• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

OT: Soccer thread

How many titles have Real won since Robben left?

huh.

Robben wins dutch league with PSV, then leaves and they don't win.

Robben wins english league twice with Chelsea, then leaves and they don't win.

Robben wins Spanish league with Real, then leaves and they don't win.

Robben goes to germany, and is about to lead Bayern to the CL finals in his first season.

huh.

and why was Robben shortlisted for PFA player of the year in 04-05 with Chelsea if he wasn't the best player on Chelsea?

Perhaps that's because the year that his teammate and Chelsea captain John Terry won the PFA POY Award?

:facepalm
 
hey, i'm only reciprocating for the respect you've shown for italian teams in this thread. it's quite disgusting, actually.

Actually, there's been quite a bit of respect shown for Italian clubs. As I stated on several occasions, all of Roma, Inter, AC, and Juventus are high-quality clubs that are capable of performing well in Europe on any given occasion. That doesn't mean that I don't consider the lack of depth in the rest of the Serie A problematic in any direct comparison with the EPL or La Liga. It's not an either/or proposition. The Serie A will likely always have several high-end clubs.
 
Zeke, you must have missed the part where I listed my hatred for Liverpool, Chelsea and Man Utd. I was cheering for Inter over Chelsea, and was cheering for Bayern over Man Utd. But keep spouting your pro Italy crap, without any sort of objective look at things.
 
Heh.

PFA Players' Player of the Year Award
1999–00 IRE Roy Keane Manchester United FWA
2000–01 ENG Teddy Sheringham Manchester United FWA
2001–02 NED Ruud van Nistelrooy Manchester United FPY
2002–03 FRA Thierry Henry Arsenal FWA, FPY
2003–04 FRA Thierry Henry Arsenal FWA, FPY
2004–05 ENG John Terry Chelsea
2005–06 ENG Steven Gerrard Liverpool
2006–07 POR Cristiano Ronaldo Manchester United FWA, FPY, YPY
2007–08 POR Cristiano Ronaldo Manchester United FWA, FPY
2008–09 WAL Ryan Giggs Manchester United
 
Go talk to the people at UEFA who do up the coefficient, your quarrel is with them, not me.
Number of italian teams in the final 4: 1
Number of english teams in the final 4: 0

Best Italian team (Inter) vs best english team (Chelsea)--> Inter with a fairly comfortable victory.

I just wish fiorentina didn't get screwed by the refs in the bayern draw.. a fiorentina-man u fixture would've shut a lot of man u fans up... especially since fiorentina is barely a top 10 team in serie a.
 
My personal take is that the amount of money being generated in England and Spain more than off-sets any other factor at the moment, and the quality of each league has improved significantly as a result. .

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forbes'_list_of_the_most_valuable_football_clubs

1) Milan: $1.943b - ITA
2) ManU: $1.870b - ENG
3) Real: $1.353b - SPA
4) Arse: $1.200b - ENG
5) Bayern: $1.110b - GER
6) 'Pool: $1.010b - ENG
7) Barca: $0.960b - SPA
8) Chelsea: $0.800b - ENG
9) Juve: $0.600b - ITA
10) Schalke: $0.510b - GER

ENG - 4
SPA - 2
GER - 2
ITA - 2

and in the next 5 (top-15), Italy has 2 (Roma/Inter), and ENG (Spurs), FRA (Lyon), and GER (Ham) have one each.
 
Number of italian teams in the final 4: 1
Number of english teams in the final 4: 0

Best Italian team (Inter) vs best english team (Chelsea)--> Inter with a fairly comfortable victory.

I just wish fiorentina didn't get screwed by the refs in the bayern draw.. a fiorentina-man u fixture would've shut a lot of man u fans up... especially since fiorentina is barely a top 10 team in serie a.

I would have loved a Fiorentina match-up. That would have been a gauranteed bye to the semi-finals.
 
Number of italian teams in the final 4: 1
Number of english teams in the final 4: 0

Best Italian team (Inter) vs best english team (Chelsea)--> Inter with a fairly comfortable victory.

I just wish fiorentina didn't get screwed by the refs in the bayern draw.. a fiorentina-man u fixture would've shut a lot of man u fans up... especially since fiorentina is barely a top 10 team in serie a.

Do we really want to look at the recent CL numbers again? Really?

I mean, congrats that Inter is in the Semi's...and I'm glad that they beat Chelsea...**** Chelsea. If you want to make the argument that the EPL is declining, feel free, knock yourself out. But it's absolutely beyond argument at this point that the EPL has an incredible record against the other leagues in the CL over the last 5-6 years.
 
Zeke, you must have missed the part where I listed my hatred for Liverpool, Chelsea and Man Utd. I was cheering for Inter over Chelsea, and was cheering for Bayern over Man Utd. But keep spouting your pro Italy crap, without any sort of objective look at things.

Mocking english football fans > objectivity
 
Do we really want to look at the recent CL numbers again? Really?

I mean, congrats that Inter is in the Semi's...and I'm glad that they beat Chelsea...**** Chelsea. If you want to make the argument that the EPL is declining, feel free, knock yourself out. But it's absolutely beyond argument at this point that the EPL has an incredible record against the other leagues in the CL over the last 5-6 years.
oh no doubt england has been the top league in the past 5-6 years.. all i'm arguing is that times are changing and your beloved man u aren't as good as you want to think they are.

i'm sorry but with the ridiculous style that english teams play and the fact that there is a hell of a lot more parity now i can't see england being very successful in the near future at all.
 
You haven't really proven anything, Preston. What "ridiculous" style are you referring to? Elaborate, because most English squads play entirely different styles from one another. Arsenal doesn't play similarly to Manchester United, which differs in style from Chelsea, who play a different form of football than Liverpool. You're generalizing as a whole on the basis of emotional dislike. It would be like me saying that all Italian squads play a defensive, technical style bereft of creativity simply because that's how the Italian national team operates. It would ignore the differences between Inter and Juventus, AC Milan and AS Roma. It doesn't make sense.
 
oh no doubt england has been the top league in the past 5-6 years.. all i'm arguing is that times are changing and your beloved man u aren't as good as you want to think they are.

I think they're one of the top clubs in the world, if their body of work over the last 2-3 seasons is compiled, they're probably one of the top 3 clubs in the world. I'll be the first to admit that they're lacking the explosiveness that they had with Ronaldo on the wing, but they're still a top quality club. The fact of the matter is though, that when you get to this stage in the Champions League, any team is good enough to knock any other team off. Porto won this ****ing thing a few years back if you remember.

i'm sorry but with the ridiculous style that english teams play and the fact that there is a hell of a lot more parity now i can't see england being very successful in the near future at all.

I have a hard time believing that you foresaw the rise of the EPL in the first place, so don't take it too hard if I accompany your sentiment with a boulder of salt.
 
Back
Top