• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

OT: Soccer thread

I see what you mean, and it would certainly make the 3 leagues more entertaining. But the leagues across Europe and across the world have naturally evolved in a way, more so than, for example, the NFL, MLB, NHL etc. Its always been like that, and its part of the reason its such a popular and accessible sport. What right does anyone have to take away peoples right to watch decent quality football in their own country and their own town, just because another league is seen as a higher standard or more important.

If I was a Swedish or Russian hockey fan for example, I'd be pretty pissed off that all our best players left once they turned 18 to play in a league on the other side of the world, where you can't watch them play.

So do we expect elite players to suite up for Hull City, Lecce and Sporting Gijon instead of Bayern Munich or Lyon? If you were a TV executive at Sky or Canal Plus, what would you pay for?

The dream of an "elite" league has always crossed national boundaries - that has been alway been the issue. UEFA has tried to mitigate the potential break away of the G-14 (or whatever the number is) by effectively creating a parallel league for elite teams. It's the Champions League.

Isn't that enough?
 
I'm a fan of the idea of the Champions League, because thats your 'elite' competition, without substantially devaluing the traditions and history of the domestic leagues which have been in existence for centuries. But to suggest getting rid of teams and leagues that have been around for hundreds of years, to improve the product of a few teams is a ridiculous suggestion that missed the point of the essence and spirit of football. Thats what I was disagreeing with. Leafovic said that it could be cut down to 3 main leagues - England, Spain and Italy, to greater concentrate the talent pool. But I say, who has the right to say that those 3 leagues should be the only 3, and teams with proud traditions in Germany, Holland, France, Russia etc are no longer worth maintaining.

Also, I'm not saying that a star player should play for a small team, rather than a bigger team or vice-versa, they should play for who they want.
 
You can't compare the talent pool in hockey to that in Soccer. There's a much much much MUCH greater pool of players in soccer, allowing each country to field professional teams, and develop national team players through their professional clubs. When the player is good enough, its up to the player where he/she wants to play. In hockey, the NHL is the top league, which is why all the players want to play there. There is no top league in soccer (arguably) and players follow the money.
 
Just got my tickets for LE TROPHEE DES CHAMPIONS that will be held at the Olympic stadium on July the 25th. The question becomes will it be Bordeaux or Marseille?
 
I'm a fan of the idea of the Champions League, because thats your 'elite' competition, without substantially devaluing the traditions and history of the domestic leagues which have been in existence for centuries. But to suggest getting rid of teams and leagues that have been around for hundreds of years, to improve the product of a few teams is a ridiculous suggestion that missed the point of the essence and spirit of football. Thats what I was disagreeing with. Leafovic said that it could be cut down to 3 main leagues - England, Spain and Italy, to greater concentrate the talent pool. But I say, who has the right to say that those 3 leagues should be the only 3, and teams with proud traditions in Germany, Holland, France, Russia etc are no longer worth maintaining.

Also, I'm not saying that a star player should play for a small team, rather than a bigger team or vice-versa, they should play for who they want.

I didn't neccesarily say they should go to three, I just said its not exactly helping concentrate the talent pool..which imo would make the game even more exciting. Otherwise, I totally agree with what you said.

The elite league concept ties in to my point actually. The elite league having a league format, would basically include all the richest clubs, enabling the best talents to show their stuff NO MATTER which league they actually played in. Plus, its an actual league, not a knock-out. So we would kinda get to see over a longer course of time who the best team was.
 
Last edited:
I didn't neccesarily say they should go to three, I just said its not exactly helping concentrate the talent pool..which imo would make the game even more exciting. Otherwise, I totally agree with what you said.

The elite league concept ties in to my point actually. The elite league having a league format, would basically include all the richest clubs, enabling the best talents to show their stuff NO MATTER which league they actually played in. Plus, its an actual league, not a knock-out. So we would kinda get to see over a longer course of time who the best team was.

There was an opportunity for a euro super league a few years ago, but they didn't take it up. Its not financially viable really. For example, why would I take anything more than a passing interest in a league where my team isn't playing and has no opportunity to play? I barely take an interest in the CL now, but do so on the slim prospect that Everton might get into it. An elitle league would be cutting off the majority of a nation's footballing fan base from actively having an interest in the upper echelon.
 
Nice move for City inking Barry from Villa. If they can complete the move for Tevez they should be much improved next season. Along with Everton and the Spurs they can close the gap on the big 4
 
Spurs will never close the gap on the big 4!

The Barry one is an interesting one. Obviously City are going places, but he's often said the only reason he would have to leave Villa would be for immediate Champions League football. I don't blame him for the move, but was surprised to hear it. Its going to be interesting watching Man City over the next few years thats for sure, as it is with QPR (who got it completely wrong last season).
 
Sky Italia reports Dzeko close to signing with AC Milan. Will be really happy for him if it happens..he is a huge fan..was as a little kid growing up in Bosnia.
 
Pretty sweet win for Italy over N.Ireland this weekend.

The kids Rossi and Foggia were pretty awesome.

Italy's current squad is only good, not great - but there's a wave of pretty sick youngsters coming up. Hopefully Lippi liked what he saw after finally giving the kids a chance this weekend, and leans on them for the next WC. Too late for the confederations cup, though, as he already stocked his roster for this one with mediocre vets.
 
Back
Top