• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

But spending more doesn't guarantee you anything. But it will come down to Fleury because he makes the big money and he plays the majority of games. And he's been pretty average over the last 3-4 years.

Agreed, Fleury blows.....hence furtheringy argument as to why spending money on reliable elite goaltending is the way to go.

Bryz was really never that great, so it doesn't look good either way.

Again furthering my point then, as he can be removed from the sample size.


It is when your starter makes 6+ and you have one of the highest goaltending budgets in the league.

12th in SV% likely has us in the playoffs the last 3-4 years.


]There's no right answer though.


Agree to disagree.....the top end of the SV% spectrum is litered with teams that have significant $ ($5.5m +) allocated to goaltending (Nashville, Vancouver, Boston, New York, St. Louis, Minny, Calgary, Buffalo) while the bottoms feeders in SV% are the ones who went the cheap route (Toronto, Tampa, Columbus, Winnipeg, Edmonton, Chicago).

Now obviously there are anomalies like LA who developed their guys from within and haven't had to pay for their goaltending yet (which is just a year away)....or a Phoenix who went cheap and got elite goaltending. There's also teams who have spent on the wrong guys, that we're never worthy of their contracts, Fleury, DiPietro, Bryzgalov (by your estimation).....but they often were obvious poor choices when they were signed. They don't really impact the belief that spending on quality net minding, often pays off.

The evidence is pretty clear that those that spend on their goaltending, and more specifically those that pay for elite goaltending, vastly improve their chances at being successful.


I'd prefer to spend a little and use the extra cash on more predictable positions.

One of the biggest gambles one could make, and one of the most common traits amongst unsuccessful teams.
 
Last edited:
The goaltending position is so unpredictable from year to year that I'd rather spend big money on more predictable positions like forwards/defense.

Yeah, and this is a weird idea...but hear me out, you could spend 5.3 million in capspace on a guy who has been in between .913-.931 for 11 years straight, with 8 of those years being .917 or above.

Goaltending is unpredictable? Then why in the hell would you pass on one of the few predictable guys?
 
You can't pay for "elite" because "elite" changes almost every year with the exception of a couple goalies. Luongo has been "elite" in exactly 1 of the last 3 seasons. He's had 1 average season, 1 good season, 1 great season over the last 3 years.

Even the "best" goalies are unpredictable from year to year. I just don't see the value in investing all this money, when there's as much of a chance we end up like Philly, Pittsburgh, Buffalo etc as we do Nashville or NYR.
 
when there's as much of a chance we end up like Philly, Pittsburgh, Buffalo etc as we do Nashville or NYR.

No there isn't...Luongo is, and has been significantly better than Bryz, Fleury, & Miller over the last 5 seasons, and has been in the same strata as Henrik & Rinne.
 
Yeah, and this is a weird idea...but hear me out, you could spend 5.3 million in capspace on a guy who has been in between .913-.931 for 11 years straight, with 8 of those years being .917 or above.

Goaltending is unpredictable? Then why in the hell would you pass on one of the few predictable guys?

There's a pretty big gap beteen 913 and 931.

913 is average. I don't want to pay elite money for average.
 
I wouldn't have as much of a problem with Luongo if the Leafs didn't have quite a few young, cheap options internally. Lets see what we have in them first before we pay big.
 
I wouldn't have as much of a problem with Luongo if the Leafs didn't have quite a few young, cheap options internally. Lets see what we have in them first before we pay big.

You saw what they had last year...

You're like that kid who retakes the same spelling test and keeps getting the same answer wrong.

99% of people know the leafs need a goalie.
 
Part of being elite, is that when you have a down year, you still provide "average" goaltending....when cheap non elite goalies falter, they tank your season.
 
Good point. At least there are options.

If Forsberg, Galch, and Grigs are gone, I'd rather trade it to Anaheim for Ryan than get Murray or Dumba.

Or hopefully there are better options out there than Ryan that we could trade it for.

Or maybe we can just sign Parise, then use it to draft the BPA.

World of opportunity right now, including the possibility of getting Yaks.
 
You saw what they had last year...

You're like that kid who retakes the same spelling test and keeps getting the same answer wrong.

99% of people know the leafs need a goalie.

Good thing the Kings didn't think like this after Quick's rather mediocre .907 SV% season.

One season isn't nearly enough to evaluate anything, especially considering one goalie started only 11 games and the other got injured.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top