I agree with you on Barry, I don't think he's international calibre by a long shot, but I havent seen Rodwell do enough thus far to suggest that he should be in a senior England squad hence why I said I'd take Barry at this point in time. I have no doubt though, that Rodwell will be the better player.
Besides, in my original post, I said that most, not all, of our under 21s wont make the senior squad - Rodwell will likely be one of those exceptions (Gibbs another that springs to mind), but he still has alot of developing to do. There is an awfull lot of very average players in our under 21s. The guys who are really going to be good enough (again with a few exceptions) tend to spend very little time with the u21 squad, and are often in the senior squad with a few years of u21 eligibility left in them.
If they handle Wilshere right, and he continues the way he has been going thus far, he'll play a handfull of u21 games if that, before he is straight into the seniors.