• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Super Advanced Awesomeness

zeke

Well-known member
Glossary:

FR% = Fenwick Rel%: The player's on-ice Fenwick% minus the player's off-ice Fenwick%; off-ice Fenwick% is the percent of unblocked on-ice shot attempts taken by the player's team when the player is not on the ice; also known as FF Rel%

FC% = Fenwick Competition%: The TOI-weighted Fenwick% for a player's competition

CR% = Corsi Rel%: The player's on-ice Corsi% minus the player's off-ice Corsi%; off-ice Corsi% is the percent of on-ice shot attempts taken by the player's team when the player is not on the ice; also known as CF Rel%

CC% = Corsi Competition%: The TOI-weighted Corsi% for a player's competition

OZ% = Offensive ZS%: The percent of all non-neutral zone on-ice faceoffs taken in the offensive zone



Even Strength 5v5

N.Kadri: 12:56, +8.31fr%, 50.49fc%, +9.01cr%, 51.49cc%, +9.94oz%
J.Lupul: 14:27, +9.07fr%, 50.57fc%, +8.53cr%, 51.56cc%, +1.67oz%
D.Winnik: 12:20, +8.17fr%, 49.56fc%, +9.02cr%, 50.57cc%, -11.49oz%

Notes: Elite possession numbers against solid competition, but with heavily favorable zone starts, so not quite as impressive as it looks.

M.Santorelli: 11:22, +5.56fr%, 50.98fc%, +2.56cr%, 52.04cc%, +0.51oz%
D.Clarkson: 11:26, +10.55fr%, 50.73fc%, +7.21cr%, 51.71cc%, +9.53oz%
L.Komarov: 11:36, +8.18fr%, 51.37fc%, +5.24cr%, 52.32cc%, -0.65oz%

Notes: Solid possession numbers against solid competition with fairly neutral zone starts. Solid line.

T.Bozak: 13:38, -6.33fr%, 53.79fc%, -3.53cr%, 54.61cc%, -3.14oz%
J.Vanryk: 13:12, -9.20fr%, 53.68fc%, -3.74cr%, 54.57cc%, -3.14oz%
P.Kessel: 14:39, -11.01fr%, 53.68fc%, -8.11cr%, 54.55cc%, -0.85oz%

Notes: Horrific possession numbers, but against by far the toughest competition and with unfavorable zone starts, so not quite as awful as it looks. They still need to be much better, though.

P.Holland: 8:28, -10.00fr%, 45.74fc%, -11.84cr%, 47.25cc%, -7.36oz%
B.Kozun: 7:32, -6.58fr%, 46.68fc%, -10.08cr%, 48.14cc%, +9.41oz%
R.Panik: 7:20, -13.74fr%, 46.41fc%, -20.73cr%, 48.20cc%, -2.72oz%
M.Frattin: 9:20, -5.36fr%, 41.90fc%, +8.17cr%, 42.70cc%, -22.07oz%

Notes: Awful posession numbers against weak competition with neutral zone starts. 4th line has been really bad so far. Might be time to give some other players a look here.



D.Phaneuf: 15:23, +7.14fr%, 52.04fc%, +6.40cr%, 53.00cc%, +4.10oz%
S.Robidas: 15:17, -7.92fr%, 53.15fc%, -4.87cr%, 53.50cc%, -4.34oz%

Notes: Dion has very good possession numbers against very tough competition, with only slightly favorable zone starts. He's been great. Robidas has pretty bad possesion number, but against very tough competition and slightly unfavorable zone starts. Not as bad as it looks, but droppping him down to the third pair for now probably makes sense.

S.Percy: 15:30, -1.94fr%, 51.39fc%, -4.19cr%, 52.56cc%, -20.20oz%
R.Polak: 17:10, +1.00fr%, 51.70fc%, +2.28cr%, 52.82cc%, -19.04oz%

Notes: this pair has been out and out great. Good possession numbers against good competition, despite heavily unfavorable zone starts. No asterisks on this pair's great play so far.

J.Gardiner: 16:38, +6.58fr%, 49.34fc%, +6.57cr%, 50.34cc%, +17.50oz%
M.Rielly: 14:34, +0.00fr%, 48.73fc%, +0.15cr%, 49.71cc%, +25.25oz%
C.Franson: 13:38, -7.11fr%, 48.27fc%, -8.44cr%, 50.08cc%, +5.28oz%

Notes: Jake is actually the only one who comes out looking good here. Solid possession numbers against very tough competition, though with very favorable zone starts. Franson and Rielly both have poor possession numbers against pretty weak competition, even with extremely favorable zone starts. Jake is probably not the one who should be sitting.
 
