• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

OT: Soccer thread

EPL will be fun this year. Big is now elite 8, any of those teams can finish in CL position really. Man U, Chelsea, Arsenal, Liverpool, City, Villa, Spurs, Everton. Should be fun.

No idea how City will trim their roster to 25 though, a lot of high paid players will be in suits more then kits
 
it was pretty dirty when manure snapped up berbatov for 30 million from tottenham 5 minutes before the transfer deadline window closed
 
Forlan is another. I don't think any of the first three listed could be considered busts at all. They've all been important contributors to the current first team squad.
 
- Der Haarg was a big member of our Champions League winning team
- Anderson was a signing for the future and his form has been up and down
- Heinze was purchased for 7 million pounds and though often injured, was quality when he was fit
- Smith was also signed for 7 million pounds, and was brought in as a reserve
- Bellion cost united 3 million pounds

Forlan definitely disappointed, and Carrick hasn't been as good as hoped.

Hardly a laundry list of terrible additions.
 
People's memories (especially when it comes to United) are awful.

Der Harg played everywhere in the double season including right back, left back and centre mid.

Heinze played on two (or three?) league champions and only was sold when Ferg paid 5M for the far superior Evra.

Anderson has been shite, but he's got one more chance this year.

Smith/Bellion are hardly big money flops, especially considering Smith broke his leg. Sorta hard to predict that one.

As for Forlan the guy scored for us whenever he played, the issue was he couldn't get enough games to really get going. Forlan scored a goal against Liverpool that is part of United lore, and anytime he got a run of 4 or 5 games he came good.

Really if you wanna slate Fergie, use Berba, Djemba(x2), Kleberson, or more importantly his pigheadedness in selling Jaap Stam.
 
[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yWtBiDuLbXk"]YouTube- Diego Forlan - Every Goal for Manchester United[/ame]
 
Der Haarg played in 8 CL games that season
Anderson was definitely a buy for the future and that future is not looking great
Bellion, Heinze and Smith were big buys at the time and left the club shortly after.. they weren't brought in to sit on the bench, that's for sure.

I didn't want to include Kleberson and Djemba-Djemba, but by that token there are also Ljalic and Tosic who i think were bought for a combined 14 million a year or two ago and will probably never put on the manu shirt again.. just didn't want to list every bad transfer.

If there was a hall of fame of soccer, fergie would definitely be in there, he's a legend and a half, but he definitely is no saint and has made his share of bad moves. He's just been able to minimize the damage of those moves with manu's financial resources where another club would go down under if a big money transfer would flop.
 
Anyways, I'm having a tough time being optimistic about Arsenal's chances this year.

If the squad were healthy, they'd have a shot, but you just know there will be a million injuries again and I think I'll be happy with a top 3 finish as much as this thought makes me cringe..
 
yeah if they cant bring in a new keeper its tough to argue against that. then again last season everyone thought they'd drop out of the top but there were there till the last month.

hopefully they get Schwarzer as a stop gap, anyone is an upgrade at this point.
 
Sir Alex recent years signings might be pretty mehh, but to be fair, over his career his good signings definitely outweighs the bad ones. Off the top of my head...

Good signings:
Schmeichel
Cantona
Sheringham
Yorke
Cole
Solksjaer
RVN
Vidic
Evra
Stam
CRon
Poborsky
Keane
Ferdinand
Rooney
JS Park

and the list doesn't even include the Fledging Flemings.

If you want to look at bad signings, look at Liverpool.
 
Sir Alex recent years signings might be pretty mehh, but to be fair, over his career his good signings definitely outweighs the bad ones. Off the top of my head...

If you want to look at bad signings, look at Liverpool.

Well I dont think anyone was arguing that Fergie's bad signings outweigh his good ones. But when you have a solid financial backing, and an at least decent eye for talent, then you should always be making more good buys than bad ones. Especially since most of those guys that you listed were guys who were fully expected to be good players by the wider footballing world, its no surprise most of them worked out. But for a manager as great as Ferguson has been (one of the best managers in the history of English/world football), his transfer record isn't great.

He still is, and always will be a **** though. Can't wait for him to retire.

As for Liverpool, its a shame Rafa is gone. He was a national joke that the Liverpool fans didn't get. He wasted all the money he was given, and then blamed it all on the owners.
 
yeah if they cant bring in a new keeper its tough to argue against that. then again last season everyone thought they'd drop out of the top but there were there till the last month.

hopefully they get Schwarzer as a stop gap, anyone is an upgrade at this point.

Yeah I'd agree. I think they'll finish top 4, largely because they have something which Spurs, Man City, Villa, Liverpool don't - Wenger.

But its a pretty frail team when the inevitable injuries start coming, and Wenger has to do something about goalkeeping.

I love seeing the kids get a run out in the cups, but I wish for once Wenger would go out to win them - it'd do alot for this team to actually win something, even if it is only the league cup.
 
Well I dont think anyone was arguing that Fergie's bad signings outweigh his good ones. But when you have a solid financial backing, and an at least decent eye for talent, then you should always be making more good buys than bad ones. Especially since most of those guys that you listed were guys who were fully expected to be good players by the wider footballing world, its no surprise most of them worked out. But for a manager as great as Ferguson has been (one of the best managers in the history of English/world football), his transfer record isn't great.

He still is, and always will be a **** though. Can't wait for him to retire.

As for Liverpool, its a shame Rafa is gone. He was a national joke that the Liverpool fans didn't get. He wasted all the money he was given, and then blamed it all on the owners.

True.

Even if the listed players (Solksjaer and Schmeichel definitely don't apply) were considered great talents by footballing world before they came to Man U, it still takes a great manager to convince them to come and work their ass off for the team.

But what I'm trying to say is that the more you buy, the more bust signings you're going to get. Happens to all managers with rich financial backings.

Barca's Pep: Chygrynskiy, Ibra (Eto'o + Cash, what was he thinking?!)

Mourinho: Tiago, Paulo Ferreira, Shevchenko (though he was pressured by Roman), Kezman.

Rafa: Too many.
 
Back
Top