Wright is a 15 HR hitter. Middlebrooks is a poor contact hitter and will be a BA liability, which counts for something, if he wants to become a regular. Lawrie has a better contact rate and walks more than Middlebrooks. Middlebrooks owns a little more power than Lawrie but Lawrie has a historically higher flyball rate, which in the cookie-cutter stadium era, compensates for a lack of power.
From that list, Cabrera, Beltre, Longo, Machado. Zimmerman is even more injury-prone than Lawrie, Headley will never hit 31 HRs again (an anomaly, just like Ellsbury hitting 32 HRs in 2011), Sandoval has weight issues and projects as a 1st baseman eventually, Seager owns a marginal skillset, Ramirez getting long in the tooth.