• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Doubt it. The other Habs D all had terrible +/- too (outside Gorges partner Subban) so the roster/goalie excuse is weak.
 
You underestimate how good/bad good/bad goaltenders can make defensemen look.

As I said, other Hab D played in front of the same goalie as Gorges and Gorges plays against opponents top lines. You may like Gunnarsson but to say he would be better than Gorges GA wise on the habs is absurd IMO.
 
Bullshit. You guys really underestimate Gorges who just lead the league in blocked shots and was a +14 for the 15th place squad. Gunny? -9.

Habsy, Gunnar had close to most minutes for us and one of the reasons is because he does pretty much everything well. He's not elite obviously but his positioning is textbook, he's a good passer and is very good when coming out of our zone. He's not overly physical but the way he positions himself he doesn't have to be...
 
In a surprising move, the Canucks let Marc-Andre Gragnani walk today........love to see the Leafs snatch him up, if we lose out on Schultz.


kid scored 60 points in 63 AHL games, as a 23 year old.
 
And my meaning was Gunny would be a third pair guy on any serious contender. I stick by that... for now.

Last year's President's Trophy winner is guaranteeing a spot to a rookie defenseman, albeit a very good prospect. I would think Gunnarsson would be good enough to crack their Top 6.
 
We seem to overrate our d quite a bit around here. Outside of Gardiner and Phaneuf, I'm not sure we have any top four d on the team. Gunnarsson is capable I guess, but IMO he's more suited as a solid #5. I really think that's where he belongs on a good team. Liles can certainly be top 4 based on offensive ability, but my god he's bad in his own zone. Komisarek is Komisarek. Franson is a 6/7 at this point. Holzer is probably a #6 at best..

There really isn't much there. We have a lot of d.. more than enough depth, but we're kind of loaded with #6/7 d.
 
We seem to overrate our d quite a bit around here. Outside of Gardiner and Phaneuf, I'm not sure we have any top four d on the team. Gunnarsson is capable I guess, but IMO he's more suited as a solid #5. Liles can certainly be top 4 based on offensive ability, but my god he's bad in his own zone. Komisarek is Komisarek. Franson is a 6/7 at this point. Holzer is probably a #6 at best..

There really isn't much there. We have a lot of d.. more than enough depth, but we're kind of loaded with #6/7 d.

Refreshing read.
 
Habsy, Gunnar had close to most minutes for us and one of the reasons is because he does pretty much everything well. He's not elite obviously but his positioning is textbook, he's a good passer and is very good when coming out of our zone. He's not overly physical but the way he positions himself he doesn't have to be...

And that makes him better than Gorges? Ok, agree to disagree.
 
In a surprising move, the Canucks let Marc-Andre Gragnani walk today........love to see the Leafs snatch him up, if we lose out on Schultz.


kid scored 60 points in 63 AHL games, as a 23 year old.

You see much of him when he was up in Buffalo? He was prone to terrible giveaways and at times just looked lost. At this point he is just AHL fodder, and I would much rather see one of our kids there already get the minutes.
 
You see much of him when he was up in Buffalo? He was prone to terrible giveaways and at times just looked lost. At this point he is just AHL fodder, and I would much rather see one of our kids there already get the minutes.

As a PP specialist similar to the role that M.A. Bergeron played for Tampa Bay he could be valuable.
 
And that makes him better than Gorges? Ok, agree to disagree.

I don't think he's any better or any worse than Gorges.

To be honest, you'd have difficult finding two more identical players around the NHL. They're virtual clones of one another and I would hardly describe Gorges as a third-pairing option either.

They're both second-pairing material that are tremendous assets on the PK and at ES.
 
You see much of him when he was up in Buffalo? He was prone to terrible giveaways and at times just looked lost. At this point he is just AHL fodder, and I would much rather see one of our kids there already get the minutes.

He was 23, and seeing his first significant time in the NHL.....I'm not surprised he wasn't a defensive stalwart.



His offensive upside is exceptional.....I'd be more than happy to have him as our #6 and manning the 2nd PP unit.
 
The remark was that Gunnarsson would be the best Habs defenseman goals against wise if he was in Montreal. Your stats clearly show otherwise. The remark was quantified.
 
Back
Top