• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

The Official 2026 Off-Season Thread: Revenge of the Nerds

even one actually negative article would have been nice.

that could have been from when he was hired based on his disastrous calgary stint. could have been about all the disastrous moves he made here while he was making them. could have been about his disastrous handling of mitch marner. could have been after he was fired based on his disastrous tenure here.

one would have been cool.

Yup, I didn't see one that actually criticized him for a bad roster, a bad coach, etc.

Here's the Sportsnet article...


It's basically Treliving apologia while blaming the players for "underperforming".

1778003984255.png

Yes, the problem was that he couldn't trade Matthews, Marner, Nylander, Tavares, or Rielly. Not that he added pure bullshit to the roster while squandering his draft equity, but that he couldn't get rid of our good players.

Simmons:

1778004099555.png

1778004127579.png
........
1778004152590.png

No, we weren't mediocre team propped up by a few elite players and great goaltending. We were that difficult to play against, and that much of a force that just fell short.

The core issue here is that our media honestly thought that the team with red flags all over it was the best iteration so far. The nerds knew better.
 
I guess I read The Athletic too much...but you guys are right, he probably got off too easy


The Athletic guys were all Dubas fanboys, so yeah that tracks that they would shit on Treliving to elevate Dubas.

The rest of our media was tearful at Treliving's firing. It was everyone's fault other than Treliving's. Shanahan's, Dubas', The Core 4's, etc, etc. Never Treliving's and never Berube's. These muppets got exactly what they want, a front office that valued all of the things these clowns have all been screaming for since like 2017 and it led to complete fucking failure. They can't reckon that it was the stupidity of their wants that got us here, it has to be something external.
 
I guess I read The Athletic too much...but you guys are right, he probably got off too easy

Jonas Siegel was the only one in the media that ever had a bad word to say about Brad. He's the only one that's allowed to bitch about Chayka (and trust me, he is). But if you were easy on Brad and didn't blast the fuck out of him throughout his time, you lose all license to criticize any other GM of the Leafs.
 
He's probably a super nice guy that nobody wants to dump on. I'm sure most of us know guys like that at the office.
Yeah we all know the type that has a dad that is a near billionaire and you don't want to say anything negative because of the connections he may have that you may need one day.

Fucking nepo babies
 
  • Haha
Reactions: CH1
Honestly some of the average joe Leaf fans I know in real life who aren't very online I find don't even know we might lose our pick tonight bc of that Carlo trade.

But they saw the Simmons con artist thing and they're all talking about the Chayka hire.
 
Did Tre ever get heat in the press in Calgary?

No, even after he left the organization the majority of the reporting was very fact based. The CBC article was mostly this:

1778005504858.png
.....
1778005462036.png

So, organization was big sad. Here's the little bit of analysis we got:

1778005583250.png

The other articles were similar. Very fact based, Calgary front office sad, Treliving good man.

Dude left a flaming tire fire of an organization behind him and everyone cried on his way out the door.
 
Speaking of corporate owned MSM, I found it interesting that for the first time ever, TSN was blackballed by the Leafs. Sportsnet got all the post-presser interviews with Chayka and Mats. TSN got shunned. Zero access.
 
"Can you make deals with other GM's in the league?"

Like the guy we just had never made deals and when he finally did it was getting fleeced 30 minutes before the deadline.
 
Speaking of corporate owned MSM, I found it interesting that for the first time ever, TSN was blackballed by the Leafs. Sportsnet got all the post-presser interviews with Chayka and Mats. TSN got shunned. Zero access.

Bell better start looking at setting up in another city now that Eddie holds everything in Toronto if they want TSN to be worth anything. They should probably do something smart and pivot to Vancouver and work behind the scenes to get a MLB and NBA team there. They're hooped in Toronto.
 
Paused about halfway through but... I think were it not for some of the negative stories and baggage out of Phoenix if you just listened to his answers, Leafs fans would probably be pretty excited for him.

and the baggage out of Phoenix mostly seems to be made up nonsense with Chayka being one part human shield for shitty ownership and one part human sacrifice on the alter of the OBC who hated him because young nerd calculator hockey isn't played on a spreadsheet didn't pay his dues!
 
I've never seen an incoming Leaf GM have to walk the gauntlet of fire like he did yesterday. Well spoken and articulate for an extremely stressful reveal.
 
Anything less than a swift firing of Berube though will have me like 'fuck this nerd' tho.

It'll reek of Rogers/Pelley interference but ultimately yah he'll probably eat it. My hope here is Pelley desperately wants to protect his guy and backs the data-backed decision... He's already gone all-in
 
Chayka said yesterday that if Sundin doesn’t like a potential trade, he won’t do it.

I hope for you guys that Mats lets John cook
 
Back
Top