• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

OT: Soccer thread

Cazorla going for his physical at Arsenal. Very good signing. He and Arteta could be devastating.

They are also trying to get Sahin on a loan from Madrid. Wenger showing a bit more pragmatic wisdom with these moves.
 
Sounds about in line with what I believe took place.....MLS told them it wasn't a prudent signing within their salary structure, explained why, and TFC agreed.

As Garber alluded to when he said “The league hasn't nixed that. (It) economically didn’t make sense for them. And at the end of the day it was a decision that they felt was in their best interest.”
 
"the league hasn't nixed that"

and

"the league didn't agree to the terms"



Aren't contradictory.....you're simply choosing to believe they are. I think both statements are 100% honest.
 
your claim was that TFC passed on mellberg.

you were wrong.

are they allowed to do deals the league doesn't want? Of course not. but the team and the player were both ready to do a deal and the league stepped in. that doesn't constitute passing on a player.
 
Sure it does....they turned the deal down, after MLS voiced their opinions on why it wasn't prudent.....as Garber said, it wasn't a deal that made sense for them economically and in the end made they a decision that they felt was in their best interest.

TFC doing what they felt was in their best interest, doesn't constitute MLS vetoing the deal....and given they got a player to fill the role for a fraction of the price, while keeping an open DP slot, I tend to agree with their decision.
 
Sure it does....they turned the deal down, after MLS voiced their opinions on why it wasn't prudent.....as Garber said, it wasn't a deal that made sense for them economically and in the end made they a decision that they felt was in their best interest.

Yes. They being the league. TFC and Mellberg were good to go on the contract. TFC did not turn the deal down.

TFC doing what they felt was in their best interest, doesn't constitute MLS vetoing the deal....and given they got a player to fill the role for a fraction of the price, while keeping an open DP slot, I tend to agree with their decision.

TFC's best interest was to sign Mellberg, as per the direct quote above. That was their decision.

The league decided they didn't like the financial structure, not TFC.

I know you just don't want to admit you're wrong, but this is becoming farcical. You keep on using phrases that imply this was TFC's doing, when we have a direct quote that it wasn't.
 
I actually don't view it that way.....I think they simply pointed out the lack of value in shoring up that kind of money in aging defenders when guys like DeMerit, Lee and likely even O'Dea provide DP calibre value on defense for a fraction of the price.

....but now I'm speculating as much as you boys are.
 
Yes. They being the league. TFC and Mellberg were good to go on the contract. TFC did not turn the deal down.

No, 'they' are quite clearly TFC....as Garber explicitly stated, the league didn't nix the deal.


TFC's best interest was to sign Mellberg, as per the direct quote above. That was their decision.

Clearly it wasn't.


The league decided they didn't like the financial structure, not TFC.

Agreed.

I know you just don't want to admit you're wrong, but this is becoming farcical. You keep on using phrases that imply this was TFC's doing, when we have a direct quote that it wasn't.

We have a direct quote that the league didn't nix the deal, and that it was TFc's decision....which you ignore.
 
Back
Top