Last edited:
I might adjust those numbers to look only at "Close" situations but that's good for now.
 
mind you, that's still a big step up from being last by a country mile in both last year.
 
Team hasn't been good so far. Ranked 24th in CR% and 26th in FR%.
No surprise there ... yet we were to believe Randy would change?

Granted, it's been 4 games only, but I'm willing to bet we'll still have similar numbers, if not worse after another month.
 
James Mirtle @mirtle
Since the start of last season, a span of 86 games, the Leafs have had a better possession rate than last night only five times.

James Mirtle @mirtle
Three of those games were against Buffalo.
 
Interesting stats. I'm still not completely sold on these type of stats, but I have a question about the offensive zone starts.

It seems you have suggested that this impacts the interpretation of the possession nos. (Corsi and Fenwick). But don't the players/line's play affect where the faceoffs are taken. Yes, I know the coach often decides who goes in for an offensive or defensive faceoff, but it is also affected by a line's play (e.g., icing will result in a defensive zone faceoff where the coach can't change it).
 
hmm, i wonder.

it's really on icing that dictates a line has to take a certain faceoff though, no? nothing else comes to mind.

how many icings are there during a game?
 
And I don't think you have to be "completely sold" on those types of stats to use them.

I for one think that its becoming clearer and clearer that they are just a descriptor of team performance, and not an actual measure of individual talent. This makes comparing players on different teams near impossible, though comparing teams to each other as a whole makes sense when judging how they've played.

These stats have their limitations but i think they're very good at describing a team's performance, and at least useful in comparing teammates to each other (though you have to kind of guesstimate how the various competition factors weigh in, which makes it very tough, and the lack of a clear way to do that probably indicates a fundamental weakness in the stats when measuring individual players).
 
I need to pay closer attention to this to get a better idea.

However, the key thing is to my mind, how often are the defensive/offensive zone starts the result of a line change? Otherwise, the player and his line have contributed to where the faceoff is taken.
 
I think more and more the coaches change lines when the faceoff comes in the offensive or defensive zones. They won't let a "weak" line take a defensive zone faceoff. I could be wrong.
 
If you ask me how the team and its players did in possession, these stats very much reflect my impression of them. So it's not like the stats are a revelation (except in the case of Percy, I didn't know how good he was and how infavorable his starts were). Instead, they confirm what I believe my eyes told me.

And, given we've played 3 of 4 games at home, and Carlyle's had the last change, my first question for Carlyle, especially if I were Dubas, is "Why did you keep throwing your 1st line out there against opponent's top line? Why not use the 3rd line more as a checking line? and avoid the toughest matchup against your own top line?!"
 
And I don't think you have to be "completely sold" on those types of stats to use them.

I for one think that its becoming clearer and clearer that they are just a descriptor of team performance, and not an actual measure of individual talent. This makes comparing players on different teams near impossible, though comparing teams to each other as a whole makes sense when judging how they've played.

These stats have their limitations but i think they're very good at describing a team's performance, and at least useful in comparing teammates to each other (though you have to kind of guesstimate how the various competition factors weigh in, which makes it very tough, and the lack of a clear way to do that probably indicates a fundamental weakness in the stats when measuring individual players).

I think you are right about that. Coaching seems to me to have a big impact on these stats. Recall Maurice getting the team to fire any and everywhere ... lots of pucks directed at the opponents' net but not many wins.

And that's where I'm not sold. It has been a while and I have not spent much time researching this, but did when Mirtle was making claims about the relationship between possession and shooting percentage driving wins. I took a look at the sources he was using and they were incredibly crude regression modelling (simple linear regression). I have yet to take another look, but what I saw suggested that people were making pretty big leaps in concluding what these numbers mean. Not saying it's wrong, just that they may involve a leap of faith.
 
I think more and more the coaches change lines when the faceoff comes in the offensive or defensive zones. They won't let a "weak" line take a defensive zone faceoff. I could be wrong.

It does seem that way, but it would be good to have the numbers. For instance, does he always yank Kadri if his line ends up on the defensive zone? Carlyle seems more intent on doing this than other coaches, but it would be useful to know the frequencies of line changes for these zone starts.
 
Actually the Maurice (and Wilson) Leafs' teams advanced stats actually confirm what this board had mostly been arguing the whole time - that they were pretty good teams, with scoring depth making up for lack of first line stars, and decent defenses, that were entirely undermined by league worst goaltending every year.
 
Actually the Maurice (and Wilson) Leafs' teams advanced stats actually confirm what this board had mostly been arguing the whole time - that they were pretty good teams, with scoring depth making up for lack of first line stars, and decent defenses, that were entirely undermined by league worst goaltending every year.

This only increases my skepticism!
 
Back
Top