not have used tech companies as the example. There is usually a clause in the contract that states they cannot share the information for a specific period (I believe 2 years was the standard at one major tech company I am aware of). So instead of two years it is basically 30 days.

So not only are you assuming his is guilty of sharing information you for some reason expect him to legally leave a job (not different than being fired) and not use his past work experience to his benefit.

Call it was it is. Sour grapes.
 
Hopefully, they can come to an agreement to keep Dudley until after the draft.

In terms of risk, it's really only our 2nd rounder that would be affected - in that Dudley could help them to scoop a player that Burke wants. We're all but guaranteed a good prospect in the 1st round, regardless of who Montreal selects.

Leafs don't own a 3rd or a 4th, and the later rounds are a crapshoot anyway.

Thanks for that.
 
So not only are you assuming his is guilty of sharing information you for some reason expect him to legally leave a job (not different than being fired) and not use his past work experience to his benefit.

I keep seeing people refer to information gathered while amateur scouting as "past work experience" which seems a little silly to me. It's completely ignoring the unique situation of the Entry Draft to suit your argument.
 
I think a front office guy who has been employed by another team all year and has access to drafting information should wait til after the draft to make the switch. At the end of the day, it's probably not disastrous but I can definitely see why the Leafs would fight for him to wait til the draft's over. Just a principle thing.
 
I still think we swap with Columbus and possibly try to swap that with Edmonton. Just my gut feeling.
 
NFL teams do this all the time during the year by signing a fringe player recently released from their current opponent later in the calendar week to try and gain an advantage with the game plan.

As Jays has mentioned, Dudley's draft record is shitty and the impact it could have on our draft is negligible at best. It's a dick move for sure, but nothing to get anybody's panties in a knot.
 
I think a front office guy who has been employed by another team all year and has access to drafting information should wait til after the draft to make the switch. At the end of the day, it's probably not disastrous but I can definitely see why the Leafs would fight for him to wait til the draft's over. Just a principle thing.

Agreed but to insult a man for taking a promotion is a bit much. Especially when he hasn't actually done anything yet.

And I dont recall anyone complaining about when Stevie Y did it.
 
NFL teams do this all the time during the year by signing a fringe player recently released from their current opponent later in the calendar week to try and gain an advantage with the game plan.

As Jays has mentioned, Dudley's draft record is shitty and the impact it could have on our draft is negligible at best. It's a dick move for sure, but nothing to get anybody's panties in a knot.

+1

Yeah it's a dick move and seriously lacking in terms of professional conduct, but I don't think that it can seriously harm the Leafs. If anything Dudley would just encourage the Habs to look at random big-bodied Russian gym rat with signability issues and severe attitude problems like he did during his Russian fetish phase in Tampa Bay and Chicago.

The guy thought Alex Svitov would become an MVP calibre player.
 
The problem isn't what Dudley thinks. Having him out of the process is a plus. The problem is he knows what the Leafs brass thinks and can use that information to the Leafs disadvantage considering how close the two teams pick.
 
Agreed but to insult a man for taking a promotion is a bit much. Especially when he hasn't actually done anything yet.

And I dont recall anyone complaining about when Stevie Y did it.

He was taking a Vice President/GM position, not moving from Director of Player Personnel to an assistant GM role with another team.
 
The problem isn't what Dudley thinks. Having him out of the process is a plus. The problem is he knows what the Leafs brass thinks and can use that information to the Leafs disadvantage considering how close the two teams pick.

How much does he really know though? I can't see him being the difference in Montreal taking a late round guy over the Leafs just because he has several month old information. The process is constantly changing beyond the top names. I'll wager that up until the final day before the draft and in some cases even before the GM strolls up to the microphone, there are guys that they are unsure about or a new name might pop up that everyone agrees upon. Things like that.
 
He was taking a Vice President/GM position, not moving from Director of Player Personnel to an assistant GM role with another team.
so?

you can only move up around draft time if you are becoming a GM?
Stevie Y didnt know about the draft plans on the Wings?
 
But yeah, from a professional standpoint he should seriously just say "you can have my input after the draft is completed." That would be the fairest, most professional means of approaching the situation.

Why did Montreal want him in the first place anyways?
 
It happens both ways. Ottawa didn't let Chiarelli join Boston until after July 1st.

But yeah there is a difference between being a GM and an assistant GM. A GM is obviously far more valuable, and a necessity in running a draft. An assistant isn't. The value gained from requiring your GM to run your draft probably outweighs the cost to the other team. With an assistant that isn't anywhere near as clear. If the cost to the other team, outweighs the benefit to the team taking the front office person away, equity lies in not making that move at that time.
 
The Leafs traded into the third round in 2010 two spots ahead of Detroit to grab a player that Hakan Andersson was reportedly high on.

I do think it's not really in the best interest of the organization to have front office management switch teams prior to the draft.
 
so?

you can only move up around draft time if you are becoming a GM?
Stevie Y didnt know about the draft plans on the Wings?

What do you mean "so?". Do I really have to point out that having a GM at the draft is pretty necessary and having an assistant GM is less necessary? :shocked:
 
The Leafs traded into the third round in 2010 two spots ahead of Detroit to grab a player that Hakan Andersson was reportedly high on.

I do think it's not really in the best interest of the organization to have front office management switch teams prior to the draft.

You're referring to Olden, right?
 
Back
Top