• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

skinny-calf.jpg
 
Doughty is no better than Phaneuf?

Yeah, ok there zekey. I don't give a damn what the stats say on that one for last year.

To use a KBism... 30 out of 30 GMs take Doughty over Phaneuf.
 
I love it personally Zeke, but are there more than 6-10 people on the board who understand wtf that all means?


...those 6-10 of us that do, should make it our mission to make them a staple of discussions around here going forward. The board as a whole has gotten a little lazy on the statistical analysis imo, the metrics improved and we remained somewhat stagnant.
 
...those 6-10 of us that do, should make it our mission to make them a staple of discussions around here going forward. The board as a whole has gotten a little lazy on the statistical analysis imo, the metrics improved and we remained somewhat stagnant.

Yeah it seems as though the quantity/quality of in depth statistical comparison/analysis has declined pretty significantly recently. Not sure if that's a product of different posters posting more regularly, vets slacking or what, but would be nice if we could get back into it for this coming season. Turned into a lot of 'I think this so I'm right' vs. 'no I think this, you're wrong', which is great and all, but clogging up threads and arguing based on subjective opinions <<< advanced statistical analysis.
 
Figure out how to eliminate the 40 plus games where Phaneuf looks like Cuthbert kept him up all night and throw out your stats to some extent. When he is on, he almost has no five on five NHL equal. He is a beast from the depths of hell.
 
I'd like people to start referring to simple, but effective statistics like goals created and offensive point shares, as a metric for player evaluation. Both statistics are well-established enough by now.
 
So, a question: how much did the stats geeks around here die inside when Brian Burke was quoted recently as saying "stats are like a lamp post to a drunk: useful for support but not for illumination"?
 
Nope, not at all.

He doesn't say disregard stats. He says use it for support.

You watch a player and draw your conclusions. The stats should only back them up, not create your conclusions for you.

Way too much of that happens around here. It's why people get fooled into thinking trash like Beauchemin is good because he plays a lot of minutes, or crap like Blake is good to keep around because he could pot some goals. Those are just two recent cases where stats did the talking, but the players were actually garbage.
 
We also don't know what "stats" Burke is referring to in that statement? Probably the basic stats like points, etc...so making any rash judgements is incredibly stupid.
 
Nope, not at all.

He doesn't say disregard stats. He says use it for support.

You watch a player and draw your conclusions. The stats should only back them up, not create your conclusions for you.

Way too much of that happens around here. It's why people get fooled into thinking trash like Beauchemin is good because he plays a lot of minutes, or crap like Blake is good to keep around because he could pot some goals. Those are just two recent cases where stats did the talking, but the players were actually garbage.

Team Canada must have gotten fooled too, because he one of the invitees to their preliminary Olympic camp.
 
If Team Canada jumped off a bridge...

The day I question my conclusions based on a couple of hundred games of watching a player just because some dimwits buy into the hype that Trashecan single-handedly won a Cup for Anaheim.

How many examples of dummies in high positions in the NHL are there? Calgary anyone? The lethal Snow Wang unit in NYI? Murray with his deals in Anaheim? The list goes on.

I'm not of the opinion that all NHL executives are smarter than everyone not in the hockey business.
 
One thing I do remember Burke saying pretty sure is that every teams needs a certain amount of production. So at least he gets it from that perspective.
Really the most important.

You can philosophize all day about how you create winning teams but ultimatley you need a certain amount of production to make it happen. It works hand-in-hand.
 
I agree fully with Burke.

Stats only tell you so much. But like in all sports there's a lot that goes on that doesn't show up on the score sheet.

If you try to build a team solely on stats you will miss out on a lot of intangibles that win you games.

Stats are great to use, but you should also be looking at character aspects as well. You need guys that will put it all on the line. Show up for every game. Have a drive to win and willing to sacrifice to get a W.

If stats were everything, then why isn't Semin signed yet..or at least coveted by half the league.
 
Back
Top