• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

OT: Soccer thread

In hindsight, starting Park over Nani/Park on the wing would be a more conservative approach, and have Jones in the CM/DM in place of the ineffective Anderson.

De Gea
Evra - Vidic - Ferdinand - Smalling
Fletcher - Jones
Park - Young
Rooney - Chicharito
 
I think I like the width a Young-Nani combo presents. I think United should have set up like an away game yesterday. Get the ball out wide to speed players and counter like mad. Two strikers is always a tall ask against someone like City. In that scenario you get the best out of Ando and you still have Park/Fletcher to destroy in the middle.
 
I don't think Park would be effective in the CM / DM role, he's not too strong on the ball, and has a limited passing range. Park is at his best when deployed as wide player because of high work rate and going box to box for full 90 minutes, and he's always been great in big games and clutch situations. And I really think he would've limit the impact on Richards and Silva with his never say die attitude.
 
You're not wrong. The other option would be to slot Rooney into a deep lying role and play Chich up front. Although I'm not sure I like that either. Maybe put Carrick in-place of Park?
 
Yes, Rooney would be at his best playing the SS/AM role behind Chicharito. Chicharito's clever movement would've opened so much space for Rooney.

Carrick, completely forgot about him. He fell so far behind the pecking order in these 2 years. Fletcher, Giggs, Cleverley, Anderson are all ahead of him. And I'm not too sure I trust Carrick in such a big game.

I think Fergie should've bought in Giggs after Evan's red card to slower the pace down. You can't go full offensive mode with 10 vs 11, its suicide against City.
 
I don't mind Carrick as long as he's protected by Ando and Fletcher. And the way he moves the ball could have been a great outlet. Anyhow, we got dicked down, but we're hardly out of it and as I said hopefully this will be the catalyst to get us going again. Of course getting Welbeck and Clevs back will help as well.
 
actually I think Javi Martinez for Bilbao might be the guy come January. But we desperately need a creator in the middle of the park.
 
read this from The Score, made perfect sense re: United's midfield

http://blogs.thescore.com/footyblog/2011/10/24/kjs-epl-weekend-notebook-six-and-the-city/#more-17747
7. Forget Wesley Sneijder; Luka Modric is the player United need – Many already know my thoughts on Michael Carrick but instead of repeating here how much they miss him I will add that it is in fact the Croatian at Tottenham who they need to get, not the Dutchman at Inter Milan. Ferguson’s team need a deep-lying playmaker, who can calm things down and distribute well from deep, who also has the energy and tactical awareness to commit forward when necessary. Paul Scholes is no longer there. Tom Cleverley is but he is not the immediate answer to a team that demands European and domestic titles.

and for the person who mentioned Silva

3. Mario Balotelli and Edin Dzeko were the builders of such a deficit but David Silva was once again the architect – Many words have been spoken and written since the defeat about formations and tactics but ultimately this game was about City’s front four causing many more problems than United’s front four. Milner-Silva-Aguero-Balotelli were much more clinical and dangerous than Young-Nani-Rooney-Welbeck. The best player of them all was once again Silva who is the true space invader. This time last season Gareth Bale was already being touted for player of the year by many members of the UK press and ultimately he won the award despite a subpar second half of the season. This year’s early frontrunner won’t likely drop off in form after January and if he continues to do what he did in the run up to City’s second goal then he’ll have individual trophies and team trophies to lift come May. He is head and shoulders above the rest of the players in the league at the moment.
 
what a game that was capped off by this

2yls1gm.gif
 
Klose is now tied for the league lead in Serie A goals. Who says he's solely an international player? Guy has fit in brilliantly with Lazio.
 
Yep. The same serie a that currently has all three teams advancing in the Champions League. The same serie a that had 3rd place team Napoli heavily outplay the premier leagues top team and get an away draw. The same serie a that had Milan drawing Barcelona in Barca.

But in the end, it's the same Klose who regularly features for a top class Germany side and has put up some historic goal scoring numbers. He's a quality player and I'll never understand the underrating of him.
 
Back
Top