MindzEye
Wayward Ditch Pig
Mindzeye, you are one of the most venerated posters around here, if not one of the most irritable.
I'm flattered
But I gotta tell you, outside of this chatboard group(Leaf board) for your sake, don't refer to a 27 year old number one defenceman. You will be laughed off any discussion.
Phaneuf is considered a consensus top 20 defender in the league. Most would have a hard time legitimately naming 10-15 defenders better than Dion, even with his 2nd half swoon. I actually take your comment here as validation that I'm right. I can count on one hand how many times I've run into someone in "real life" that can discuss hockey at the usual level of this board. That I would be "laugh off" by a normal hockey fan suggests that I'm correct. Since when are you an "appeal to the masses" type? You regularly talk down to the "sheep".
Now all the stat police on this board can take out their Iphones and Blackberries and attempt to do whatever it is they do, bean counting or whatever. But Dion Phaneuf, a number one defenceman? If that is true, then the NHL is a lot more watered down than I ever imagined.
Or maybe, just maybe, you're not the talent evaluator you think you are?
For one third of regular season games, yes. He is. But what about those other two thirds? What number is that out there? A number seven?
Dion was playing at a Norris contender level for the 1st half, and was good overall, but sloppy and error prone at time in the 2nd half. The trap you're falling into is assuming that other top end defenders don't go through cycles of boom and bust over the course of a season. They just don't do it under the bright lights in Toronto and it's ridiculous hockey coverage. There are a handful of steady, elite defenders in the league. Then there's a bigger pile of great defenders that don't consistently bring their best game. Dion is firmly entrenched in that group with guys like Doughty, Yandle, Boyle, Byfuglien, Keith, Letang, etc. They're all of roughly the same calibre, it's just a personal choice on how you rank them.