• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

OT: Soccer thread

1. You know very little about the system.

2. All you do is bitch, whine and poke fun at the set up.

3. You do not support local soccer, MLS/USL etc.

Everything I hear from you is condescending BS and not helpful moving forward.
 
Last edited:
1. You know very little about the system.

2. All you do is bitch, whine and poke fun at the set up.

3. You do not support local soccer, MLS/USL etc.

Everything I hear from you is condescending BS and not helpful moving forward.
My office has Whitecaps tix so yeah I "support MLS".

Our men's national team is deserving of derision. It is a national embarrassment. We aren't top 6 in CONCACAF. I told you last October we wouldn't advance.

Me supporting the system will not change a thing.
 
1. You know very little about the system.

2. All you do is bitch, whine and poke fun at the set up.

3. You do not support local soccer, MLS/USL etc.

Everything I hear from you is condescending BS and not helpful moving forward.

On the list of reasons why the Men's Canadian Soccer team can't make the World Cup... this is about #1919356 in priority.
 
https://www.theguardian.com/football/2016/sep/13/mls-canada-american-citizens

Interesting article about the unbalanced playing field for Canadian soccer players in MLS
More interesting is this tidbit

Montagliani warns that unless a critical issue is addressed – that Canadian players are treated as equal to Americans under MLS rules – Soccer Canada may take sweeping and dramatic action to block Toronto FC, Montreal Impact and*Vancouver Whitecaps*from continuing to play in the league.

It is unfair though, that Canadian players are considered international players even when playing on Canadian based teams. What is the point in having a Academy at that point?

Also interesting is that soccer canada is looking at Australia to figure out how to make their own national league. Would make sense from a player development standpoint but how badly would saputo, MLS and whoever owns the Whitecaps be hurt from this move?
 
1. Canadians are domestics on MLS teams.
2. The nuclear options is an empty threat.
3. The Canadian leave will start in 2018 and will not have any of the current MLS teams but Ottawa and probably Edmonton are moving.
 
1. Canadians are domestics on MLS teams.
2. The nuclear options is an empty threat.
3. The Canadian leave will start in 2018 and will not have any of the current MLS teams but Ottawa and probably Edmonton are moving.

1. I will make a correction, Canadians are domestics on Canadian based MLS teams, but so are Americans. Canadians are internationals on American based teams while American players are domestic.

2. Ya, most likely. But the rules need to change, if only to make American players internationals on Canadian teams.

3.Depends on number 2. Hey, Vancouver Toronto and Montreal might like it, I don't see other teams in the Canadian league challenging those three for a while.
 
The probelm is that national designations distort the player trade market. A Canadian is "domestic" at home, but market value and ability to move is degraded because the player is "foreign" for the large majority of potential trade partners.

So why bother having Canadian players at all?
 
The probelm is that national designations distort the player trade market. A Canadian is "domestic" at home, but market value and ability to move is degraded because the player is "foreign" for the large majority of potential trade partners.

So why bother having Canadian players at all?

With this setup I'm pissed the impact spend any money on their Academy
 
1. I will make a correction, Canadians are domestics on Canadian based MLS teams, but so are Americans. Canadians are internationals on American based teams while American players are domestic.

2. Ya, most likely. But the rules need to change, if only to make American players internationals on Canadian teams.

3.Depends on number 2. Hey, Vancouver Toronto and Montreal might like it, I don't see other teams in the Canadian league challenging those three for a while.

1. I agree and have been yelling this for a while, down to discussing why TFC2 is adding players like Ben Spencer, M Davis and Akinola who are not Canadian when our development path should solely focus on Canadians.

2. The rules need to change to provide more opportunity to Canadians, I would much prefer to have more spots for Canadians available on american based teams but whatever is needed should be done. As far as the Nuclear option i'm not even sure how it could work as MLS teams are not independent entities they are simply franchises of MLS. I don't think "Toronto FC" as it currently stands could change leagues, it would be shut down and then a new team would have to be created in another league.

3. I'm not speculating when it comes to this... the MLS teams won't be leaving MLS and their USL sides also won't be joining. Hamilton, Ottawa, Calgary and Edmonton are 4 that have been confirmed to me. Regina, Saskatoon, Victoria, Halifax and Moncton are the others that have been speculated but would love to see another one GTA based.
 
Floro out

CMNT to play during both of the upcoming international windows

CPL on track

An MLS canadians as "domestics" rule will be announced before the end of the season... appears it may be a couple canadian exemptions per team but not totally clear right now.
 
Floro out

CMNT to play during both of the upcoming international windows

CPL on track

An MLS canadians as "domestics" rule will be announced before the end of the season... appears it may be a couple canadian exemptions per team but not totally clear right now.

Excellent news on all fronts. Do you have any explanation as to why MLS made the "domestic player" designation rule change so quickly? Public pressure from Toronto/Montreal/Vancouver fans?
 
It's not a quick change... it's been something people have been going after them to change for a long time. It's also not the 1st time the CSA has said they thought it would be resolved soon.

In the beginning the Canadian teams liked the rules this way because it gave them an upper hand but now it makes players who come through our academies virtually valueless on the trade front.
 
Back
Top