• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Komi and Army were chock full of immeasurable intangibles.

You are going to hate McClement

Theres more to sports then just stats.

And when looking to round off your roster and add 3rd - 4th line guys, Id rather have the guy who only scores 20pts in the season, but also blocks shots, finishes checks, kills penalties and is a leader both on and off the ice, instead of the guy who scores 30pts but does nothing else.
 
Yet either statistic is rarely if ever, used in your posts. (I'm also guilty of that)


If we want others to start using them, we need to start by making them as much a staple of our own posts as PPG/TOI/SV% etc...

I used goaltending point shares when arguing with cork about Anderson's value in that big debate a month or so ago, so there was that. But yeah, I'm guilty of it too.

Will start evaluating players on the basis of those stats.
 
You are going to hate McClement

Theres more to sports then just stats.

And when looking to round off your roster and add 3rd - 4th line guys, Id rather have the guy who only scores 20pts in the season, but also blocks shots, finishes checks, kills penalties and is a leader both on and off the ice, instead of the guy who scores 30pts but does nothing else.

Or who plays 25 minutes but is a turnover machine and the dumbest player on the ice at any given time.
 
You are going to hate McClement

Theres more to sports then just stats.

And when looking to round off your roster and add 3rd - 4th line guys, Id rather have the guy who only scores 20pts in the season, but also blocks shots, finishes checks, kills penalties and is a leader both on and off the ice, instead of the guy who scores 30pts but does nothing else.

But there are stats to measure all that stuff, aside from leadership.
 
Zeke jerks it to the movie Moneyball. If they ever made a Moneypuck movie centered around the Leafs he'd go blind.
 
But there are stats to measure all that stuff, aside from leadership.

People only seem to care about pts.

So even if a guy blocks 200 shots a year and throws 200 checks, if he only scores 20 pts, hes 'not as good' as the guy who blocks 20 shots a year and throws 20 checks, but gets 30pts.

Thats sorta where I was going..
 
People only seem to care about pts.

So even if a guy blocks 200 shots a year and throws 200 checks, if he only scores 20 pts, hes 'not as good' as the guy who blocks 20 shots a year and throws 20 checks, but gets 30pts.

Thats sorta where I was going..

I believe that most people would recognize the superiority of the latter player. It's the same reason Robert Svehla was a better defender than Bryan Berard.
 

Do you find something quite amusing about my statement?

It's not coincidental that those who most often decry or criticise the merits of statistics are the ones who were too lazy to even attempt understanding them in the first place. It was like pulling teeth in the baseball community just to get them to recognize simple statistics like WHIP or WAR over wins and batting average for the longest time.
 
Come on. Your reply was meaningless.

Some stats are good sometimes, but not good other times?

You're being deliberately obtuse...some advanced statistical measures are far more useful in evaluating players than other, more basic, subjective ones.

But you know this.
 
Back
Top