• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

I'm not even sure I'd trade Kadri for Staal.

We all give him benefit of the doubt cos he's the 3rd line center, cos he has little PP minutes.

But look at the times when Crosby and Malkin were out due to injuries, NEVER has Staal come in and performed on 70-80 points pace!
 
Staal, between Lups and Kessel would put up 70+ pts w/o breaking a sweat. (Sweating would put him over 80pts).
 
if Galchenyuk and Grigs go before our pick does anyone available have a potential to be more of an impact player then Stall?
 
[video=youtube;KQORptM6zGA]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KQORptM6zGA[/video]
 
[video=youtube;biCYAX2AVxE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=biCYAX2AVxE[/video]

Also IMO Forsberg.

Forsberg is a unknown product to me. Beyond the scouting report I know much about him

Reilly I've seen play a few times and he is going to be good but how much more of an impact beyond what Stall can make now is a question.

Personally I see Galchenyuk and Grigs are potential elite centres who are can't miss prospects. There are question makes with both but the there is no questioning the talent and abilty this guys have. If they are there to take, you have no choice but draft one.

Saying that, if they go before our pick AND we are in pursuit of Luongo as the reports suggest then I say we make a play for Staal.

Luongo's window to still put up top numbers is arguably 4-5 years, then we should expect a drop off in play (typically the norm but there are exceptions) so instead of waiting for a guy like Forsberg or Reilly to reach that level, why not try acquire the guy who is already there and is still a kid himself.

You can sit and argue until you're blue in the face about the potential Staal has or doesnt have but there is no denying that he would be a major upgrade at centre for us and would give us a guy who can do it all at both ends of the ice.

Like BG mentioned, the points will come. If Bozak can put up 50+ with those Kessel and Lupul, Staal is putting up 70+

The addition of Luongo and Staal and possibly Schultz could very well push up to making some noise in the playoffs.
 
Bozak moves the puck well though. I just don't see Staal having the playmaking ability, or offensive IQ to ever put up the 40-50 assists he'd need to be a 70+ point player.

I wouldn't acquire him under that pretense. I still like him though. He is big and is a hell of a skater and can score goals. He plays a Carlyle type game. He can play the PK, where I think the Leafs badly need some skilled players that can play there. Don't get me wrong, I'd take him.

I wouldn't trade a top 5 pick for him because I think he can be a very good first line center though.

If you are talking about a Kadri/Schenn and Kulemin kind of deal though like LA gave up for Richards? Sure. I'd hate to end up giving up a Couturier type prospect though. And I think at 5 you are 100% going to get a guy like Grigorenko, Forsberg, Galchenyuk or Rielly, all of whom I'd rather have than Staal.
 
how many times do we need to go through this learning experience? if a player is not putting up points at the NHL level, then simply changing teams and giving him better line mates will not suddenly make him a star. The odds are against that and you don't give up a top five pick to hope that you find a diamond in the rough.

I wouldn't trade Kadri for Stall, wouldn't trade the pick for Stall, nothing that has potential to be a star should be given up for Stall IMHO.
 
I'd rather have Nash. He's better.

Staal is only cheap for another year too. Then he'll get as overpaid as he is overrated. Which is a concern for me. If Grabo is making $5.5 do I want to pay $6.5-7 mill for a 60 point 2nd line center?
 
I'd rather have Nash. He's better.

Staal is only cheap for another year too. Then he'll get as overpaid as he is overrated. Which is a concern for me. If Grabo is making $5.5 do I want to pay $6.5-7 mill for a 60 point 2nd line center?

7.8 million dollars overpaid?? Not a chance.

It makes sense if you don't really want Staal but not Nash over Staal. If you wouldn't pay a 23 year old 60-70 point center 6.5-7.0 million, why would you pay a 27 year old 60-70 point winger 7.8 million?
 
Say what you about Nash, but he's just one of a handful of guys with a 5 straight 30+ goal seasons.

Toughest thing to find are goal scorers, especially young, big ones. I'm fine with overpaying for scarcity and consistency.
 
7.8 million dollars overpaid?? Not a chance.

I really don't think he is going to be much cheaper than Nash. Maybe $1.8 million max. And Nash has elite, first line talent, and Staal doesn't IMO. So yeah, more overpaid than Nash.

I'd much rather overpay for elite skill than anything else.
 
I wouldn't mind acquiring Nash but I find it really hard to give up that 5th overall knowing we'd still have no strength up the middle.

Oh I don't want to give up the 5th for him either. I don't want to trade it period, unless we are talking about Getzlaf or Weber or something like that. I'm just saying if we are going to trade it give me Nash over Staal.
 
Back
Top