• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

OT: Soccer thread

BUDAPEST, Hungary -- FIFA president Sepp Blatter has asked German great Franz Beckenbauer to find an alternative to penalty shootouts.

Blatter told the FIFA Congress on Friday that soccer "loses its essence" when matches are settled by penalty kicks.

Soccer "can be a drama, even a tragedy, when we go to penalty kicks," Blatter said. "Football should not go to one to one, because when football goes to penalty kicks, it loses its essence as a team sport."

Last Saturday, Chelsea beat Bayern Munich in a shootout to win the Champions League after the German side had dominated a game that finished in a 1-1 draw after extra time.

Beckenbauer, the former Bayern captain and president, heads FIFA's Task Force Football 2014 panel that Blatter created in 2010 to improve soccer before the next World Cup in Brazil.

"Perhaps Franz Beckenbauer with his Football 2014 group can present us with a solution, if not today then tomorrow," Blatter said.

The FIFA chief later clarified his view on Twitter, writing that he did not want to scrap shootouts but believed that matches should be decided "11 v 11."

The task force has met several times, but has shown little public interest in scrapping penalty shootouts.

Beckenbauer's task force deputy chairman Kalusha Bwalya also has recent experience of a shootout.

Bwalya, a Zambian great as a player, saw his home nation win the Africa Cup of Nations in February on a shootout after drawing 0-0 with Ivory Coast.



Not a big fan on penalty kicks to decide big tournaments, but I can't think of an alternative.
 
just switch to golden goal and play till someone scores.

its not like you have to worry about it during league play or round robin stage of tourneys
 
Shootouts are gay in every single sport that they're used.

It has absolutely nothing to do with skill as a team and everything to do with luck or specialists that are particularly good at just one small facet of the game. In the NHL when you have marginal guys like Jokinen or Lander who suddenly turn into all-world studs for one event it's stupid. Soccer has the same problem and should look at scrapping them altogether. Win as a team, lose as a team. It's that simple.
 
There's a lot of running in soccer. What will happen is, as the players get tired, they will stop running and sit back, and there's no chance of a goal happening.
 
Someone will score eventually.

And if they're supposedly fit (half the time they spend their time walking around the pitch anyways) they'll be fine.
 
Just expect some 5-6 hour games.

Italy can lock teams down for a good 12-13 hours at least. When they won the world cup, they only allowd 2 goals all tournament, none from open play. One was a PK and one was an own goal.
 
Eh, it's a bit of a health hazard to have players running around for over 120 minutes. It's not like hockey where you can play for hours on end. Soccer is a vicious sport.. As badly as a game in the World Cup can be ruined by a penalty shootout, the tournament can be ruined by injuries to key players or (and I know this is extreme, but it has happened) life-threatening occurrences. There really is no alternative and it would be stupid to jeopardize the lives of these players just to change the game that has been the same and so successful for many many years.
 
How about giving power play to one team for 10 mins and switch to the other after that? 10 on 6 maybe? Back 4 and the 2 DMs! lol...You don't need to run as much cause you'll have control of the ball most of the time if you're on the PP and the defending team will sit back and do best they can for 10 mins. Penalty shootouts are really a dumb way to decide a game so i agree with that.
 
How about giving power play to one team for 10 mins and switch to the other after that? 10 on 6 maybe? Back 4 and the 2 DMs! lol...You don't need to run as much cause you'll have control of the ball most of the time if you're on the PP and the defending team will sit back and do best they can for 10 mins. Penalty shootouts are really a dumb way to decide a game so i agree with that.

This is a really creative idea. I like the sounds of it on paper.
 
Back
Top