Bob McKenzie seems to think he will drop past 5. Personally, I think he SHOULD be gone before our pick but if he's not there's zero excuse for us to not be all over that, IMO.
It seems to be a case of Sean Couturier all over again. If you recall last season's pre-draft projections at the start of the season he was getting a lot of press as a possible first overall selection.
Then throughout the course of the season, much like Grigorenko this season, a lot of red flags and perceived shortcomings began to be identified by the assembled scouts and team brass that went to Drummondville to watch him play, and these in turn began to make people question whether he was as good as originally thought.
Scouts began to pick apart every single short-coming in his game and magnified it to the point that his stock began to fall and he was only ranked third or fourth by mid-season. His size and skill began to be questioned or overlooked, he was criticised for lacking passion and going through the motions, for not dominating to the extent that he was capable. A mediocre World Juniors tournament followed in which he also underwhelmed relative to his lofty expectations.
When draft day came Couturier went from a surefire top three selection and even potential first overall candidate to a relative afterthought, picked all the way down at eighth by Philadelphia. Then he made the opening night roster, played hard, acquitted himself incredibly well against grown men in a physical league, did not look out of place defensively in the least bit, and made a lot of valuable supporting contributions all season long and into the playoffs (even scoring three post-season goals). It now seems absurd that he could have lasted so long, but the same thing appears to be happening all over again with Grigorenko.
I like to call it the John Tavares Factor, because he was another highly-regarded prospect who was in the spotlight for so long his flaws became magnified simply due to the overexposure. It was a case for missing the forest for the trees. Sometimes we spend so much time and effort evaluating these kids and picking apart every single aspect of their game, evaluating their fitness levels, and subjecting them to so many psychological evaluations and tests that we begin to lose sight of the obviousness of their talent levels. Extrapolating their flaws and the desire to look smarter than everyone else, to go with a non-obvious pick that bears fruit, is a temptation far too many GMs and scouts give in to on a draft day.
Just pick the most talented guys and leave it at that. This misguided notion that every single highly-regarded youngster or prospect that is available should be as well-developed as Crosby or Malkin misses the point: most of these kids are prospects in the literal definition of the term. They need to put on more weight, they need to develop their all-around games, and they need to get much stronger. They are a raw product in development and sometimes taking that raw, unfinished talent requires being patient. You're far more likely to end up with a three to four year work in progress than a Sidney off the bat that's for certain.