leafman101
Well-known member
I think Rattie's offensive ceiling is significantly higher than that.
Lets be honest here. The list of midgets that lack explosive skating ability becoming high end producers in the NHL isn't very long.
I think Rattie's offensive ceiling is significantly higher than that.
If I thought Biggs would wind up as good as Dustin Brown, I wouldn't have a problem with the pick though. I don't.
Lets be honest here. The list of midgets that lack explosive skating ability becoming high end producers in the NHL isn't very long.
Lets be honest here. The list of midgets that lack explosive skating ability becoming high end producers in the NHL isn't very long.
But that is what he projects to be. A big winger/center that can skate and goes out there and hits everyone. If the difference between him and guys like Brown and Backes is that he isn't talented enough to play the PP and scores 15-20 goals and 35-40 points instead of 25-30 goals and 55-60 points I can't say I have a problem with that.
I liked the Biggs pick more than the Percy pick.
Percy was a very safe pick. He's a good prospect, probably going to be 2nd pairing dman one day, but he doesn't have high end upside, nor is there anything about his game that makes you take notice. If he can become a Gunnarsson type, it will probably be a success.
With Biggs, there's more of a boom/bust aspect. If his offensive game evolves to a point where he can play on a top 2 line, he's going to be one hell of an asset because he can bulldoze people. A 50-60 point, PF type would be great value at the end of the 1st rnd.
I don't think trying to find Whitney 2.0 is a particularly good strategy either.
Lets face facts here. Both these prospects are limited in significant ways. To pretent like Rattie is some gem is kind of ridiculous. He's 180 pounds soaking wet and not a very good skater.
There is a reason they were 20-30 picks in a draft that had nothing after the top 10 or so.
I liked the Biggs pick more than the Percy pick.
Percy was a very safe pick. He's a good prospect, probably going to be 2nd pairing dman one day, but he doesn't have high end upside, nor is there anything about his game that makes you take notice. If he can become a Gunnarsson type, it will probably be a success.
With Biggs, there's more of a boom/bust aspect. If his offensive game evolves to a point where he can play on a top 2 line, he's going to be one hell of an asset because he can bulldoze people. A 50-60 point, PF type would be great value at the end of the 1st rnd.
It's funny because I actually felt the opposite about those two picks. I think Percy is a guarantee to be a Paul Martin, nice third or fourth defenceman one day. Not a star player, but then again Biggs doesn't have star potential either and to be honest I would rather have that safer, more conservative pick that looks to have a legitimate chance at being an NHL'er than the hope that a non-offensive guy suddenly starts producing offensive numbers. It could happen but I'm skeptical about Biggs' long-term offensive upside.
Surprised at this assessment from you. Does not seem consistent with... well, anything you've ever said.
What's harder to find though? A 2nd pairing dman or a 2nd line PF?
I'd take Hartnell over Martin for example.
Surprised at this assessment from you. Does not seem consistent with... well, anything you've ever said.