• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

I think the worst thing this franchise could do is fire Burke, regardless of how this season pans out.
That's a mighty long rope you're giving the guy.

It'll be what, 5 years by the end of this season? If the guy can't turn the team into at least 8th place over that period of time then I can't believe he's keeping his job.
 
That's a mighty long rope you're giving the guy.

It'll be what, 5 years by the end of this season? If the guy can't turn the team into at least 8th place over that period of time then I can't believe he's keeping his job.

Restarting the process doesn't make us a better team....unless there's a better option available (Holland) there's no point of starting over just for perception or what fans want.

Long term success is the goal, and if I had to pick someone to give us the best chance to win from today forward, Burke would be near the top of the list.
 
Jesus, Burke had absolutely ZERO to work with at the NHL level and especially our prospect pool. Now the on ice NHL product is much better now than it was and the prospects? that speaks for itself.
I think him making the playoffs in any of the past 5 seasons would have been a bonus.
As it stands this franchise is in such better shape going forward than it has been in the last 10 years.
 
How do you guys get conned by Burke's flip flop?

Ever since he took over, everything he's said and done has been specifically to "make the playoffs"......but now, when it comes down to yet another opportunity to buy some elite talent, he suddenly starts with this "patience" schtick. come on.

The list of elite talent that has changed address since Burke took over here is immense, and yet even with a capped out roster every year Burke never even attempts to get in on it.
 
Wouldn't we rather here him say this?

"Parise and Suter are the two legit elite talents on the market, and we will do everything in our power to sign both of them this year, because they will not only make us a playoff team but will also serve as building blocks for a contender in the near future. We will find the necessary capspace by looking at every option we have with our underperforming big-money contracts."
 
I'd rather have it straight out that we are not going to sign a player then wait and be disappointed (ie Brad Richards last year), though.
 
How do you guys get conned by Burke's flip flop?

Ever since he took over, everything he's said and done has been specifically to "make the playoffs"......but now, when it comes down to yet another opportunity to buy some elite talent, he suddenly starts with this "patience" schtick. come on.

The list of elite talent that has changed address since Burke took over here is immense, and yet even with a capped out roster every year Burke never even attempts to get in on it.

This is too simplistic though with respect to his overall performance.

I think he's handled the draft and trades quite well. He's been able to add some, young, core pieces, without giving up very much. In the draft, when he's had top picks, he's drafted skill over toughness (Rielly / Kadri).

He's been a disaster though in free agency. He's overpaid for role players and he hasn't even tried to attract the elite FA's. This doesn't make much sense. And he should be attacked for this.

Overall, though, I think the Leafs are a lot better off since he's taken over.
 
As of this A.M: Schultz looks like Vancouver or Edmonton; apparently they are making the biggest pitches. No word yet of the Leafs even having a plan on meeting with Schultz.

No change on Luongo; Panthers and Leafs still there. Leafs were also kicking the tires on Tim Thomas, which I don't get at all.
 
I absolutely despise most of his UFA decisions.
I've loved most of his trades though.

If at the end of 5 years, he's brought in Lupul, Kessel, JVR, Phaneuf, Gardiner, and Luongo... that's a long way from where we came from.
 
How do you guys get conned by Burke's flip flop?

Ever since he took over, everything he's said and done has been specifically to "make the playoffs"......but now, when it comes down to yet another opportunity to buy some elite talent, he suddenly starts with this "patience" schtick. come on.

The list of elite talent that has changed address since Burke took over here is immense, and yet even with a capped out roster every year Burke never even attempts to get in on it.

+1
 
Wouldn't we rather here him say this?

"Parise and Suter are the two legit elite talents on the market, and we will do everything in our power to sign both of them this year, because they will not only make us a playoff team but will also serve as building blocks for a contender in the near future. We will find the necessary capspace by looking at every option we have with our underperforming big-money contracts."

Exactly.

I'm tired of his same old song and dance. He has acquired some nice, young, core pieces for the team, but his record is atrocious.

Not even a sniff of the playoffs after a few years at the helm, and a totally embarrassing inability to address the two biggest problems faced by the franchise - lack of adequate goaltending since pre-lockout Belfour and lack of first line center since Sundin.

Players have hit the market - B. Richards, M. Richards, Carter, Staal, Vokoun, Nabokov - that would have helped or even outright solved the problems, but in some cases, he didn't even bother making an offer. Instead, opting for cheap longshot types or scrapheap salvation projects.

Forgetting about lost opportunities, if now he went all out for Parise and Suter, and got them, he would then have a surplus of talent that he could trade to fill the spots we need. If those two guys are in the fold, Gunnar, Franson, Liles, MacArthur, and Lupul could each become available whereas right now we can't really afford to part with them.

Based on the trades he's swung, he's clearly capable of making a good deal, but maybe the problem we're seeing with Burke is that he's all or nothing. He has to either rip the other team off in a deal (e.g., Phaneuf, Lupul, Liles, Gardiner, Kessel (he didn't think he was parting with such high picks), Colborne) or get a guy for pennies on the UFA market (MacArthur), or he sits on the sidelines. The Komi deal is really the only exception to this pattern.

Sometimes you have to give to get. And in the case of big ticket UFAs, it's always, not sometimes. Parise and Suter will get top dollar, because they deserve it, and we need and can afford them, so we should be vying for them, unless there's actually something better via trade, but we've had no indication of that.
 
Not sure how this surprises anyone....the minute he isnstituted his 5 eyar rule meant no eltie tealent was signing in Toronto...plain and simple.

At least this year he is ruling out all hope.
 
Back
Top