• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

OT: Soccer thread

Diving in soccer is hard to combat mostly because the ref has too much area to cover. NHL went to two refs, soccer might have to as well..the field is just way too big for one to always be there.

Unfortunatley, the case with soccer is that in the leagues that call stuff more often,(like Spain) the players try to take advantage. The Spanish love the free flowing soccer, so they call the interference (shirt grabbing) which should be called..but then the players just try to take advantage. In the EPL, they let them play more, more physical...but I think players get away with some stuff there and it might hurt the game the other way.
 
Football doesn't need an extra ref, it needs the linesmen to excerise more control of thier half of the pitch. They are called assistant referee's for a reason, they should be assisting the official instead of blowing offside calls.
 
Football doesn't need an extra ref, it needs the linesmen to excerise more control of thier half of the pitch. They are called assistant referee's for a reason, they should be assisting the official instead of blowing offside calls.

It is hard enough to pay attention for the off-sides..there is absolutley NO WAY they could make that work. I can see some situations in the corners with no possibility for offside..and they do sometimes make calls there..but otherwise..with the pace of the game...
 
If a player goes down for more than a few seconds he has to leave the field and cannot return for at least ten minutes. If he lays there until play is stopped he misses 20...he's obviously very hurt and for his own safety he should rest.
That would take care of some of it.

And they can start implementing retroactive fines and cards for obvious video reviewed fakes...like grabbing your head and falling to the ground when the replay shows there was no contact.
 
This isn't just a soccer thing either.

Watching basketball has become exhausting. Anytime a player drives to the net there is a foul called. +1 non-stop.

I just think both leagues need to get "tougher" and allow the players to play. When/if that gets out of hand then reining it in should be easy.
 
The problem isn't with the speed of offside its with the idiotic law as its currently written. We need to get back to the old rule and get away from this active/inactive nonsense.
 
If a player goes down for more than a few seconds he has to leave the field and cannot return for at least ten minutes. If he lays there until play is stopped he misses 20...he's obviously very hurt and for his own safety he should rest.
That would take care of some of it.

And they can start implementing retroactive fines and cards for obvious video reviewed fakes...like grabbing your head and falling to the ground when the replay shows there was no contact.

If you've ever played soccer you know that there are differences between impact and muscle injuries. An impact injury is going to put you on the ground in alot of pain, but it subsides after a minute or 2. Alot of the time, when players are on the ground holding their leg its because it actually hurts. Unless you've played you won't understand. But i agree that there is too much theatrics in today's game.
 
How is it any different than other sports, where the athletes don't lay on the ground in agony after every incident of contact?
 
The problem isn't with the speed of offside its with the idiotic law as its currently written. We need to get back to the old rule and get away from this active/inactive nonsense.

You are right on both points.

It's not really the speed so much as having to pay attention to two areas at the same time..you have to pay attention to the ball carrier and then at the same time look ahead to see if there is an offside situation. That's difficult.

And I agree on that.
 
How is it any different than other sports, where the athletes don't lay on the ground in agony after every incident of contact?

Padding?

also I've lined a bunch of games, the key is to watch the defensive line, and listen for ball to be passed. If by the time the ref hears the pass, he can see the man behind the defensive line, its obviously offside.
 
I've taken a few knocks playing in goal all my life and I can feel for some guys who go down and are in agony but I can see where Cork is coming from. I don't know how much soccer he does watch but for someone who's flicking through the channels and sees a game on, there is a lot of embellishment
 
One thing to note is I found the diving in the NHL was the worst at that point in time where it seemed it was really tough for the skilled guys to make the nice plays. I think we are seeing something similar in soccer..because in the old days, when there was more room, less tactical play/organization, less fit players...there was room and the skilled players were able to make the plays without having to wait for a foul.

I hate making major changes to the game but the key in soccer would be the offside and how you handle that to give advantage to the more skilled players
 
Having said that though, footy doesn't have much of a problem IMO.

The awesome goals that get scored game in and out are amazing...you don't see that in hockey.
 
Cracking one for 40 yards out and watching sail under the crossbar is magical. I still don't understand how some of those guys can hit the ball that hard
 
Any good players want to play in an Adult men's league? My team is looking for a few skilled players, if you don't mind coming out to a practice and showing us what you got? let me know!
 
tv #'s from yesterdays game

1430 TSN UEFA Championship Barca vs ManU = 215,000
1900 TSN UEFA Championship Barca vs ManU Replay = 140,000
Combined total = 345,000

others:

1930 CBC HNIC Chicago vs Detroit = 1,338,000

1330 SportsNet MLB Toronto vs Baltimore = 127,000

2100 TSN NBA Denver vs Los Angeles = 189,000
 
Cracking one for 40 yards out and watching sail under the crossbar is magical. I still don't understand how some of those guys can hit the ball that hard

Like this one, recently:

[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SqpbMHc5XVU[/ame]

siiiiiiiiiiiick
 
The only other thing that kills footy is way too many top leagues. Imagine if hockey had 4-5 main leagues where the best players went?
That be shitty quality.
 
If you've ever played soccer you know that there are differences between impact and muscle injuries. An impact injury is going to put you on the ground in alot of pain, but it subsides after a minute or 2. Alot of the time, when players are on the ground holding their leg its because it actually hurts. Unless you've played you won't understand. But i agree that there is too much theatrics in today's game.


I've played, and I still play...but they've got to get rid of the ridiculous diving and theatrics and I think they need to do something drastic. Hell, sometimes you lay there just to catch your breath, but just like the NHL cracking down on obstructions and sometimes getting brutal calls, if Football wants to stop this crap they have to come up with something concrete.
Even if the exacts of my idea are a little too much, I think what I'm proposing has some merit. How many times have we seen a guy writhing in agony or laying there motionless, then jumping up when the ball gets near him and he realises no call is coming.

A the very least, every video-confirmed blatant dive should be carded and fined. You have to make the threat retroactive, and I'm talking about those ones where he acts like he's been head-butted when he hasn't (not so much the dives with actual contact when a guy is embellishing a trip).
The only way to get it out of the game is to make the punishment harsh...that's why I say if they act so hurt they better get off the field for a while.
 
Back
Top