• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Yeah, honestly I can see Gardiner struggling a bit next year. Not that it should cause concern for anyone or anything.. but we just shouldn't be surprised to see him struggle a bit. He is human, after all.
 
Gardiner, 11/12:

Oct/Nov/Dec: 35 gms, 0 gls, 9 pts (82 gms, 0 gls, 21 pts)
Jan/Feb/Mar/Apr: 40 gms, 7 gls, 21 pts (82 gms, 14 gls, 43 pts)

Pre-Allstar: 42 gms, 1 gls, 14 pts (82 gms, 2 gls, 27 pts)
Post-Allstar: 33 gms, 6 gls, 16 pts (82 gms, 15 gls, 40 pts)



He played better as the season went on, and his role increased.
 
Lets jump in the Delorian and go back to June 2011..

Reimer is more then capable of putting up .920+ after his 1/4 season run..

We seen how that turned out. No one is disagreeing he is not capable of what you say, just don't be shocked if it doesnt happen. The slump is so common
 
Gardiner was still one of our best defensemen in the first half of the year where he struggled offensively. Even if he scores 30 points next year, he'll be an impact player for us.
 
Not this again.


Are we gonna keep using a stupid injury as an excuse for his career failures too? Why can't we ever just admit he isn't that good?
 
When we can admit that Bernier isn't that good.
What does this have to do with Bernier? He's another guy that has proven absolutely nothing and I find him extremely overrated.

But at least he has the skills to potentially be a starter one day. I wouldn't be surprised if he doesn't but I, and 30 GM's in the league, take him over Reimer every day.
 
What does this have to do with Bernier? He's another guy that has proven absolutely nothing and I find him extremely overrated.

But at least he has the skills to potentially be a starter one day. I wouldn't be surprised if he doesn't but I, and 30 GM's in the league, take him over Reimer every day.

Because it's incredibly stupid to write off anybody after 1 bad season, especially when that player has excelled in every other season prior to that, at every level.
 
How did the rumor go from Gardiner + for #1 (while specifying the '+' wouldn't be #5) to 1st overall costing us both Gardiner and #5?
 
I love Gardiner but I have a hard time ignoring the fact that historically rookies tend to struggle in their 2nd season.

I see big things for Gardiner in the future and he could very well pick up where he left off last season but I wouldn't be shocked to see him struggle offensively and niether should anyone else
 
Wouldn't be a shock to see a bit of a sophomore slump from Gardiner but I still wouldn't want to give him up to move to one if I thought Grigorenko would be there at 5 and Bobby Mac is usually pretty in touch with these things.
 
The only way I'd ever consider trading Gardiner at the draft would be if it was part of a straight-up trade for the #1 pick. Otherwise, trading him to move up four spots in this draft would be an obscene and foolish overpayment.
 
Burke needs to weigh the risks of the 4 forwards going 1-2-3-4, and how much it would cost to move into the top 4.

Getting one of Galchenyuk/Grigorenko could mean a more immediate impact on the team vs. a Forsberg/Teravainen.

I definitely think that Burke needs to move up here, even if it's just swapping picks with the Isles.

I guess any indication that the Isles would move down should indicate their interest in a defenceman, but the price shouldn't be that much - probably a mid-level prospect.
 
Last edited:
Wouldn't be a shock to see a bit of a sophomore slump from Gardiner but I still wouldn't want to give him up to move to one if I thought Grigorenko would be there at 5 and Bobby Mac is usually pretty in touch with these things.

Yak + Grigs or Yak + Murray would be damn tempting though.
 
One of the best defensive centers in the league (in my opinion) and he'd make for a flawless fit as a Carlyle third line shutdown center.

Also kills penalties, is solid in the dot, and should come relatively cheap.

100 percent agreed.

This team's third-line has been one of its major weaknesses over the past few seasons. It may sound like a minor area to be focusing on but adding a defensive stud like McClement would make the Leafs a lot harder to play against.
 
Back
Top