• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

I feel there is a pretty solid chance that we end up with Grigs, without any movement at all.

1. Yakupov
2. Forsberg
3. Galchenyuk
4. Murray
5. Grigorenko

If Burke wants Forsberg or Galchenyuk, he needs to make a move.
 
If I thought Biggs would wind up as good as Dustin Brown, I wouldn't have a problem with the pick though. I don't.

But that is what he projects to be. A big winger/center that can skate and goes out there and hits everyone. If the difference between him and guys like Brown and Backes is that he isn't talented enough to play the PP and scores 15-20 goals and 35-40 points instead of 25-30 goals and 55-60 points I can't say I have a problem with that.
 
Yeah, he's 6 feet, but thats not the size that is important in the NHL. He's like Kadri. He doesn't have the weight. Just he doesn't have the skating to make up for it.

Yeah, exactly, you are talking about a potential Ray Whitney vs a potential Hartnall or Backes. Its not like we are talking about a front line potential player here. I know which one I'd rather have.
 
But that is what he projects to be. A big winger/center that can skate and goes out there and hits everyone. If the difference between him and guys like Brown and Backes is that he isn't talented enough to play the PP and scores 15-20 goals and 35-40 points instead of 25-30 goals and 55-60 points I can't say I have a problem with that.

I don't think trying to find Lucic 2.0 is a particularly good draft strategy. I have no problem with the Leafs going out and drafting players with size or even who play this style but typically the players like Brown and Backes showed far more skill at 18/19 than Biggs has so far.
 
I don't think trying to find Whitney 2.0 is a particularly good strategy either.

Lets face facts here. Both these prospects are limited in significant ways. To pretent like Rattie is some gem is kind of ridiculous. He's 180 pounds soaking wet and not a very good skater.

There is a reason they were 20-30 picks in a draft that had nothing after the top 10 or so.
 
Brett Hull wasn't a particularly good skater either. But like Whitney and Hull before him Rattie simply has a knack for getting in the right place at the right time. His release is NHL quality.

His ceiling is much bigger than Biggs'.
 
Brett Hull was 200 pounds and played in the 80s/early 90s.

This is exactly what i'm talking about. The list of productive NHLers who are little and aren't good skaters isn't very long. Rattie is a limited prospects.
 
I liked the Biggs pick more than the Percy pick.

Percy was a very safe pick. He's a good prospect, probably going to be 2nd pairing dman one day, but he doesn't have high end upside, nor is there anything about his game that makes you take notice. If he can become a Gunnarsson type, it will probably be a success.

With Biggs, there's more of a boom/bust aspect. If his offensive game evolves to a point where he can play on a top 2 line, he's going to be one hell of an asset because he can bulldoze people. A 50-60 point, PF type would be great value at the end of the 1st rnd.
 
I liked the Biggs pick more than the Percy pick.

Percy was a very safe pick. He's a good prospect, probably going to be 2nd pairing dman one day, but he doesn't have high end upside, nor is there anything about his game that makes you take notice. If he can become a Gunnarsson type, it will probably be a success.

With Biggs, there's more of a boom/bust aspect. If his offensive game evolves to a point where he can play on a top 2 line, he's going to be one hell of an asset because he can bulldoze people. A 50-60 point, PF type would be great value at the end of the 1st rnd.

It's funny because I actually felt the opposite about those two picks. I think Percy is a guarantee to be a Paul Martin, nice third or fourth defenceman one day. Not a star player, but then again Biggs doesn't have star potential either and to be honest I would rather have that safer, more conservative pick that looks to have a legitimate chance at being an NHL'er than the hope that a non-offensive guy suddenly starts producing offensive numbers. It could happen but I'm skeptical about Biggs' long-term offensive upside.
 
I don't think trying to find Whitney 2.0 is a particularly good strategy either.

Lets face facts here. Both these prospects are limited in significant ways. To pretent like Rattie is some gem is kind of ridiculous. He's 180 pounds soaking wet and not a very good skater.

There is a reason they were 20-30 picks in a draft that had nothing after the top 10 or so.

But the facts are that even these types of players still typically put up great numbers in the minor leagues. And the strategy isn't "find Whitney 2.0", it's the "don't pick players who can't produce in the minors and hope they will in the NHL".
 
I liked the Biggs pick more than the Percy pick.

Percy was a very safe pick. He's a good prospect, probably going to be 2nd pairing dman one day, but he doesn't have high end upside, nor is there anything about his game that makes you take notice. If he can become a Gunnarsson type, it will probably be a success.

With Biggs, there's more of a boom/bust aspect. If his offensive game evolves to a point where he can play on a top 2 line, he's going to be one hell of an asset because he can bulldoze people. A 50-60 point, PF type would be great value at the end of the 1st rnd.

Surprised at this assessment from you. Does not seem consistent with... well, anything you've ever said.
 
It's funny because I actually felt the opposite about those two picks. I think Percy is a guarantee to be a Paul Martin, nice third or fourth defenceman one day. Not a star player, but then again Biggs doesn't have star potential either and to be honest I would rather have that safer, more conservative pick that looks to have a legitimate chance at being an NHL'er than the hope that a non-offensive guy suddenly starts producing offensive numbers. It could happen but I'm skeptical about Biggs' long-term offensive upside.

What's harder to find though? A 2nd pairing dman or a 2nd line PF?

I'd take Hartnell over Martin for example.
 
Surprised at this assessment from you. Does not seem consistent with... well, anything you've ever said.

Generally, I'd go for skill above all else.

But if there's a player with PF potential, I could be swayed in that direction because these type of players are so rare and tough to get.

Very hard to find the Roberts/Tucker types.
 
Back
Top